Fishwife reviews and discussion

4.5

89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vibrant, giftable packaging design
  • Consistently flavorful, high-quality fish
  • Ethical, sustainability-forward sourcing
  • Versatile, recipe-friendly selections
  • Small portions per tin
  • Occasionally dry cod texture
  • Overly smoky flavor variants
  • Inconsistent flavor intensity

Fishwife earns strong reviews for genuinely tasty, high-quality tinned seafood—standouts include Smoked Rainbow Trout, Smoked Albacore Tuna, and Fly By Jing Smoked Salmon—paired with striking, giftable packaging and an ethics-forward sourcing ethos. Reviews also flag meaningful drawbacks: small portions, frequent dryness or intense smokiness in certain SKUs (notably Campfire Cod), inconsistent flavor intensity, and a price that many consider steep for everyday use.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

219 reviews and posts

  • Love the packaging and their collaborations. Their holiday sets are a hit. If you’re just into tin fish, go to any aisle in an Asian market and you’ll find cheaper options.

  • 10/10 for pretty packaging but I really couldn't tell the difference in quality of the product inside to justify the high price.

  • Delicious! Wild-caught smoked albacore tuna was so good and I can't wait to use the tuna with additional recipes. I really enjoyed and definitely will be re-ordering.

  • High quality and SO PRETTY. The packaging is what sold me, but I mean it when I say the fish actually exceeded my expectations, too.

  • Full disclosure: I do not eat seafood. But I bought these for my boyfriend, and he says that they are the best tinned fish he's ever had.

  • Honestly, this is pretty good tinned fish. Love the fancy flavors. It's definitely more expensive than random tins you get in Portugal, but isn't the point kind of that it's different than that? A great special treat for yourself every so often when you want to turbo charge your sandwiches, salads or snack boards.

  • I got to try Fishwife at their first pop-up in LA, and I had a great time! Getting to try their fish with some other chosen items was pretty awesome, and it was a great first impression. I went with the smoked rainbow trout, and it paired perfectly with focaccia bread and butter. While I definitely prefer my fish not to be smoked, I still enjoyed it. I also really love the packaging for the tins. The little box it comes in is beautiful, and I kept mine and will reuse it to store small items in.

    Feedback

    When I am used to paying less than a dollar for a tin of fish, charging $24 for three tins is hard for me to justify the cost, especially when I prefer non-smoked fish. I do love how the fish is sustainable, so if they are able to get the price down a bit, I would love this a ton. Also, maybe add some non-smoked options.

  • I got these in a sampler box and they are STUNNING quality. A little spendy, but it's a luxury product. Great for packing on a hike or adding to a salad or charcuterie spread. For special occasions not every day, due to the price. The trout though is fire. Smokey and fresh, not oily. I might buy that one more frequently...

  • As i expected, this tinned fish is absolutely next level. The smoked rainbow trout is incredible, amazing texture, and if you are new to the world of boujie tinned fish, this will indeed surprise you. I have a couple other tins I am saving for the right moment but each one ive tried has been amazing. I cant remember what kind of fish it was but a while back I had one that had Fly by Jing chili oil in it and it was incredible. I love tinned fish <3 and I love fishwife! Great company with quality and ethically sourced fish, and cute packaging!

  • amazing quality, something for everyone, and I love the packaging!! tin fish agenda is strong

    Verified purchase

  • Fishwife is EVERYTHING to me. I came for the gorgeous branding but I stayed for the incredible taste! I’ve tried almost every type of canned fish they sell and I can assure you it’s worth every penny. My favorite way to enjoy Fishwife is tossing it into a giant salad or straight up on some fancy crackers. I could eat this every day!

  • I love everything about this brand but I wasnt a huge fan of the cod that I got from the thing drop- was a bit chewy and didn't have a strong or salty flavor (my personal preference)! I am looking forward to trying more products and hope that they a little more flavor... but they are on the pricier end (I know its for tracability etc which I love so feels worth it as a treat)

    Verified purchase

  • I knew I would love Fishwife; I'm a hot girl who loves tinned fish (lol, kidding). I was particularly excited to try the Garza collab, because I do adore the Garza olive oil. The campfire code was rich, flavorful, and a small can packs a big punch. I used the cod to create a pasta dish that Fishwife newsletter shared and despite not being a hot girl who loves tinned fish, my husband raved about it. Recipe here: https://eatfishwife.com/blogs/recipes/cod-chowder-pasta

    Feedback

    I hate how cute the packaging is, I don't want to throw it away! I couldn't incorporate this tinned fish into my regular grocery schedule, as it is a wee bit too expensive for me.

  • Incredibly delicious and clearly made with care. Ate it right out the can as suggested although their recommendations make a lot of sense... it would clearly be fantastic over pasta or any other medium. If you like canned fish, pretty much doesn't get better than this!

  • I am a sucker for packaging and as soon as this went on sale at Whole Foods I had to grab it! I've been loving the tuna in the spicy oil! I have yet to crack the salmon can! My only thing is it is a bit pricy compared to other tinned fish you will see at the store. But, when its on sale, I will always make sure to grab a few cans.

  • Not only is the packaging stunning, the fish is really high quality and flavorful. Took me a while to try FW because of the price point. I usually stick to Trader Joe's tinned fish. But this was such a tasty treat. Smeared on toast with labneh and lemon!! Excited to try the other flavors too.

  • These tinned fish are soooo good! I bought the 2023 Big Fish Pack so I could try a bunch of different flavors. The fish holds up over time and tastes so premium. The one thing I'll add is that it's pretty expensive for tinned fish, and there are still great brands at my local grocery store that I would purchase for more regular tinned fish consumption. This is a great special occasion snack!

  • THE CUTEST PACKAGING EVER. Seriously, opening up the package brought be joy. The fish is such high quality for canned fish. I love having this in my pantry for a quick meal. I either incorporate into pasta or put on toast. The tuna and salmon are my favorites <3

  • I love Fishwife! I am easily turned off by seafood if it is too fishy, but the smoked salmon I ate from Fishwife was not that at all. The salty and smoky flavors were rich and I really feel like you could tell the product made use of high quality fish. I am also a sucker for brand collabs so was excited when the Fishwife X Fly by Jing sku came out in 2022.

    Feedback

    If it were slightly less expensive I would buy more often.

  • So cool! I love the packaging so much (even came with cute stickers!) and all of the artwork of the branding. I tried the Campfire Cod and it was so tasty. I made a pasta dish with it, but I could imagine a lot of ways to eat this! I'd love to try some of their other flavors. I also think their collabs are pretty cool :)

    Feedback

    A bit pricey, so definitely a treat for me.

    Verified purchase