Fishwife reviews and discussion

4.5

89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vibrant, giftable packaging design
  • Consistently flavorful, high-quality fish
  • Ethical, sustainability-forward sourcing
  • Versatile, recipe-friendly selections
  • Small portions per tin
  • Occasionally dry cod texture
  • Overly smoky flavor variants
  • Inconsistent flavor intensity

Fishwife earns strong reviews for genuinely tasty, high-quality tinned seafood—standouts include Smoked Rainbow Trout, Smoked Albacore Tuna, and Fly By Jing Smoked Salmon—paired with striking, giftable packaging and an ethics-forward sourcing ethos. Reviews also flag meaningful drawbacks: small portions, frequent dryness or intense smokiness in certain SKUs (notably Campfire Cod), inconsistent flavor intensity, and a price that many consider steep for everyday use.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

219 reviews and posts

  • Best branding ever! Such a delight to open. Fish was really tasty too! I was so impressed with their customer service too-- I had an issue with my initial package not being delivered, and customer support was super helpful in getting me a replacement. Certainly pricey for tinned fish, but you can taste the quality. Would be great for a special picnic or lunch, or on a dinner party spread!

    Verified purchase

  • This was a great product the cod was not overly Smokey. And the online recipes were very useful

  • Love this brand – love the branding, love the product. Great flavor and feels high quality. I've tried the cod and the tuna. The delivery experience was a good one – stickers in the package and all branded materials (tape, box, tissue, etc).

    Feedback

    My husband noted that despite being locked in moisture, the cod is still a little bit dry. Wish the fun branding was carried over to the actual tin, since I placed it directly on a charcuterie board. It's a little pricey for a typical tin that I would eat regularly, but good for a special occasion. (They're also quite hard to find in-store so not a typical buy for me.)

    Verified purchase

  • I love fishwife and am willing to go bankrupt for it. First of all, it's delicious. Second, it's like the easiest meal ever. Make a quick salad, toss it in a rice bowl - whatever you do it comes together in minutes. I haven't tried any of the recipes they recommended, but it's great that those are available. I also appreciate how transparent they are about their sourcing and love love the packaging.

    Feedback

    I did find their collaboration with fly by jing to be so so. I would recommend just getting their smoked salmon and adding your own chili crisp to it. Saves you a few dollars, which can then be spent on more fishwife.

  • Even better than expected! Such a great snack. I wasn't really sure what to make with them so I just at it on a saltine cracker, which was perfect.

    Feedback

    The boxes are cute but it's such a bummer to have a boring little tin on the inside! I wish the tins themselves were designed/printed on so I could display them on my shelf.

  • Really impressed by the look, feel and taste of Fishwife. It's making canned fish seem tasty and good for the planet. Not at all like how I'd associate canned fish from growing up. The trout was especially flavorful.

    Feedback

    More varieties would be welcome.

  • This brand is truly changing the entire idea of eating tinned fish, and has somehow made it cool and trendy. The packaging is adorable, the quality of the fish is great. My only gripe is the price, but I'd still pay it.

  • Absolutely love Fishwife! The spicy tuna is delicious and has great high quality ingredients. The packaging is incredibly eye-catching, whimsical, and great to add as a gift. Highly recommend.

  • Yum yum yum is all I can say. I’ve purchased the smoked salmon in 3 different flavors, plus the tune in two different flavors (one was spicy). This brand will stay in my kitchen at all times. Their packing is also pretty damn beautiful. Tastes very high quality.

  • Fishwife has absolutely fantastic branding, I'll give them that. That being said, I've tried a large variety of tinned fish from different brands, and I don't feel that Fishwife's flavors stood out among the other options, which is disappointing considering their price point.

  • some of the best tin fish i've had! very much a splurge, the cost is a lot for what you get. cute packaging though.

  • I purchased the anchovy tin and attempted to use it as a base for flavor in a pasta recipe. The product was easy to use - the anchovies dissolved quickly and easily in the dish. However, the flavor was quite bold (bolder than I expected) and created a very strong smell in the house. I don't feel as though it really added much of anything and I will probably not use their product again as the base of a dish. It was not cheap, created a lot of extra waste and I didn't love the final product.

  • You can't go wrong keeping a few tins of Fishwife in your pantry, IMO. Yes, there are other tinned fishes out there that are less expensive (and also delicious). But Fishwife always tastes amazing and never disappoints. It's not the cheapest, nor is it the most expensive; it's generally right down the middle price-wise, but excels on delivering high-quality products. Their packaging is fun, and I love seeing the colorful boxes among our tinned fish collection. Not the tinned fish I always purchase, but the one I return to time and again when we want to feel "fancy" but not break the bank.

  • Recently tried the smoked salmon Fly by Jing collab (picked it up on sale at a local grocery store) and it was SO good. I really want to try more varieties and their packaging is SO cute I had to save it. I wish it was a little cheaper but I understand why they price it the way they do since it's ethically-sourced, etc. Can't wait to try more!

  • tried the fly by jing collab - so good, and love what the company stands for

  • Excellent for a quality meal on the go or a solo snack. I gave them to my relatives in their Christmas stockings and everyone enjoyed them. Truly excellent quality and the packaging is a fantastic bonus.

  • Highly sourced fished in cool, trendy packaging. They really hit the "tinned fish" trend on the nose.

  • Fishwife is it. This is what I like to see. Gorgeous crazy packaging that makes me feel so hot while I am eating my insane lunch over the sink while listening to a podcast episode for the 3rd time and stare out my window having ZERO thoughts. Products like this are like a little light in a cave baby. Makes normal life just a little better. Plus it is in good oil and we all know that is what takes good tin fish great. You can also like bring this to a sexy little dinner party as a gift are something and all the girlies are going to think it is cool and think you are cool which is what life is all about.

  • Awesome selection and great tasting tinned fish. The smoked salmon is insanely good. Love the sustainability model as well.

    Feedback

    Everything is great, would love to see wider availability in stores