SmartSweets reviews and discussion

3.9

72% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vivid, nostalgic flavors
  • Lower‑sugar candy formulas
  • Convenient portion packs
  • Vegan, plant‑based options
  • Extremely sticky texture
  • Inconsistent chew quality
  • Notable sweetener aftertaste
  • Potential gi discomfort

SmartSweets earns largely positive reviews as a lower‑sugar candy that satisfies cravings—standouts include Sweet Fish, Peach Rings, Sourmelon Bites, red twists, and gummy worms—while recurring complaints in reviews cite an extremely sticky, tooth‑clinging texture and occasional odd or stevia‑like aftertaste. Reviews also note inconsistent chew across flavors and batches, plus some GI sensitivity for a few users; if you want a healthier candy fix and can accept a different chew, SmartSweets is a compelling swap, but purists may prefer the originals.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,536 reviews and posts

  • While you can definitely tell that these are a healthy alternative, they make a great substitute. The sugar coating isn't my favorite as I found it has a slightly powdery texture, but I'm sure for most that wouldn't be an issue. I usually buy packs that don't have the sugar coating and love them!

  • Smart Sweets make healthier version of your favorite childhood candies. Over the years, their formulations have improved to better mimic the candies they are looking to emulate. While their large bags are consistently soft and fresh, their smaller bags have more variance. Some bags contain much firmer, almost stale candy, but newer versions have proven to improve that. Overall, the fish and ring varieties are good, but are a safer bet when purchasing in larger packs.

  • They just didn’t do it for me. I love that they are low calorie, but the flavor and craving was not satiating.

  • Tasty but not worth the money. I like the taste and consistency of the candies, but I don’t see myself buying them because it seems silly to spend that much on something with no function.

  • I love gummies, but don't eat gelatin so I was really happy to find a brand that not only offers a low sugar version but also gummies I can eat. The sour gummies are amazing.

  • I do love the taste and that they are a healthy alternative to major candy brands but man oh man do these get stuck in your teeth.

  • It's a nice treat when you're craving that chewiness. I find that there's very little flavor in the gummy to keep on munching. It's something I keep in my bag while I'm on the plane or on a trip.

  • Great and better choice vs getting the main brands. I’ve tried all the products, my favorite is the sour watermelon. It’s easily accessible and found at Whole Foods, sprouts, target and Kroger.

  • I know they use natural flavors, and let me tell you, they are absolutely delicious! It's great that you can find them almost anywhere you go. I personally grab mine from either Target or Whole Foods, and they never disappoint!

  • Honestly, I do not think its a good alternative. The texture is not it. I have a big sweet tooth and tbh i would never choose to eat these as a treat

  • Yummy and healthy - so lovely to snack on throughout the day when Im running around as a little pick me up! Perfect to throw in your purse and have on the go :)

    Friends with SmartSweets
  • yum, lots of fiber, great tasting candy, the perfect amount of sweetness

    Feedback

    dont think it will taste the same. It does taste very good but its a new taste.

  • The Sour Melon Bites are excellent. You can taste the quality and the reduction in sugar. It is noticeable and does not lack flavor.

    Feedback

    Much more sustainable packaging would be great.

  • I have a friend who is in the fitness industry and counts macros, etc. I don’t. I truly enjoy candy, however my friend tried introducing me to smart sweets as a less sugar alternative and I am absolutely impressed that I have been purchasing from this company since. I highly recommend, it’s once of those health candies on the markets that actually tastes like real candy.

  • Sugar makes me feel like garbage. Artificial junk in food makes me feel like garbage. But these treats? Even this sensitive stomach loves it. I think a lot of folks are used to a saccharine-sweet type treat, and that's totally cool! If you don't eat a lot of treats and your taste buds have adjusted, I find a few pieces of these to really hit the spot when a craving hits. They're a fixture in my life.

    Feedback

    Don't ever change the gummy worms! I'm so glad they were moved from being a Halloween-only candy to a permanent fixture.

  • I have to say, for the price they are really not that great unfortunately. If they were similarly priced to other candy then yeah they might be a nice alternative, but I cannot justify spending like $10 on mediocre gummy bears that do kind of taste like artificial sugar. I know this sounds harsh but it’s how I feel :(

    Feedback

    Make it more affordable and/or taste less artificial

  • I've only ever tried the Watermelon gummies, but I was actually so impressed. They didn't seem as overly sweet as regular gummies. One flaw--these gummies are the "sticky" kind. They don't have the gummy, chewy texture that we all attribute to the classic versions.