Italic reviews and discussion

4.6

93% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Plush, hotel-quality bedding
  • Durable, sleek luggage
  • Soft, substantial cashmere
  • Elegant, well-balanced candles
  • Inconsistent apparel fit
  • Occasionally light candle throw
  • Limited product variety
  • Frequent, prolonged stockouts

Italic earns largely positive reviews for high-quality home goods—especially sateen and percale bedding, plush towels, candles, knives, and sturdy luggage—while clothing and accessories are hit-or-miss. Reviews of Italic highlight luxurious-feeling basics and durable pieces, but recurring drawbacks include inconsistent apparel fit and quality, limited variety with frequent stockouts, occasional slow shipping, and mixed customer service experiences.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

291 reviews and posts

  • I've only used Italic to purchase stainless steel cookware, but I love it so far. I appreciate the transparency and what the brand stands for. Everything seems high quality so far. I have to go solely based on reviews to know if the claims are really legit, but no complaints so far.

  • The products on Italic aren't exactly luxury quality but they're very high quality nonetheless.

  • When Italic first started out, you had to buy a membership in order to purchase their products and that was too big of a commitment for me. Once they opened up the site for the public to purchase, I immediately bought the purse that I had been eyeing for months and it arrived wrapped perfectly and in excellent shape. The quality felt exceptional and to this day it's still holding up really nicely. Italic also has a customer rewards program now, I believe, so it's worth checking out.

  • I ordered two wallets from Italic and the quality is excellent! I’m very pleased with the quality and design for such a reasonable price point. Definitely a good place to look if you’re willing to pay a little bit for quality and don’t necessarily need a brand name product.

  • When I first learned of Italic, I thought it was the best idea ever. They've continued to grow their offering and their items are high quality and affordable.

    Feedback

    I've been a customer for a long time and I felt a little disappointed when they transitioned from subscription to non-subscription. I felt like I wasted money when I bet on them from the beginning, which definitely hurt my feelings about the brand a bit.

  • I have had a great experience with my italic orders. I have a pair of shearling boots that are exactly like Uggs and my husband has a pair of joggers. I think it’s easy to find “dupes” for certain brands but honestly italic products are even better than the original in many cases! I will definitely be a repeat customer.

  • Recently bought new bedding via Italic, and I was very impressed with the quality! Prices were very reasonable and quality was comparable with some of the more prominent linen brands out there. Would definitely purchase again from them!

  • I purchased a lot of items for my house from Italic. Prices and philosophy are great, but the quality is a bit lacking compared to the actual premium products that are supposedly produced by the same manufacturers. I give them an A+ in the customer service department

  • Purchased a set of mixing bowls from this company that were meant to be from the same manufacturer as Williams Sonoma. Though I personally cannot verify that I'm extremely satisfied with my purchase. The bowls are sturdy and reliable. They do feel like they're a higher quality than something I could buy at target. Only shortcoming of Italic is they do tend to have limited supply so you may not always find what you're hoping for.

  • Really great high quality products for the price point. Many high end dupes that are great quality

  • i'm a luxury candle bitch. unfortunately, i like scent burning throughout my home constantly, which means i go through candles often. italic makes some of the best smelling and quality candles for a fraction of the price (only $18). i've gotten the 4-pack twice, but my favorite scent is oud rosewood.

    Feedback

    i wish they had more scents, or at least limited edition scents, and i wish they came in a 3-wick format. also their catalog of other goods is impressive but sometimes overwhelming to navigate. i'd welcome more curation from their site.

  • A huge variety of products for really reasonable prices. the eucalyptus sheets are my favorite! so soft and cooling!

  • Great quality products and an added benefit that you no longer have to pay a membership fee.

    Feedback

    The cashmere, skincare, shoes, leather goods and accessories are wonderful. As a 6’4” man, the pants run a little short but that’s not overall surprising.

  • Hit or miss with their products - but their sunglasses are great. Their prices have dramatically increased over time (sunglasses used to be $30 and now at $45) - not sure that you are getting the value that you are claiming when they continue to increase prices.

  • I think this business model is genius. I have tried their T-shirts, candles, sunglasses, leather goods, cashmere, you name it. All pieces were of incredible quality and match those of the high-end competitors. I love the transparency in terms of manufacturing locations. Their copy around each product, whether it be sizing or scent notes, is always accurate and informative.

    Feedback

    I love that they are expanding across so many categories from clothing to home to athletic gear/wear.

  • Italic has become my staple source to check before buying any basic item be it a new cutting board, a durable umbrella or a windbreaker. Things are often priced unbelievably reasonably for super high quality products. I'm happy with almost everything I've gotten there!

  • I got my dog a cute harness from here!

    Feedback

    Took too long to ship/get to me.

  • Huge fan of the model and products - have purchased a few like their ugg slipper alternatives and their candles and the quality is top notch

  • I have been an Italic customer since day one and you'll find their stuff all over my apartment but never know it. My sheets, towels, wallet, yoga pants, yoga mat, and water bottle are all from the company. The goods are high quality and always unbranded. I love knowing what other luxury goods are produced at the same factories, and it feels good to buy directly from the manufacturer.