Overall, Italic offers an excellent variety of high-quality products for men, women, and home, at a price that's close to unbeatable for the quality. Obviously the experience will vary by product and category, but at this point I've ordered mens clothing, mens footwear, womens clothing, womens footwear, home, and bedding, and all of the items have met or, more often, far exceeded expectations. I highly recommend the Bold membership, because it pays for itself through credit drops throughout the year and offers even bigger discounts on items periodically.
The challenge with Italic is primarily around fit, which is to be expected from a brand that sources from a variety of factories that supply other luxury brands. MOST of the clothing items I've purchased have fit perfectly, but the occasional item has weird proportions that are likely just similar to another brand the factory supplies. Overall, 9 out of 10 times the items fit as expected, and the reviewer community is great about leaving detailed feedback to help inform buyers prior to purchase.