Oatly reviews and discussion

4.3

85% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Creamy, milklike mouthfeel
  • Exceptional frothing performance
  • Versatile, coffee-enhancing flavor
  • Consistent, barista-grade texture
  • Additive-heavy ingredient list
  • Occasionally too sweet taste
  • Watery low‑fat variant texture
  • Potential gut sensitivity reports

Oatly impresses in reviews for creamy, café-worthy performance—especially Barista Edition, which froths reliably and elevates lattes, matcha, and espresso—while its distinct oat flavor works across coffee, cereal, baking, and smoothies. Reviews also flag meaningful drawbacks: frequent concerns about additives/oils, sweetness and blood-sugar impact, occasional separation or watery low‑fat variants, and mixed reactions to texture; fans call it the best-tasting oat milk, but ingredient purists and some sensitive stomachs report issues.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

2,462 reviews and posts

  • Oatly is a great dairy-free alternative with a creamy texture that works well in coffee, smoothies, and baking. The flavor is mild and not overly sweet, making it versatile. However, the ingredients list includes added oils and sugars, which may not appeal to those looking for a cleaner product. Despite this, it’s still a solid choice for plant-based milk lovers, just not perfect in terms of ingredients.

  • I think Oatly is what helps me best mimic coffee shop quality coffee and matcha lattes at home. Great product!

  • In a world where alternative milks are (thankfully) a-plenty, I do find myself falling back to Oatly more and more. I like how creamy it is for my coffee bar at home and the taste blends well!

  • Oatly is top of the line oat milk, my coffee is just not the same without it. I have tried around 10 oat milk brands and this is by far the rockets, creamiest oat beverage around!

  • While I prefer and love oat milk I felt like this formula was a little off. The consistency was too thin for me and I don't like it when I mix with other liquids and it breaks up a bit. I'll continue to try different flavors and maybe it's better in just iced coffee.

  • Tastes nice, but only realised afterwards that they have vegetable oils... wouldn't buy again on that basis.

  • It's fine. Still not a milk substitute and don't love their ingredients. Wouldn't go out of my way to purchase again.

  • Overall oat milk is not my favorite. I think the best part about Oatly is that if you are making an alternative milk latte it froths up pretty well

  • Ok I'm an almond milk girl through and through, but Blue Bottle Coffee uses Oatly as their milk, and it's pretty good. I love the packaging design, and I think they do a great job on branding.

  • Oatly is a pretty good oat milk brand. It's biggest strength is how long the milk stays good compared to its competitors. I feel like I can get a couple extra weeks or days from buying their milk in comparison to other oats. I also really enjoy that they have protein-infused flavors as I look to increase the amount of protein I eat. Like many brands in this field, I wish they used more sustainable packaging. Even with their box offering, they use plastic caps and line the cardboard body with plastic.

  • Good flavor, good consistency. No notes

    Feedback

    overall its what to be expected from a good oat milk

  • I used to drink Oatly on the daily with my morning coffee. Now I have swapped over to other brands that include fewer vegetable oils in their product. In saying so, the Oatly barista milk (grey packaging) is pretty standard at most cafes, and barista friends have said it froths well.

  • The creamiest oat milk sold in grocery stores. This is my favorite brand of oat milk ever, it works as the perfect dairy substitute in everything I've used it in-- from sauce, to coffee, to baked goods!

  • The milk tasted good, slightly sweet but nice in coffee. It was a little chalky

    Feedback

    If they made the texture smoother. It had a bit of a chalky aftertaste

  • Okay, I bought this after seeing the ads EVERYWHERE. It's my favorite brand of oat milk - they nailed the consistency and flavor. It's perfect to cook with, without being terribly overbearing.

  • I love oat milk and Oatly’s products are some of the best. The barista variety works great with my milk frother!

    Feedback

    There is room for improvement in the ingredient list and processing for less environmental impact.

  • Best oat milk I have ever tried in regards to flavor as well as texture. It gets as creamy and foamy as dairy milk in any latte, cappuccino, etc.

    Feedback

    The brands advertisements are bizarre. Love the product hate the very odd marketing tactics.

  • I wanted to love Oatly but it's a processed food which is not great for our bodies or the environment. :( Freshly made oat milk = oats + water + salt blended together is a far better alternative than all the phosphates and canola oil used in Oatly.

    Feedback

    Ingredients and process to make this. Also oats tend to retain pesticides. A pesticide-free version would be great.