Good Weird reviews and discussion

Got the Cold Brew Under Eye Cream. I really wanted to love it. I have an under eye brightener from Ulta, and this I'm sad to say that this is not a strong competitor. As much as I love the idea of the applicator tip, it doesn't help spread or absorb the product into the skin as well as I would have hoped. The product itself just doesn't have that same sort of brightening or refreshing feel as my current under eye brightener. That being said, I adored the packaging, I love this brand, I love what they stand for. They just missed the mark with this product unfortunately.

I was very skeptical about the The Coldbrew Undereye because it's marketing seems to target teen Gen Z's, and what under eye concerns could a 16 year old have?? This product does give you a fresher look, covering slight dark circles and evening out texture, it does feel more like makeup than a permanent solution. The product is thick and the applicator doesn't spread it evenly, you'll need to pat a little with your fingers to blend it.

Definitely makes my under eyes feel moisturized, but waiting to see a big difference with my dark circles. This goes under makeup super well and doesn’t pill, which is a huge plus!

I shared this product with a friend who recently had a baby and she said the following: "I had always wanted a topical caffeine-based undereye product, and was absolutely stoked to receive this. Also the applicator is a cool metal smoother, which feels very nice on tired eyes. I've been using it to appear more put-together than my usual Sleep-Deprived Mother of an Infant self, and this is the ONE item besides cleansing and moisturizing that I use in the 2 minutes I have to get ready in the morning. 10/10 no notes"

Like the concept... it absorbs well into the skin and smells nice. Appears to be moisturizing but still hard to say if it's doing much long-term regarding aging skin and the like.

I really like the product and the applicator that it comes with on the tube, which I wasn't expecting. I'm not crazy about all of their marketing, but I think it is just not my taste. I would be interested in continuing to purchase the cold brew eye cream or other similar products in the future.

Okay product, application is kind of hard.

The Cold Brew under eye cream is nice, but it don’t know is it’s any different than other eye creams. It smells nice and the applicator is cool. However it’s easy to dispense too much and you still need to pat the cream in while using the applicator. That said, the branding is cool and I’d be interested to try the other products in the line

I really like the applicator and adding the under-eye serum to my routine makes me feel on top of life. The product does feel more like a cream than a serum, but overall really enjoyed using so far.

I was pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed the Cold Brew undereye cream. I don't usually use undereye cream, but I have started uses this one daily as I notice it does help with my makeup not creasing as much and staying fresh throughout the day. I have also used this on other dry areas of my skin to see overnight improvement in patchiness of makeup application. Overall pretty great, and I am considering purchasing again if I notice more long term benefits!

The applicator is cute and fun, and the cooling feeling is really nice. That said, I don't 100% believe under eye cream does anything and this product didn't prove to me otherwise. So like... if you wanna support this cool business (or just love the new gossip girl i guess?) go for it!

I had super high hopes for this product, but I unfortunately didn't notice any changes to my undereye. I'm giving it three stars because it was moisturizing so I'm fine using it under makeup applications to keep my undereye from getting dry, but there was definitely no change to fine lines, puffiness, or dark circles.

Really cool packaging but don’t see a difference on the puffiness of my eyes.

Love the branding and the mission. The product application process and tool is extremely pleasant, and honestly I want to apply more than I should just because of how nice it feels. My issue is that the applicator doesn't spread the product gently under my eyes, and instead leaves a neat line of it that requires me to use my fingers. It's not a huge deal, but it does take away from the clearly intentional addition of the applicator tip. It definitely brightens my undereyes, though I can't say I noticed any lift or perking effect on my skin.

I love the packaging and the idea of the product. The applicator looks and feels cool under my eyes, but it doesn't really spread the product around and I end up needing to use my fingers to really dab it in. I'm honestly not sure if the product does what it says it does, but I would honestly buy it for the cooling effect of the applicator alone.

Loving this product - this is the first eye cream I’ve used and absolutely dig it. The caffeine in the cold brew extract really does perk up my skin.

The cold brew undereye serum is alright. I think the packaging is cute and I do like the applicator, but it's not effective enough to fully apply it. The coolness of the metal feels nice under the eyes so I start out applying it that way, but then I have to rub it in with my fingers for it to sink in. The texture of the cream is nice and I do think it moisturizes, but as for helping with dark circles, I can't say I've seen much of a difference.

I love the applicator and that it is metal. Feels cooling and very easy to clean. Didn't notice anything different to be honest so not sure I would repurchase.

I love my goodweird under eye serum! I keep the tube in the fridge so the metal applicator feels cooling on my skin and helps with puffy/tired eyes. The product does not leave a residue and soaks into the skin nicely. As a plus, the package shipped super fast and was packaged very nicely.

Feels great going on!