Poppi reviews and discussion

4.3

84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vibrant, flavorful profiles
  • Crisp, refreshing carbonation
  • Appealing, playful packaging
  • Versatile, mocktail-friendly drink
  • Noticeable stevia aftertaste
  • Inconsistent flavor execution
  • Occasionally low carbonation
  • Polarizing cola and root beer

Poppi earns largely positive reviews as a satisfying soda alternative that tastes close to the real thing—standouts include Raspberry Rose, Strawberry Lemon, Orange, Ginger Lime, Doc Pop, Classic Cola, and Cherry Limeade—while many praise the light, crisp fizz and perceived gut-friendly prebiotic/ACV benefits. Reviews also flag weaknesses: a noticeable stevia or “diet” aftertaste in some flavors, variability by flavor (cola/root beer polarizing), occasional flatness or low carbonation, and that several drinkers don’t feel meaningful gut effects.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

2,174 reviews and posts

  • I am so happy Poppi is at Costco! I love these pops, but didn't buy them too frequently because they were so expensive. My favorite is the orange flavor, but I haven't tried one that I did not like.

  • These are fun to sip on when you're craving something sweet. I like the root beer flavor a lot (however I doooo like the olipop root beer a bit more)

  • If you are looking for a healthy alternative to soda, these are great. I like the fruit flavors and that they are made with prebiotics so that they are healthy for you. These are made with good for you ingredients and are really refreshing.

  • LOVE poppi! Tastes great and is really good for you. Definitely recommend!

  • Tastes is ok but I don't love the aftertaste - also, I don't feel that the 'probiotic' has much effect.

  • By a landslide my favorite prebiotic soda. My office has replaced our daily diet cokes with these, and its my favorite part of my day. 90% of the flavors are incredible, and I love the unique flavor combinations. I can't say I notice a big difference in my gut health from these, but they don't upset my stomach nearly as much as my daily soda used to.

  • I tried. I honestly tried but the artificial sweetener taste is so unappealing to me. I know that ppl have raved about Poppi but count me out. I would rather drink water. I wish I could describe the taste to you in a descriptive way. Flatish too sweet no thanks. I'll stick to water.

  • Looove these! These were the first prebiotic sodas I've tried & they're definitely a go-to. That being said, they aren't as tasty as some other ones on the market with similar pricepoints. I wish they had some new and exciting flavors more often as well. If you haven't tried, definitely worth a try!

  • I recently had my first poppi and really enjoyed it! The flavors I've tried are cherry limeade (my favorite) strawberry lemon, and orange. They are a great alternative to traditional sodas and I definitely noticed the benefits of the prebiotic and ACV. They've really perfected including ACV in the drink without having the smell or tang of other vinegar drinks I'ved tried. They definitely need to be cold though, I did try one at room temp and noticed the vinegar then.

  • The flavors taste artificial to me. I don't enjoy them as much as other similar brands

  • The best "healthy" soda I have ever had. They are perfectly sweet and the flavors are balanced well. They do not have the strange aftertaste that occurs with some reduced sugar sodas. Plus, the can design is cute. I buy a can every time I got to the store.

  • Love these drinks! Helped curb my addiction to mainstream diet sodas that are not good for me. I also have struggled with gut health for years, and these help so much by supplementing probiotics (can’t eat dairy). I love the variety packs on Amazon that let me try new flavors but I also have favorites- the orange, ginger lime and cola. They have an entire collection of soda flavored classics that helped satisfy the craving of a diet pop.

  • YUM! I love these sodas! They are so refreshing and the flavors are delish! Also the cutest cans ever!! Strawberry is my fav :)

  • Very similar to Olipop, great varietal health drink. Refreshing and tasty. Lower calories than Olipop but less fiber. I do like the apple cider vinegar they add to it.

  • The raspberry rose flavor is incredible! This is a nice alternative to regular soda, without alllll of the sugar.

  • Absolutely mfing gas. I’m Italian be we love orange soda. You can bang one of these out and it hits like a crush but it helps your belly so win win.

  • I love the lemon flavor! It’s a perfect amount of fizz and kick - plus it makes me feel like I’m doing something healthy because of the probiotics.

  • Love this brand! So many good ones! I just wish they were sold in pack instead of individually!