Experiment reviews and discussion

4.4

92% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Innovative, science-driven formulations
  • Comfortable, reusable silicone mask
  • Noticeably hydrating glycerin serum
  • Sleek, playful brand aesthetics
  • Sticky, tacky serum texture
  • Inconsistent mask facial fit
  • Leaky chin during masking
  • Fussy squeeze-bottle dispensing

Experiment earns strong reviews for innovative, science-forward skincare and its reusable Avant Guard silicone mask, which boosts hydration, fits comfortably with ear loops, and reduces waste. Reviews also flag drawbacks: some products feel sticky or slimy, mask fit can gap or leak at the chin, Buffer Jelly’s squeeze bottle is hard to control, and results may be modest for non–mask users.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

197 reviews and posts

  • I was turned onto Experiment years ago back with OG Thingtesting during a ThingDrop when I first grabbed some for my wife. Since then this brand has remained a staple in our medicine cabinets and skincare routines. It is a testament to quality and efficacy as my wife loves to try new brands but usually defaults back to her staples, but these guys have stood the test of time in our household and become part of the staples. The software and the saturated barriers have been used and re-purchased a dozen times and the sheet mask and re-useable sheet mask holder are just brilliant. If you are on the fence give the brand a try, but from personal experience be prepared to make this a recurring member of your skincare team.

    Verified purchase

  • I recently tried Super Saturated based on a review/recommendation on Tiktok from a cosmetic chemist (@alexeducatedmess) and I LOVE it. I have sensitive/combo skin with eczema and suffer from dryness in the winter especially. I am kicking myself for not stocking up on a sale they had recently but am hoping they have one during black friday! I plan on just getting refills so I can continue to use the bottle I have already (I'm almost out!) - I love that they have a refill purchase system! (with a slight discount) update 8/21/25: I have been through literal multiple bottles of super saturated (I have it on subscription lol) and tried the new moisturizer barrier cream on launch and am already on my second tube! I love Experiment's efforts to be sustainable as well. I truly squeeze every last drop out of my products haha. I also love Softwear but wish it was a little bigger!

  • I love Super Saturated! Gives the best boost of hydration and leaves my skin supple. I like to use it at night as my serum step. My skin type is oily and acne-prone.

  • I am such a huge fan of experiment after trying this thing drop! The packaging is super fun and it will definitely stand out on your shelf, but most importantly, it’s incredibly efficacious. It’s like a mix of an oil and Vaseline and it’s really great for people who don’t like the idea of slugging But still want the benefits. I’ve loved my product so much that I ended up getting the super saturated one that is in a blue bottle and I’m so excited to try it. I’ve heard such wonderful things about that product being infinitely better than hyaluronic acid. The fact that they’re able to create such effective yet affordable products is a testament to experiment! Branding-wise I have to say I’m really excited about seeing fun, bright colors that are moving away from millennial pink!

    Verified purchase

  • I love the concept of the Buffer Jelly and so far have had good results giving my skin some extra moisture. I love the slightly odd texture of the product. The fun packaging and science-backed formulations really add to the overall feeling of a solid, thought-out company (as opposed to a quick gimmick). Curious to try more of their products. Only thing that I would change is that I have a hard time getting a smaller amount of product to disperse.

    Verified purchase

  • The Buffer Jelly gets 6/5 for packaging and fun, and for getting us customers excited to use the product. (Their site is also super fun to scroll.) I find the most benefit when using the Buffer Jelly at night, as it locks in whatever products I've put on my face for the longest stretch of time without as much wear, i.e. being out in the sun and sweating. "Oil-gel" is a good way to describe the consistency, as it's in between: its viscosity is more gel to me, but the feel of the product is oil-like, and that's how it feels after applying it on my skin. That said, it's not overly oily, and it seemingly disappears into my skin fairly quickly. As far as effect, based on personal experience, I've seen the most improvement when using the product consistently at least once a day. For me, I noticed my skin hasn't been as dry in my T-zone, which it sometimes can be in the summer. I'm going to shelf it for now and look forward to using the product throughout the winter months, when I feel it will really help lock in moisture. I'd also be excited to try Super Saturated, and look forward to keeping an eye on this brand to see what else they come out with!

    Verified purchase

  • I was able to score the Experiment Jelly Buffer as a Thingdrop. I found it to be a great alternative to rubbing Vaseline over my hydrating products. It comes in a gel oil mix and was easy to spread. It was fast absorbing and did not leave my skin feeling sticky. A must if you're into slugging.

    Verified purchase

  • After a long wait, Super Saturated finally arrived in my mailbox. I LOVE THIS PRODUCT SO MUCH. It immediately gave me the plump, bouncy skin that I've tried to achieve with a dozen different products that either did nothing or broke my sensitive skin. My only complaint is that this doesn't come in a larger size. I love that they offer a refill to help reduce packaging though. I've been wasting my time with hyaluronic acid serums, but apparently glycerin in the magic ingredient. Experiment is a brand that I heard about on Tiktok, but I love that they are starting their product line small and focusing their efforts on science backed products.

  • I tried the Buffer Jelly and am obsessed! My skin was visibly softer and clear after a week of using this. Typically, skin products that are too oily or thick really bug me but I think the Buffer Jelly had a perfect texture. Experiment only offers a few different products and based on my experience with the Buffer Jelly, I can’t wait to see all of the cool products they come up with!

    Verified purchase

  • fun experience but didn't seem to have a long term effect!

    Verified purchase

  • Feels great on the skin, but is super tiny, and hard to control how much product comes out, since it is a squeeze bottle.

    Verified purchase

  • This reusable sheet mask was so helpful and my skin care routine. I always hated having to throw away my shit mess because it felt a little wasteful but now that is not the case I just applied a couple drops of my serum and applied the reusable silicone mask, this was a great way to end my spa night.

    Verified purchase

  • I tried Super Saturated and it definitely does what it promises - it's really hydrating and protective of the skin barrier. I'm a big skincare junkie and I've never tried a product like this before. Definitely worth trying if you have sensitive or dry skin - it's made a huge difference in the winter!

    Feedback

    I did get some sensitivity with this product the first couple of times that I used it but the sensitivity went away with more regular use. Really interesting product and love that you can buy refills directly through their website!

    Discount code
  • I tried the serum. The texture is very sticky and interesting. I have super dry skin and was hoping the high glycerin concentration would do a lot but I don’t feel like it greatly surpassed other hydrating serums. I still liked it a lot though!

    Feedback

    Packaging is a bit bulky, but cool looking!

  • I actually really enjoy this thing. Makes you want to start a face mask routine.

  • Ok, I was skeptical about this at first and it sat on my counter for a while. But this is a great product! I'm petite, so the small size fit my face perfectly, and the ear loops were very comfortable. What I really like is that unlike regular disposable sheet masks, the only side with any type of liquid is the side that touches your face, so I can keep my glasses on and do other things while I have the mask on. There's no mess and it's super easy to clean when you're done. I think this would be a great gift for friends who are into beauty/skincare products.

    Verified purchase

  • Really love this product. For those of us who loves sheet masks, but are tired of the waste it creates, this is a lifesaver. I found that it functions exactly as advertised - the only issue is that it doesn't perfectly lay flat, but that could be user error. I'll keep trying!

  • The skincare products are just fine. It’s the lip balm that sends the brand to the stratosphere for me. The texture is ideal, I get all day hydration, there’s no scent. If I was Oprah, it would be in my favorite things box every single year.

  • Softwear is the star of the brand! Barrier jelly feels good but I don't like the bottle because it's not very disability friendly. It's difficult to squeeze and gets a bit too oily for sustainable use! (AKA it's hard to open and control and squeeze out the proper portion-- would like a pump mechanism like the Super Saturated!)