SmartSweets reviews and discussion

3.9

72% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Tasty low‑sugar candies
  • Nostalgic flavor recreations
  • Bright, fruity flavor profiles
  • Convenient portioned packaging
  • Extremely sticky texture
  • Inconsistent chewiness firmness
  • Sweetener aftertaste lingering
  • Potential gastrointestinal discomfort

SmartSweets earns positive reviews for genuinely tasty, low‑sugar takes on nostalgic gummies like Sweet Fish, Peach Rings, Sourmelon Bites, and Red Twists; it satisfies cravings and often avoids “fake” sweetener aftertaste. Reviews also flag real drawbacks: many candies are extremely sticky or tough, flavors can be inconsistent with occasional stevia/allulose aftertaste and GI upset, and portions feel small. Overall, SmartSweets is good if cutting sugar, but texture quirks and formula variability make it a compromise for purists.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,537 reviews and posts

  • Price point a bit high. We as humans are more inclined to grab the unhealthier choice if it is a $1 or $2 less which is often the case with these smart sweets. flavors are great and do taste like the “real” version.

  • I love smart sweets. The products are yummy and I love the fibre rich product. I wish more products were gelatin-free (or at least certified grass-fed gelatine) given that the farming industry can be a dirty, cruel place. But I stick to the fish and they're delicious! This is my go-to when I need a sweet treat and don't want a sugar headache!

  • As someone who's constantly trying to maintain a healthy lifestyle while also having an undeniable sweet tooth, I've struggled to find the perfect balance between indulgence and nutrition. But my prayers were answered when I discovered Smart Sweets and their delectable Sour Gummy Bears. These tasty treats have become my go-to snack, satisfying my cravings without sabotaging my diet. One of the most impressive aspects of Smart Sweets' Sour Gummy Bears is their nutritional profile. With just 3 grams of sugar and a whopping 28 grams of fiber per bag, these gummies are a game-changer for anyone adhering to a strict diet or simply looking to cut down on sugar intake. It's hard to believe that something so delicious can also be so guilt-free! The taste of these sour gummy bears is nothing short of extraordinary. They strike the perfect balance between sweet and tangy, with a mouth-puckering sourness that's simply irresistible. It's easy to forget you're eating a healthier alternative to traditional gummy bears, as the flavor and texture are remarkably similar to their sugar-laden counterparts. Smart Sweets has also made a commitment to using high-quality, all-natural ingredients, and their gummies are free from artificial sweeteners, colors, and flavors. This is particularly important for those who are mindful of the food they consume and prefer clean eating options. In conclusion, Smart Sweets' Sour Gummy Bears are an absolute must-try for anyone looking to enjoy a tasty, guilt-free treat while sticking to a healthy eating plan. These scrumptious gummies offer a fantastic flavor, an impressive nutritional profile, and a commitment to clean ingredients, making them an ideal choice for the health-conscious snacker. Say goodbye to sugary candies and hello to the delicious world of Smart Sweets!

  • Good alternative to traditional sweets when I am trying to eat healthier. But they do have a slight aftertaste that I wasn't exactly expecting, it wasn't bad just had to get used to it. Overall, really like the candies I've tried.

  • I love the concept of it but I feel that it doesn’t really mimic what it’s trying to replace. It’s also very hard

  • Smart Sweets offers a variety of low-sugar, plant-based candies that are a healthier alternative to traditional sweets. While some products are great (peach rings, sweet fish), others need some work (sour blasts, gummy bears). Taste is king, after all! If you're trying to cut back on sugar but still want to indulge in candy, Smart Sweets is definitely worth a try. Just be prepared to experiment with different flavors until you find the ones you love!

  • Great Candy! The lack of sugar does not mean lack of flavor. They pack a punch and have me eating a whole bag real quick.

    Feedback

    More Flavors!

  • These are definitely a great alternative to traditional candy if you don't mind the obvious taste of stevia. They are chewy like other gummy candy and melt the same too. I'm not a huge fan of the taste of stevia but don't mind it every so often.

    Feedback

    I wish there were more pieces in the bags and that the candy wasn't so sticky.

  • I tried a few different types around Halloween and found them to be pretty much just as good as any other candy!

    Feedback

    Pricier than regular candy but if you have a sweet tooth but are looking for something with less calories this may be a good alternative !

  • I found Smart Sweets to be a great way to treat myself without having too much sugar. The flavors are delicious and the portion sizes are perfect for indulging without going overboard. It also makes me feel good knowing that I'm making healthier choices when it comes to snacking. I'm very impressed with the quality of the ingredients and the affordability of the products - they make it easy and enjoyable to set up healthier habits. Highly recommend!

    Influencer for SmartSweets
  • Tried a bunch of different candies and honestly help me give in to cravings without feeling like I was eating crap.

    Feedback

    Expensive for what it is, but if you have the money and a sweet tooth totally worth it! For me it’s a once and a white splurge.

  • Smart sweets can be really hit or miss depending on what you buy. The sour melon bites and peach rings were the only two things that I liked. Everything else tasted very artificial and didn’t really live up to the hype. If you really need to cut down on sugar for whatever reason, these may be a good alternative but if you’re able to, I would say to just eat regular candy.

    Feedback

    Avoid the caramels at all cost! They were the worst.

  • This is easily one of my favorite brands and one of the *very* few food-related subscriptions I have. As someone with a huge sweet-tooth that constantly needs to snack, Smart Sweets have been the perfect go-to and everything they make tastes as good as their sugar-based counterpart.

    Feedback

    They are slightly chewier and stick to your teeth more but that just forces you to take it slower between each bite! Not every item may work for you, so my recommendation is starting with the variety pack and finding your favorite.

  • I’m a gummy addict, I just crave a sweet treat in the afternoon and after dinner. I love the idea of having a lower sugar option and sometimes buy these to make me feel better about my gummy habit. Ultimately though, they’re just more expensive and not as good. So, by all means, purchase to alleviate guilt if you need to, but otherwise, just go with the good stuff.

    Feedback

    Great for tricking yourself into thinking you’re being “good” while actually paying more and being disappointed you didn’t just buy Haribo. 😂

  • I buy the Sweet Fish or Sour Blast Buddies when I want to eat candy while still making a healthier choice, since SmartSweets have so much less sugar than the popular candies. I think SmartSweets tastes great and are pretty comparable to Swedish Fish or Sour Patch Kids, just a little more chewy.

    Feedback

    I do like this candy but it is definitely more expensive, so I don't buy it all the time.

  • Innovative and timely product. We all want healthy alternatives to traditionally harmful snacks. Unfortunately this one fell flat for me. The gummies were hard to chew and not as flavorful as the original ones.

    Feedback

    Improve mouthfeel texture and boost flavors.

  • I love candy and gummies especially so when I saw SmartSweets, I knew I had to try them! They are tasty and honestly pretty inline with normal candy - plus it's a bonus that they don't hurt my stomach when I finish a bag!!

    Feedback

    I wish they were a bit cheaper.

  • Spendy but worth it when you've got a hankering for candy but are limiting sugar! It's not an exact replica of the real deal but the flavor, while different, is good and hits the right notes from a consistency standpoint. I'd buy these often to curb my sweet tooth when I was on a heavy sugar cutback. The faux sour patch kids are especially tasty.

    Feedback

    The serving sizes are pretty small... but they have to be because eating too much artificial sweetener will make your tummy very unhappy!

  • I’ve continued to purchase their products over the years because I have a massive sweet tooth and it makes me feel less guilty when I’m eating gummy bears from SmartSweets than Haribo. However, I can’t say they have the best tasting products—it just helps with filling a need (aka sweet tooth)!

    Feedback

    The sour gummies need a lot more love…truly. In any case, I support the brand and what SmartSweets are doing in their mission to make candy less bad for you to consume.

  • The melon flavor is my fav. Such a good and guilty free treat!