4.4
90% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
GOODLES
4.4 • 372 Reviews
•

4.4
90% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
GOODLES earns strong reviews as a tastier, higher‑protein, high‑fiber upgrade to classic boxed mac and cheese, with many praising creamy, cheesy flavors (Shella Good, Cheddy Mac, Twist My Parm, Down The Hatch) and al dente noodles. However, reviews flag inconsistent flavor execution (especially Cacio e Pepe and some vegan options), occasional watery or bland sauces, high sodium, small portions, and reports of stomach discomfort; shoppers who prioritize nutrition over pure nostalgia find it a compelling pantry staple, while purists may prefer Annie’s or Kraft.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
The vegan variety is really tasty, with tons of good-for-you ingredients without any unpleasantly "healthy" taste. Perfectly creamy for not having any dairy, too. The price is a little high relative to conventional mac & cheese, but for vegans, this is a solid, easy option... would love to see some of the other flavors made vegan.
great pasta! love the mac and cheese specifically but the pasta itself is good if you pair a good sauce with it. a bit chewy but that's what you get with protein pasta
3y ago
They taste good, but they are usually double the price of Annies or Kraft. For me there is not enough added protein (I think the difference between Annies and Goodles is like 5 g of protein) to justify paying that much for boxed Mac and cheese. I would buy the product again if it was cheaper or if it had a higher protein content (like above 20 g)
A healthy alternative to my typical box mac n cheese?! Sign me up! I first say Goodles in Whole Foods and was drawn in my the bright and fun packaging, a major selling point for me. It was very easy to make, resembling any other box mac n cheese with pasta and a package of cheese to add in after. Having alternative flavors to the classic cheddar mac, like Cacio E Pepe, is a win in my book as a self-proclaimed adventurous eater. I think Goodles is a great alternative to your typical box mac n cheese brands if you're looking for a healthier alternative.
I wholeheartedly believe a box of Mac and cheese is one serving ;) so having some extra protein in it is a huuuge bonus. The whole box is usually 500-600 cals which really is not that bad!! And the flavors are honestly fantastic. I’ve l tried maybe 3-4 of the flavors and they all blow me away. I am a big fan
I LOVE Goodles! Makes me feel less guilty about enjoying a childhood favorite box of Mac n cheese
So delicious! Try the truffle flavor you won’t regret it. Kraft who???
Listen, if we wanted Mac and Cheese to be healthy we would have asked for that.. this is simply foul. save your money
3y ago
Huge fan of goodles!! Great taste and macros, makes for a super easy addition to any meal. Love that they’re widely available as well, just got a GIANT box at costco!
Goodles is easily my new favorite carb. I eat an entire box of the vegan white cheddar goodles to myself in one sitting with no shame and a happy stomach. Few ingredients, higher protein content, and it satisfies you the same way that Kraft Mac and cheese used to back in the day. I am personally non-dairy, so this has been an amazing discovery for me. I’ve actually tasted the dairy flavors, and nothing beats the vegan white cheddar. Highly recommend!! Not to mention the packaging, branding, and, of course…GAL GADOT.
I've ONLY tried the Mac n' Cheese version, like a classic Kraft version. I will never eat another box version that isn't this - it's absolutely SO GOOD!!! It tastes just like I remember as a kid only better, and leaves me feeling full since it actually has good for you noodles and protein. Easy to make, I just bought more - and I will say the only thing to note is to make sure you stir the post while cooking the pasta so the noodles won't stick together. LOVE!! I would like to try the other versions soon, too!
I only tried the vegan version of this and it was pretty good. I wish the sauce were creamier but maybe adding some vegan cheese would help with that. I do like that it has more protein than other brands! It was also easy to make.
Tried the shella good shells - tastes great for a healthier alternative to mac and cheese.
Really good boxed mac and cheese that you can convince yourself is better for you to eat than Kraft or Annie's!
4y ago
I've tried a few different Goodles flavors and they are all pretty average in terms of taste. They are more nutritious than your typical mac n cheese options with less artificial inclusions, but flavor-wise I think some of the competitors have the upper hand. The individual boxes are also pretty pricey compared to the typical box of mac n cheese. Would recommend to a friend who is looking for something that's a little healthier, but is still reminiscent of the typical mac n cheese flavor.
Feedback
The cacio e pepe doesn't have enough flavor. The aged white cheddar was pretty good.
4y ago
Have repurchased the variety pack several times! We love the non-traditional flavors and the nutritional value by comparison to similar products. Easy to make, and even tastes good heated up as leftovers.
Feedback
One thing I'm always looking for is a variety size to make mac&cheese for a larger family. I also would love a GF or DF option.
I like the idea of these, but the flavors just aren't as good as the boxed versions sold in stores. Easy to cook, pretty much exactly the same as all the other boxed mac and cheeses.
Feedback
I get the reasoning behind the higher price point, but I wish it would be lower to make nutrient packed, high protein, high fiber mac and cheese more accessible.
Woweeeeee. The flavors! The branding! The taste! The nostalgia! 10's across the board. It was actually dangerous having these at home...there was a week were I was eating a box of mac 'n cheese per day... Honestly delicious though and love that they are slightly better for you (but not better enough to eat a box a day lol). Creative flavor choices too! Couldn't choose a favorite. Didn't realize Gal Gadot was behind these...I thought I couldn't have more of a girl crush than I already did after Wonder Woman. I was wrong.
Feedback
A little bit expensive full price (I got as Thingdrop), but I think I'd still buy again. Wish the portion sizes were bigger. As someone else said, it's just too much for 1 person but not enough for 2...probably ideal for kids (which is their target market I imagine lol)
Verified purchase
4y ago
Great flavors, and great taste! Will definitely be using this in place of the default mac n cheese brand.
bacon flavor was super good.