GOODLES reviews and discussion

4.4

90% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • High-protein, nutrient-dense pasta
  • Creamy, satisfying cheese sauces
  • Nostalgic, crowd-pleasing flavors
  • Chic, memorable packaging
  • Occasionally bland, uneven seasoning
  • Sometimes overly salty taste
  • Sauce thin or coagulates cooling
  • Small, less-filling portions

GOODLES earns strong reviews for tasting like nostalgic boxed mac and cheese while adding meaningful protein, fiber, and veggie-derived nutrients; many praise flavors like Shella Good, Cheddy Mac, Twist My Parm, and Mover & Shaker and note easy prep and appealing packaging. Reviews also flag downsides: inconsistent flavor punch, occasional salty or bland notes, stomach discomfort from fiber, small portions, and sauce texture issues (thin or coagulating), with some saying it’s not markedly better than Kraft or Annie’s.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

377 reviews and posts

  • LOVEEE this stuff. It is so filling & has reasonable calories, especially compared to the protein content. The flavor is good but a bit bland, definitely worth the calorie trade off though because it is still very good. I love the texture of the pasta, it's exactly like regular pasta. It is expensive but so worth it!

  • I purchased the Shella Good and the Cheddy Mac and cheese. The whole idea around this is to make regular Mac and Cheese, nutrition packed that will taste like normal. I thought a healthier version so gave it a try. I must say when I tried both I thought that they both tasted good. They did not have that artificial taste that the others usually have. I would by again and try some other kinds they have.

  • Thrilled Cheese is so creamy, cheesy, and satisfying! I love the rich cheddar flavor and fun noodle shape. It has that classic comfort-food taste but feels a little more elevated. Easy to make, delicious, and definitely a mac and cheese I’d buy again!

  • Shella Good is a delicious twist on classic mac and cheese! The shell-shaped noodles are perfectly chewy and hold onto the creamy, cheesy sauce. It’s comforting, flavorful, and easy to make—definitely one I’d keep stocked for a quick and satisfying meal!

  • Twist My Parm is such a fun take on mac and cheese! Super creamy, cheesy, and packed with Parmesan flavor. I love the little twisty noodles—they hold onto the sauce so well. Comforting, flavorful, and an easy upgrade from classic mac!

  • Goodles is such a fun upgrade from regular boxed mac and cheese! It’s creamy, cheesy, and comforting while still feeling like a better-for-you option. I love the variety of flavors and how quick and easy it is to make. Perfect for a quick lunch or easy dinner!

  • Absolutely love this one as well, but is my least favorite of the Goodles collection. That being said, it is still incredibly good and so worth the money. Would still buy and recommend this flavor! Love this brand!

  • 100% recommend this to any and everyone. Sooo good and love the clean ingredients, as well as the protein! So so good! Also love how it isn’t crazy expensive and can be found in so many shopping locations!

  • I’ve tried a handful of flavors from goodles and they’ve become a staple quick meal in my household! We always stock the gouda and hatch pepper flavors. The noodles have a nice al dente texture and the flavor is enjoyable.

  • Im an australian living in thge US so mac & cheese is not really something i have ever ate alot of. The Kraft version just really puts me off but i figured i would try Goodles. I actually enjoyed it. Wasn't too heavy and quite tasty.

  • I really did not like Goodles Shella Good Microwavable cup. I did not like the texture or the taste which I found off putting. Maybe it is just harder to make a good microwavable product. I think someone might like it for the ease and convenience, but it wasn't for me.

  • I had my doubts that this would turn out as good as it did. Prep was easy. Just remove the cheese pack, add water to the fill line, microwave, add cheese, let melt and mix. It turned out just like the boxed Goodles, but with less time over the stove. This would be ideal for situations where you have access to hot water, but not to a cooktop, such as traveling. Definitely will pick some up for these situations.

    Received a free product from GOODLES
  • Goodles are amazing! I love the cheddar flavors. Especially the deluxe versions which are just divine. Easy to make and delicious to eat! I always have a box on hand for a quick, easy, and healthy dinner.

  • I absolutely love this brand. I think it’s my go to for mac & cheese across support because of the high-protein. My cheat code to add in more protein is to cook it in bone broth and then blend with cottage cheese!

  • Tastes similar to the mac and cheese that we all grew up on but slightly better. It feels less junky and has better ingredients. I actually prefer Goodles and plan on purchasing again. I wish that my grocery store had more varieties available so I didn’t have to order online but I do love that I got a free item when I did order online.

  • My teenage son, who has celiac disease and follows a gluten free diet, likes this brand over all the other boxed Mac & Cheese available in stores. This is the only brand he buys, claiming the flavor and texture is better. As a mom, I am just happy there is something gluten free out there that he likes and can make himself.

  • My Mac and Cheese brand of choice! Tastes great, love the variety of flavors. Sometimes I go vegan and gluten free just for fun and those are good too! Also allegedly glyphosate free unlike some other protein Mac and Cheese brands....................

  • Goodles mac was an easy to cook pasta. I didn't notice much that this was high protein pasta made with chickpeas. The pasta alone tastes like normal and the texture is similar but slightly chewier than normal pasta. I love how easy it was to make and how creamy the sauce was. I tried the Cheddy Mac gluten free flavor. One thing I'll say is that it doesn't reheat well. It only tastes good fresh.

  • I love this brand - I buy it regularly for my family at Costco. My (picky) son loves the flavors and happily eats this in rotation with Annie's mac & cheese. However, I am pretty sensitive to the type of fiber they are using so notice some discomfort after eating!

  • The vegan Mac and cheese is the best tasting vegan boxed Mac and cheese I’ve ever had, and I have tried many. How they are able to make it taste so good and include nutrients and protein, I’m not sure, but I’m not asking.