4.5
89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Fishwife
4.5 • 219 Reviews
•

4.5
89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Fishwife earns strong reviews for genuinely tasty, high-quality tinned seafood—standouts include Smoked Rainbow Trout, Smoked Albacore Tuna, and Fly By Jing Smoked Salmon—paired with striking, giftable packaging and an ethics-forward sourcing ethos. Reviews also flag meaningful drawbacks: small portions, frequent dryness or intense smokiness in certain SKUs (notably Campfire Cod), inconsistent flavor intensity, and a price that many consider steep for everyday use.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
10mo ago
Bought this as a gift for a birthday and it was a hit! The packaging was really nice and had a nice variety of flavors! The quality of the fish is really good, tasted very flavorful and paired nicely with some bread.

Verified purchase
The packaging of fishwife is spot on and I love the concept of high-end canned fish with ethical sourcing. The taste was good, but not outstanding on the Fly by Jing product. I’m looking forward to trying the others!

We need a moment of silence for the branding and packaging before we begin. WOW. ... ... ... So far I've tried the Salmon and Trout. When I first got them in the mail I was just so excited I didn't know what to do so I opened up the salmon and ate it straight from the tin (I mean hot girls eat tinned fish, right?). I didn't really love it like that, but the quality was incredible and I appreciated that. When it came time to try the trout, my friend whipped up a quick little dip with the limited ingredients in my house (celery, white wine vinegar, off-brand Ritz crackers), it was so good, an absolute HIT. I still have the Tuna left and will definitely be making some sort of dip or salad. Sad to see 'em go, love to watch 'em leave. I also have the dish towels that just make me so happy.
Feedback
I know there are recipes on the site, but it'd be great to have a fun lil post card or something in the box!

I really loved the site experience and overall vibe and aesthetic. I got the rainbow trout and it didn't taste canned at all. It's a great sized lunch for one and I made it with toast and a pasta dish.
Feedback
I'd love more recipe ideas and to try other types of canned fish from Fishwife!

1y ago
My favorite is the smoked rainbow trout. I like freshwater fish, since they will contain less mercury. The albacore tuna is really tasty, but it is an occasional treat. There are other brands of tinned fish I like much better TBH. This is also quite expensive. I also do not consider any farmed fish "sustainable" at this point. Which means I will not be buying the smoked rainbow trout. Wild caught in waters which the fish are plentiful and not going to take needed resources from predators is the only fish I will eat. Many tribal fisherman in my area are well known to be the most sustainable option available, so I will be supporting them over anyone else.

All the Fishwife varieties I've tried have tasted lovely. The packaging is whimsical and funky, leading their tins to stand out amongst an otherwise dull tinned fish grocery store aisle. I think these would work great in a gift basket for any foodie. The pricing is absolutely ridiculous, and simply not justifiable.

So good! I ate the Campfire Cod out of the can with nothing added to it and it was so delicious. I could eat it for lunch everyday. No notes. Perfection.
Feedback
It's a little pricey. I definitely think it's worth the money, but I'd be more inclined to buy it if I could just pick it up in a shop as opposed to ordering it online.

Verified purchase
This tinned fish goes beyond the cute packaging and great marketing, it's actually delicious. I found out later that Fishwife was on Shark Tank and that's great because I can buy it from many more retailers.

2y ago
Though a bit on the expensive side (I had a coupon for $2 off the normal $8.99 price), this is one of those situations where you absolutely get what you pay for. I purchased the slow-smoked mackerel with chili flakes, and absolutely loved it. I've tasted a few other brands—King Oscar immediately comes to mind—and these were far and away more flavorful. There's a touch of sugar and garlic mixed in with the olive oil and chilis, which adds a unique sweetness and punch to the overall taste (It's so good I saved the oil to blend in with vinegar for a future salad dressing). If you like tinned fish, definitely give this one a try!

Obviously the packaging and branding is A1, but as cute as that is, the price point is way too high to see myself as a repeat customer. I bought a little bit of everything for my husband to try and his comments were “that one brand from MOM is still better. (Raincoast) I tried the smoked tuna myself and wasn’t really feeling it. It was such a tiny amount and I didn't like the smoke flavor. That’s my personal preference, so if you’re a smoky person it may be wonderful. It almost seems like they’re a graphic design house that stumbled upon fish, instead of the other way around.




4y ago
Amazing branding and nice tasting fish, but at an astronomical cost that I simply can’t justify. The campfire cod was actually a little dry on the inside even though it was drenched in olive oil and pepper. I much prefer smoked fish from a regular grocery store which is cheaper per ounce and isn’t as dry.
Feedback
Pricing. How can you justify $10+ for a tiny 3.5oz tin of fish? This is just not attainable for regular folx. Also a lot of packaging - do the tins each need their own individual paper box? Probably not necessary.

3y ago
I tried the rainbow trout and it was pretty tasty, but I don't feel that this brand is worth the high prices they charge. It feels like they're trying to make this feel high-end and hipster-y and so you're basically paying for the pretty packaging. I'll stick to the Trader Joe's trout.

4y ago
I meannnnnnnn. Branding is perfect. Think Becca and co are absolutely crushing it. Product tastes great. Expensive, sure, but I get the hype and I'm all for it!

I love tinned fish. For years I maintained detailed tasting notes, tracked prices, probably ate a can a day! So I was extra excited to try Fishwife (thanks #thingdrop!). The packaging was lovely. The company mission is great. And I really liked the fish. It was my first time having tinned cod. I should have expected it but the fish itself was a little more toothsome than I'd expected. But since it's a low-fat fish that's just the way it works. Flavor was great, too. Not sure I'd pay full price but perhaps as part of a larger spread for a special occasion where folks would appreciate the unique nature.
Feedback
Would have loved this Thingdrop as a sample pack. It's too bad the actual can wasn't also decorated. Would look fly on a charcuterie board.

Verified purchase
Fishwife is one of my favorite brands I've discovered in 2022. I found them at my favorite neighborhood coffee shop, Mom 'n' Em and have been keeping them stocked in my pantry since. The Fly By Jing collab is one of my favorites, with the smoked trout as a very close second. They're great on their own, in a salad, in your ramen, or really in any way you'd like to consume them. I LOVE them as a camping snack. The packaging is TO DIE FOR cute and if you order from them you get cutie stickers as a bonus.
Feedback
They're definitely a treat yo'self item for the price & size.

1y ago
With the amount of tin fish out on the market, nothing comes close to fishwife in flavor. I tried one with chili and it was just perfect for my salad topping. You don’t need extra sodium, seasoning or oil.

1y ago
I love Fishwife's tinned fish! It is slightly pricey but I stock up whenever it's on sale at whole foods. The flavor is fantastic so you don't have to mix it with anything the way I would with a standard can of tuna. The Smoked Salmon with Chili Crisp (a collaboration with Fly By Jing) is SO delicious and makes a perfect satisfying meal with some rice and veggies, and then I love the tuna with some crackers and pickles for a quick lunch.

4y ago
Absolutely obsessed with Fishwife’s branding. Everything from the boxes the tins come in to the packaging tape are just done so well and are so cute. As for the product itself, I’m so glad I got to try the campfire cod. It was so tasty and had so much flavor. Definitely looking forward to trying other Fishwife products!

Verified purchase
Great flavor and branding, but not quite great enough to justify the steep price. I tried Fishwife's limited-edition Campfire Cod product as part of a ThingDrop. The flavor was fresh and smoky and the quality of the fish was evident -- plus the packaging was fun and inspired. But the price was beyond what I would reasonably consider paying for fish. With a retail price of $39 for three *small* tins (smaller than standard fish tins), I could not see myself buying this again without the discounted price I first received. Perhaps I'm vastly misunderstanding the true cost of ethically-sourced seafood, but $13 for a few bites of canned cod just doesn't seem worth it to me.
Feedback
I would highly suggest seeking ways to cut costs without compromising on values and mission, to the extent possible.

Verified purchase
Part of the Thingdrop! I love the packaging in the box, it's probably my favorite part of the brand itself. Came in a set of 3 with some cute stickers.
Feedback
Perhaps I'm picky with my canned fish but thought the taste for the canned cod was overall okay: the texture was a bit crumbly, and the oil mix was good but saltier than expected. Had it with a lettuce wrap but might benefit in a sandwich or large salad form.

Verified purchase