Everlane reviews and discussion

4.1

84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Durable cashmere sweaters
  • Flattering cheeky denim
  • Minimalist timeless designs
  • Soft comfortable fabrics
  • Inconsistent sizing across styles
  • Boxy unflattering silhouettes
  • Thin sheer cotton tees
  • Occasional quality fluctuations

Everlane earns largely positive reviews for durable, minimalist basics—especially cashmere sweaters, Way-High and 90s/Classic Cheeky jeans, alpaca knits, and sturdy backpacks—suggesting the brand is good for timeless wardrobe staples. Reviews also flag real drawbacks: inconsistent and often boxy fits, variable and sometimes declining quality in cotton tees and newer drops, limited size inclusivity/lengths, and controversies around sustainability claims and union-busting.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

751 reviews and posts

  • Quality is their game! I love their pieces. I wish they would venture into new styles (not much has changed since 2012), but I love some of their trust staple pieces like their T-shirt’s and jeans.

  • Love Everlane! Top quality t-shirts. Their v-neck tees are may absolute favorite. Super soft and they last forever!

    Feedback

    More bundles please!

  • I bought jeans from here and I didn't really like them so I ended up reselling them on Poshmark.

  • Look, they make affordable clothing even though their in-person salespeople suck and it feels like a giant mass "who's who" of your neighborhood. I am glad they started to extend their sizing--but it's still not enough! Be more inclusive! Also, I wish their luxurious items were 100% instead of a blend. :/

  • Such an elevated staple–I have this turtleneck in five colors and rotate through them all winter. The ribbed fabric is soft and high quality, and show little wear even after years. I love the center seam and the back and that the sleeves are nice and long.

  • Unexpected find with their socks. I love the 3 pack in white. The grooves on the sole keep these socks feeling snug and comfy without feeling too tight or bulky. They wash well too. Highly recommend.

  • Everlane makes adorable dresses that make you want to wake up early and go to the farmers market in them. They have a suburban style to them. I love the dresses because they have a nice flow to them and you’ll never get hot. The ribbed tank dress is cute on its own but you can also dress it up with hats, belts, or other accessories. They’re a little pricey but it’s also quality that will last.

  • Everlane makes great work basics. Their jeans & sweaters are good quality. This store reminds me of a mix of Gap & J Crew.

  • The sizing can be a little allover the place. I bought a pair of pants in size 8 and they're WAY larger than the same size at other retailers. That made me nervous to buy more of their clothes online. Now I only shop in-store. Their designs are of good quality and practical.

    Feedback

    Price and sizing.

  • I have purchased several items from this brand. Sometimes the fit can be very off.

    Feedback

    Improve transparency and labor disclosures.

  • Their high waisted wide leg jeans fit and look great. A bit pricey but worth it to me.

  • Good quality basics that last forever

    Feedback

    Not always the ideal fit but great basics overall

  • I will flag that it has been a long time since I have bought anything from Everlane, but I purchased one basic white cotton t-shirt in 2016 and the quality just wasn’t good enough for me. It was thin (see-through) and the material felt cheap. I might give them a go again, but expected more the first time!

    Feedback

    Quality could be improved.

  • Everlane’s plain cotton t-shirt’s and cotton undies are my favorite. They are high quality, breathable and hold up to years of wash and wear.

    Feedback

    Better transparency, less new product drops and making efforts to be even more sustainable.

  • I love their product! You can't beat the price for the quality and I love that they're so open about their supply chain. Their Uniform jeans are the most comfortable I have worn, that I won't go back to regular jeans.

    Feedback

    N/A

  • I mean, what can I say, I often find things at Everlane that I love. But It really bums me out that they keep dropping new items like every 3 days. I feel like this generates clicky, impulsive shopping, in more orders/boxes, not unlike fast fashion.

  • I love the simplicity and quality of everlane products. Their jeans are very comfortable and stretchy and their tees are really soft. I also love that they are made from sustainable materials and they make it easy to love eco-friendly clothing!