Tony's Chocolonely reviews and discussion

4.6

94% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Creamy, luxurious mouthfeel chocolate
  • Inventive, memorable flavor lineup
  • Chunky, satisfying bar format
  • Ethical, mission-driven sourcing
  • Overly sweet chocolate profiles
  • Thick, hard-to-break pieces
  • Inconsistent caramel texture hardness
  • Limited higher-cacao dark options

Tony’s Chocolonely earns strong reviews for rich, creamy chocolate, inventive flavors like Milk Caramel Sea Salt, Dark Almond Sea Salt, and Dark Milk Pretzel Toffee, plus mission-driven, fair-trade sourcing. Reviews also flag drawbacks: some bars taste overly sweet or bland to dark‑chocolate loyalists, the thick, uneven pieces are hard to break and share, and concerns appear about heavy metals in certain dark varieties and salt intensity in caramel bars.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,927 reviews and posts

  • Delicious, amazing chocolate, and you get a lot of bang for your buck!

  • The quality of the chocolate is wonderful. It is smooth and flavorful. The packaging is also cute and holds up relatively well when you eat a little bit now and then. Of note, the bar is segments into semi-random pieces - some large and some small. It can make it hard to share equally with another person.

  • I found this chocolate at the health food grocery store in my neighborhood and it's so good. I love that knowing it's in stores like this and Whole Foods I can trust the quality of ingredients. I love dark chocolate, but I've also enjoyed their milk chocolate. They have such great combos and I love how huge the bars are, haha, sometimes you just need a GIANT chocolate bar. And this is the only one I know of.

  • This chocolate is amazing! My husband and I ended up fighting over it and I love that it is ethically sourced.

  • Only Tony’s would get me to write a review on chocolate lol. I first grabbed a bar in Whole Foods on a whim and I’ve never looked back! These bars are delicious and have creative flavor combinations (but not crazy ones like spicy or savory). I buy the sampler pack whenever it is on sale at Whole Foods and keep a stack of them on deck for emergency hostess gifts! Tony’s is the definition of a little luxury that will make your life better.

  • The chocolate is so good but if you’re buying Tony’s for their slave-free chocolate commitment, their status is currently tainted because their distributor does use space labor..

  • So so good - my favorite is the milk chocolate pretzel bar. Love the quality of the chocolate and the mission.

  • This chocolate is truly delicious and I love their mission. I like to add a bar to gifts.

  • It’s good. They need to replace Hershey bars everywhere with this one.

    Feedback

    🍫

  • Yum!! Love the thickness and rich taste of this chocolate!

    Feedback

    More options with no milk please!

  • How is this chocolate SO GOOD? Love the flavors I wouldn't even think I would like - each one is tasty and delicious. Plus, I love the branding.

  • The chocolate is excellent, particularly the salted varieties.

    Feedback

    It’s too hard to break off the right-sized piece because the chelate is scored with the logo instead of even pieces.

  • good classic chocolate flavors - no frills, high quality chocolate that doesn't rely on gimmicky fill ins to cover anything up. fantastic mission & great product in itself. punchy packaging design, and whimsical sectioning of the chocolate - does get a little annoying for portioning haha but i think it's more fun than annoying for sure. it is a little pricey compared to something like hershey's, but when you consider the quality, it actually is a pretty good price for how much product you get. Definitely makes a good stocking stuffer or small add-on gift.

  • Good enough mission. Product is average and doesn't distinguish itself by any means.

    Feedback

    More innovative offerings? Flavors... Darker chocolate... better design...lots of options

  • Chocolate tastes good but is a bit too thick to bite down on.

  • The best chocolate bars, very worth the price. Delicious and ethical!

  • Delicious chocolate and fun flavors. I love the toffee and pretzel in particular.