Italic reviews and discussion

4.6

93% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Plush, hotel-quality bedding
  • Durable, sleek luggage
  • Soft, substantial cashmere
  • Elegant, well-balanced candles
  • Inconsistent apparel fit
  • Occasionally light candle throw
  • Limited product variety
  • Frequent, prolonged stockouts

Italic earns largely positive reviews for high-quality home goods—especially sateen and percale bedding, plush towels, candles, knives, and sturdy luggage—while clothing and accessories are hit-or-miss. Reviews of Italic highlight luxurious-feeling basics and durable pieces, but recurring drawbacks include inconsistent apparel fit and quality, limited variety with frequent stockouts, occasional slow shipping, and mixed customer service experiences.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

291 reviews and posts

  • Pleasantly surprised by the quality of the products, especially their towels and candles. For a company built on the premise of eliminating the costs associated with purchasing from top notch brands, I found their branding to be top notch.

  • Truly hit or miss. Good mission, not sure how its all executed. Sometimes they nail it and im glad and other times things fit weird or are off. I loved the sunglasses i got.

  • I bought a bunch of things I would honestly recommend to a friend

  • LOVE Italic products. The quality really is very similar to the luxury brands they list on the product pages. They also are priced so well and are always launching new products. The only downside I've experienced with them is that their customer service can be improved. We had an experience where we bought a mattress topper, didn't even open the box, then returned it, and were accused of trying to return a dirty and destroyed mattress topper (which wasn't possible since we didn't even open the box). Outside of that, we've recommended Italic to everyone we know!

  • I got a couple of home furnishing from italic and the quality is pretty good

  • The candles are not as strong as I’d like. However, the wine decanter is great and well loved.

  • Overall, Italic is fine, but I don't know if it's worth it. I have bought a decent number of items from there and enjoyed them. Those items include: my dog's donut bed, her travel carrier, champagne glasses, a meditation cushion, baking pans, my sunglasses, and my teapot. However, every time I have tried the fashion, I have been disappointed. I have yet to keep a single article of clothing because it never fits right. Either it's too big, too small, too short — it's always something. I joined their Bold program with enthusiasm back in 2021 as I loved the idea of premium goods for less. But I don't really feel like it's been that worth it for me. I recently ended my Bold membership because I didn't feel the ROI was worth it. If you're looking for home or pet goods, I would highly recommend theirs as the quality is outstanding. However, for clothing items, I'd suggest looking elsewhere.

  • Been a member for 2+ years and it feels like the quality of the products has gone down - but the price of the items has gone up. I no longer feel like I'm getting a good deal on items, just paying a premium for an unbranded item.

  • A great way to get name-brand quality for reasonable prices, I just haven't had a bad experience with them.

    Feedback

    They still aren't *too* cheap, unless you bargain-hunt through their clearance section. But still pretty excellent.

  • I have made several purchases from Italic for clothing and accessories. While some items have been great, others have fallen short. Nevertheless, I wouldn't say that the brand is terrible, just that some products don't live up to their expectations. Highlights - I have been extremely pleased with the cashmere joggers and premium denim jeans I purchased. The joggers are affordably priced, which aligns with the brand's values, and with the added credits I had, I was able to get an even better deal for the quality. The denim jeans are also reasonably priced and I love the wash (color) which is unique. Plus, they have a 4-way stretch which is impressive given that it doesn't compromise the quality or durability of the fabric. Lowlights - Nothing was truly disappointing, but some of the products and fit were not up to par. For instance, the matching sweatshirt and shorts I bought did not meet my expectations and I probably wouldn't have purchased them if I had the chance to see them in person first.

    Feedback

    All-in-all it truly depends what products you're purchasing, because the quality of the products offered by Italic varies greatly, with some being exceptional and others requiring improvement. Additionally, it's worth noting that popular items may sell out quickly and may not be available for purchase again. On a positive note, Italic rewards its customers by offering credits for writing product reviews.

  • I cannot express how much I love Italic. I have an affinity for luxury items and this brand allows me to fill my wardrobe, home (and even my puppies accessories!) with high-end items at a fraction of the cost. I've ordered cashmere scarves, gloves, hats, workout sets, dog collars, sunglasses and more and have truly been blown away by the quality of every. single. piece.

    Feedback

    Please add more items to your brand!

  • I purchased a couple beauty products and towels through Italic. The retinal and exfoliating toner. Both have worked really well on my sensitive skin. I can't compare to the duped product but overall I like the price point for the quality. The Australian towels are AMAZING. I've tried towels from many different brands including Target and other highly rated brands on Amazon but nothing compares to these. They are lush and have held up really real through many washes. The price point is also very similar to Target, but the quality is significantly better in my opinion. These are our favorite towels.

    Feedback

    Would love to see more product options in general, but overall love this brand.

  • Best pajamas for a great price. Clean, crisp cotton and the right fit. I love them and they are my faves.

    Feedback

    The home goods, like silverware, glasses, etc are not as high quality.

  • Have purchased a few things from italic and they’ve all been great. Most recently, I purchased a backpack from there and absolutely love it. It’s thoughtfully designed and well made.

  • Got some sunglasses about a year ago, they're so great. Awesome quality