GOODLES reviews and discussion

4.4

90% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Creamy, satisfying cheese sauce
  • Al dente, springy noodles
  • High‑protein, fiber‑rich formulation
  • Playful, distinctive flavor variety
  • Inconsistent, muted flavor execution
  • Salty, high‑sodium sauce
  • Small, unsatisfying portions
  • Occasional digestive discomfort reports

GOODLES earns strong reviews as a tastier, higher‑protein, high‑fiber upgrade to classic boxed mac and cheese, with many praising creamy, cheesy flavors (Shella Good, Cheddy Mac, Twist My Parm, Down The Hatch) and al dente noodles. However, reviews flag inconsistent flavor execution (especially Cacio e Pepe and some vegan options), occasional watery or bland sauces, high sodium, small portions, and reports of stomach discomfort; shoppers who prioritize nutrition over pure nostalgia find it a compelling pantry staple, while purists may prefer Annie’s or Kraft.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

372 reviews and posts

  • IT'S DELICIOUS! As an avid Kraft Mac & Cheese connaisseur, I was hesitant to see how Goodles would taste, and let me tell you, they delivered! All the flavors are great (Cheddy Mac & Shella Good are personal faves) and one box is more filling than I anticipated. All branding and feeling of the box is also A+

    Verified purchase

  • I was able to try both the pasta and mac & cheese for free through a rebate website. These are my new go to. I love the variety of flavors of the macaroni and cheese. The pasta tastes good as well. The price is affordable. I will definitely purchase on my own.

  • The boxes of pasta are very small. Even when combining a box with rice there wasn't enough food for my small family. I'd like to see larger packages. What I like about Goodles are as follows: every product is VERY cheesy, cheese is a liquid and not a powder which makes the sauce blend in easily without chunks of powder and the ingredients align with what I like to feed my family (no filler, simple ingredients and no alternative sweeteners).

    Received a free product from GOODLES
  • So happy that I discovered these! I love the taste, they are super easy to prepare and the best part is the high protein content. I've tried a few of their flavors and so far I like all of them!

  • Finally, some fun and adult mac and cheese that isn't full of fake color, flavors and chemicals! I've tried 4 of their flavors and they are tasty. The fact that they're loaded with hidden nutrients and veggies is amazing! I still haven't tried their Beer or Hatch Chile flavor but they're next! The truffle flavor is great!

  • Picked up the Parmesan Goodles as an impulse buy at Target and they were v yummy! An easy-to-make side or meal that tastes a little more elevated than what you expect out of a box? Yes please! I will definitely be grabbing these again.

    Feedback

    Would love some serving tips on the back of the box - ie suggestions to hack or upgrade the noodles into a fancier or more complete meal.

  • Gal Gadot's Gooder Noodles Goodles (my new favorite tongue-twister) Tried out the cacio e pepe one — It was good! I think for anyone who loves box mac & cheese and really values the "better for you" part, this would be amazing but personally probably either going with one of the extremes of super nostalgic box mac & cheese or going homemade but this is definitely a good middle convenience play. Also my brother was a HUGE fan of these, said they were better than 'Annies' and already reordered the Twist my Parm and Shella Good

  • What's not to LOVE!!! The texture and creaminess...oh my! I have tried so many, and they are each so worthy. A wholesome upgrade to mac & cheese: rich, protein-packed, family-friendly—just keep an eye on sodium.

  • I don’t really eat mac and cheese myself, but my husband does, and GOODLES makes me feel a lot better about having this category of food in the house. It’s packed with protein and fiber, uses better ingredients, and still delivers on the comfort and flavor he loves. It’s a win-win: he gets comfort food, and I feel good knowing it’s a more thoughtful version. We always keep a few boxes stocked in the pantry.

  • I just bought it and ate it! The dreamy and creamy is soooooo good. Taste better than Kraft. I need to buy more before the hype gets real and they're sold out .Boasts 14 grams of protein, 6 grams of fiber, and 21 nutrients from plants.

  • I love Goodles mac & cheese they have flavors that I do not typically see in boxed mac & cheese. The texture of pasta is great and the cheese flavor is mild. My favorite part about it is the high protein and fiber content.

  • I picked up a case of Goodles on a #thingdrop and have been charmed by both the nostalgia and the work to make it "healthy." If for some reason you can't bring yourself to buy regular Kraft or Annie's mac and cheese, this will satisfy both your hunger and your desire for more goodness in your food.

    Feedback

    I would never buy these full prices.

  • We love Goodles in our family! There are so many varieties of Goodles and I love the ingredients. I feel good knowing that’s what my daughter is getting for her Mac and Cheese rather than some unhealthy brand!

  • If you served me these in a pinch I wouldn't think twice that they were loaded with protein, fiber, and plant nutrients. The pasta texture can lean a big mushy if you overcook them, but the flavor was good, and they are infinitely customizable.

  • I've had white truffle mac and cheese before and it was quite heavy and creamy tasting. Fast forward years later, and obviously I had to try Goodles' Here Comes Truffle! It did taste less heavy and creamy, however the cheese to pasta ratio in the box was a little odd..maybe because it's been awhile since I've made boxed mac and cheese, but I was hoping it would be 50/50 apples to apples. Would try again the tried and true Cheddy Mac!

    Feedback

    Make more flavors and more accessible at mainstream supermarkets!

  • A very good boxed mac and cheese! All the flavors are tasty and I really like the added protein benefit. My favorite flavor was definitely the twist my parm (goes really well with the Zesti parm hot sauce). But at the end of the day I do think the biggest issue is the price, it's not adding enough benefit to justify the price per box.

    Feedback

    Bring down the price, otherwise it's a great product

    Verified purchase

  • Goodles has interesting flavors for pasta, which comes packed with high protein and fiber. The pasta are rich in taste, just a bit different from conventional pasta. Given the high fiber content, it is best to drink lots of water when eating this pasta (Your tummy would thank you hours later).

  • This is our favorite brand of macaroni. And we’ve tried a dozen. Love the protein content and the amount of cheesiness. Also love the nostalgic feel the main noodle one is. It gives a throwback feel but much healthier.

  • I really liked Goodles' products! I've tried some of their Mac n cheese flavors and I think they are not only good quality products but also tasted pretty good. I also liked that they are made using great ingredients.

  • Honestly super fast making this Mac and cheese. Don’t have much experience making these either. I will say that the food came out a little bit salty in my opinion but it’s no big deal. Will probably purchase again