Glossier reviews and discussion

4.2

85% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Effortless, buildable formulas
  • Compliment‑magnet signature fragrance
  • Iconic, intuitive packaging
  • Natural, seamless finishes
  • Sheer, short‑wear pigments
  • Inconsistent reformulation outcomes
  • Drying, quick‑spent mascara/brow
  • Fussy, fragile packaging

Glossier earns mixed reviews: the brand excels at effortless “no-makeup makeup” with standouts like Boy Brow, Cloud Paint, Lash Slick, Stretch Concealer, and the Glossier You fragrance, but several users find the skincare average and some makeup too sheer to last. Reviews praise easy, finger-friendly application, flattering shades, and iconic packaging, while noting weaknesses such as reformulations (Balm Dotcom, You), limited coverage and pigment, mascara/brow products drying quickly, packaging flaws, and scent or longevity concerns with You.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

2,460 reviews and posts

  • I like Glossier! Some great quality products for reasonable prices, and the packaging/brand/etc are fun. I like that it's a skin first brand. I love the cloud paint and the boy brow the most, I also have an exfoliant I like

  • The Boy Brow is one of the best eyebrow shapers I've ever used. I get the brown tinted pomade and it makes my brows look fuller and shapes them beautifully. I'm also a fan of the Milky Oil makeup remover as well. It doesn't dry out my skin and it works well.

    Feedback

    I think it's a little overpriced for some of the skincare ingredients. There are better brands that are cheaper, but there are, without a doubt, a few of Glossier's makeup products that I love and use daily.

  • Doesn’t need much introduction. Everything from Glossier feels like an experience, from the packaging, the products, the stores, their content. I’ve tried and continue to use multiple products from Glossier, the Super Bounce serum is amazing under foundation, Futuredew is my hero product, the balm dot com in birthday comes everywhere with me, and the stretch concealer is great too, not too drying.

    Feedback

    Less wasteful packaging!

  • The product were so so. Nothing completely wowed me. I think Glossier has amazing packaging, brand identity, and marketing but the products aren't anything that hasn't been done before. The products work okay... it's just that you can't really build up coverage or color so the "no makeup makeup" is really isn't adjustable where as other makeup IS.

    Feedback

    The products seem watered down and when applied, it doesn't last long or is barley noticeable. I understand that the concept of the brand is "no makeup makeup"... but I would rather use makeup that is "makeup makeup" but then just sheer it out myself so that I can get two looks in one product. I think there are Glossier fans who like the branding and would like to see the brand offer makeup that is also buildable for makeup fans who love to wear "makeup makeup".

  • I’ve tried a few Glossier makeup items. The eyeliner smudged on my under-eye, so I returned it. Their customer service is so quick and friendly. The Generation G lipsticks are tricky. They’re really dry your lips out, so you have to apply a thick coat of lip balm before applying. Don’t even attempt in the winter through; they’re just too drying. The Ultralips are more hydrating. Neither of these lip options last, which is fine since they don’t promise that. Love the Lid Paints. So easy to use and have that soft, pretty watercolor effect on the eyes. I always get compliments when I wear them, but they dry out so quickly. They phased out Glossier Play, but I bought some Color Slide eyeliners from that line. Usually, pencil eyeliners smear all over my under-eyes, but these have some restraint. Maybe I’ll have a little smudging at the end of the day, but they’re easy to wipe off.

    Feedback

    Would be great if you could bring back some items from Glossier Play, like the Color Slide eyeliners.

  • When Glossier first launched I was really excited about Boy Brow, but over the years I've found other brands to be superior in quality. I like their Body Hero line, the lotion is not heavy on my skin. Their costumer service team is very proactive if you have shipping issues.

  • Overpriced for decent products that use same exact ingredients as drugstore brands. You're paying for a brand experience, not an innovative product.

  • I mean... boy brow forever. Consistently great products coming from the Glossier pipeline. And it's affordable!

  • Haven't tried many Glossier products, but Balm Dot Com is amazing!

    Feedback

    The sizes of the products can be pretty inconsistent — brow boy, for example, looks like a sample/half the size of a normal product!

  • Tried their solution and cleanser. Both seem fine but didn't seem too different from other, more affordable options at the drug store.

  • I love all of their lip products - balm dotcom, generation g, and ultralip. I like how the website shows photos of the products on different skin tones. I always get compliments when I wear the perfume. Boy brow could be a great product for you, but only if you already have thick brows to begin with. The sunscreen is pretty good - it is clear so it doesn't leave a white cast on your skin after application. Also, as many people have complained about before, the skincare and foundation type products are for people who have great skin to begin with (very little to no coverage).

    Feedback

    Honestly? I don't want to like Glossier. There are problems going on behind the scenes that make me want to stop supporting them, so I truly hope that they are actually making an effort to change.

  • I've used the solution toner, boy brow, balm.com, and skin tint, and I really like them all but not obsessed. I would try out more of their fun makeup products but probably won't use their skincare again since I just think there's better options out there.

    Feedback

    I feel like the skin tint is only good on already clear skin as it has little to no coverage and can stick to dry skin. Love boy brow although it barely lasts me 2 months before drying out so I stopped buying it.

  • 3 years in and I'm like, "why can't I find another brand that's outpaced my love for Glossier yet?". Huge fan of the perfume and cloud paint.

  • Glossier is a brand that you either love or hate. I personally love all of their products - from skincare to body care to makeup. Some of my favorites include: Lash slick: truly the only mascara that doesn’t flake or smudge Super pure: a gentle way to keep skin clear without any harsh exfoliants After baume: for when you really need that thick layer of moisture and protection I think everyone can find at least one thing from glossier that makes it to their “top shelf”. PS: glossier, if you see this, bring back zit stick!

  • like most girls - i’ve been trying to find products to achieve that dewy, glazed look. i’d honestly heard about futuredew for a while, but was wanting to try cheaper products to see if i could get the same look/feel. let me tell you - just spend the money and get this product! i use it as a last step of skincare - after serums, moisturizer, etc and i really do look so glowy. it’s also a good starting base for makeup. in the summer, i can get away with using futuredew and then adding concealer and blush on top. it has just the right amount of tint to blur imperfections. i have somewhat sensitive skin and haven’t had any issues with it causing blemishes or breakouts or clogging my pores. if you’ve been thinking about buying this - just do it!

  • AHHHH. Words need not describe. I've been a fan since it started. Since middle school. I had a set they don't even make any more: the Milky Jelly Cleanser, the Priming Moisturizer, and the Balm Dotcom. (holy grail), And I used Boy Brow with a way-too-heavy hand. I will always be a part of the cult.

  • Love Boy Brow. The spoolie is juuuuust small enough that it makes the product super easy to use. It also has pretty good staying power and won't budge once applied. The black color looks natural and gives the perfect "clean girl" brows. It is pricier than other drugstore alternatives, but the ease makes it worth it, imo.

  • Some products are nice but the only thing I repurchase is the mascara.

  • Balm Dot Com is my favorite lip balm (unflavored), the updated tip makes it way easier to use. Their customer service is amazing as well.