Staycoolnyc reviews and discussion

4.5

86% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Plush brushed interior comfort
  • Nostalgic puff-paint graphic appeal
  • Tight stitching garment construction
  • Vibrant colors with wash durability
  • Inconsistent length-to-width proportions
  • Narrow body with limited stretch
  • Undersized kangaroo pocket design
  • Sizing unpredictability for oversized fit

Staycoolnyc earns positive reviews, with customers praising its soft, midweight hoodies, nostalgic “Crayon” puff-paint graphics, and durable construction that stays vibrant after washes; the brand is good for comfortable, true-to-size or intentionally oversized fits. Reviews also flag inconsistent proportions—longer lengths with small kangaroo pockets, narrower body and limited stretch—and occasional sizing surprises, which may frustrate those seeking a classic loose drape.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

15 reviews and posts

  • I purchased a hoodie through a Thingdrop and was definitely impressed with the quality and unique designs the brand has. I bought it for my husband, and he found the sweatshirt to be super comfortable and fit true to size. He gets complimented on it everyone he wears it!

  • I've been eyeing STAYCOOL Chillwear for a few years and was excited to score this hoodie via Thingdrop! The designs are so nostalgic and make me happy. I love what this brand is doing:) I can't wait to wear my hoodie when we get a break in the weather- it's a nice midweight hoodie. I like wearing oversized hoodies, so I ordered an XL; it's perfect. The quality of the garment is top-notch, with tight stitching, a brushed interior that makes it super soft and comfortable, and the logo is vibrant and fun! The color combination is fantastic. I didn't know I needed a cream-colored hoodie in my hoodie rotation until this arrived. I wasn't sure if I'd like the cream color; I thought it could look dingy, but I was totally wrong. Did I mention the Crayon Logo is...PUFF PAINT? I love everything about this garment! Shipping was lightning fast- less than a week. Overall I'm impressed with STAYCOOL, and if you like Chillwear and want to feel like you're a kid again, you'll love this brand too!

    Verified purchase

  • I am not usually a fan of prints for clothing. The print in the picture is super cute so I was bummed that this was not going to be the one offered. However, when I saw that the one offered in Thingdrop was geared towards crayons, I was sold! I love all things coloring! I ordered a size up since I like my hoodies to be a bit more comfy rather than fitted. It definitely gives off a comfy, oversized feel. The color is interesting, but the design is actually a bit raised and more like puffy. It gives off a cool textural difference to the fabric of the sweater. I am afraid to wear it since it is a lighter color and I do not want it to get ruined. My only ding on the stars is because the normal price is expensive! If I want to buy another one and for my stepson, we are looking at $200.

    Thingdrop Tester
  • Comfortable and was quickly delivered to my home. Packing was simple and efficient. If I order again I'll make sure to size up so it's a loose fit

    Verified purchase

  • The quality is great, the print doesn't look like it will fade after washing, I like that there are no tassels hanging from the hood, and the fit is still fitted but baggy (I sized up for a roomier fit). tbh it is July and like 85° outside, so I haven't worn it much but will report back after a few washes with an update

    Verified purchase

  • I worked for one of Staycoolnyc's popup stores in nyc in college. The brand's attention to detail is really thoughtful and I love the vintage vibe to the branding --- they've been doing it long before it became trendy. I still wear my sweatshirts from the brand all these years later.

    Friends with Staycoolnyc
  • I love the hoodie I got from the ThingDrop. It's really comfortable & I love the design on the front. Looking forward to getting a lot more use out of it in the fall!

    Verified purchase

  • I purchased a sweatshirt as part of a thingtesting drop. The design is cute - more similar to puffy paint. However, the fit isn’t totally spot on. I ordered up a size for a baggier fit, however, it seems like it just got longer. Additionally, the kangaroo pocket seems like it wasn’t designed to match a larger size (it’s like they kept a small size on and xl sweatshirt). Because of the discount I received, I happy with the product, but would have been disappointed to pay full price.

    Verified purchase

  • Overall this is a very comfortable hoodie. I'll put it through a more thorough test this Fall when the weather cools down. Very soft and I love the fabric.

    Verified purchase

  • Super soft sweatshirts with fun designs. Runs a little long.

    Verified purchase

  • Love the sweatshirt it fits just right not too big or too tight. The sweatshirt feels very comfortable def would get other products from them in the future

    Verified purchase

  • I got a sweatshirt as part of a thingdrop and it is very comfy. Super warm and soft, great now that the weather is cooler!

    Verified purchase

  • Received the hoodie through a Thingdrop and absolutely love it! It has a comfortable oversized feel and the design is simple but cute. My go to travel and lounge hoodie!

    Verified purchase

  • This sweatshirt is very cute. It's soft inside and out. A little more narrow and not as stretchy as I thought it would be. I expected a looser fit, but overall I like the quality.

    Verified purchase