4.6
94% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Tony's Chocolonely
Tony's Chocolonely reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Creamy, luxurious mouthfeel chocolate
- Inventive, memorable flavor lineup
- Chunky, satisfying bar format
- Ethical, mission-driven sourcing
- Overly sweet chocolate profiles
- Thick, hard-to-break pieces
- Inconsistent caramel texture hardness
- Limited higher-cacao dark options
Tony’s Chocolonely earns strong reviews for rich, creamy chocolate, inventive flavors like Milk Caramel Sea Salt, Dark Almond Sea Salt, and Dark Milk Pretzel Toffee, plus mission-driven, fair-trade sourcing. Reviews also flag drawbacks: some bars taste overly sweet or bland to dark‑chocolate loyalists, the thick, uneven pieces are hard to break and share, and concerns appear about heavy metals in certain dark varieties and salt intensity in caramel bars.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
1,927 reviews and posts
4y ago
I had the good fortune of someone leaving a bar behind at my house. It was like finding $5 in a pair of jeans that you didn’t know was there, but even better. If I had to choose one thing to eat for ever this would be at the the top of the list.
It's just good, reliable chocolate. Hard to resist when any store has it by the checkout. Great flavor, great texture, high quality, well-sourced, real-life Wonka vibes from the branding...no notes. Sea salt caramel? That's the one.
Pretty good chocolate, I've only tried the milk chocolate and a few others but they were a bit sweet for me. They chocolate bar itself is pretty big.
MY. FAVORITE. CHOCOLATE. EVER. I will never, ever, EVER, reach for another chocolate brand ever because this chocolate brand tops them all. The texture and taste of this chocolate is just perfect. If you are looking for a more ethically sourced version of the velvety Dairy Milk, reach for this brand instead! The transparency of their brand is also cool because they talk about it right inside the wrapper!
Feedback
I would for their mini-size versions to be more available. I would also love it they were to expand their products to things like hot chocolate and stuff. Honestly, I'm reaching here. I don't know what they could improve on because this brand is killing it!
4y ago
Not only is this amazing tasting chocolate, but the price and brand mission make it outstanding! Don't let the packaging fool you. This bar could easily sell for half the size and double the price.
Feedback
A lot of the seasonal flavors and packaging (christmas calendars) can only be found in the Netherlands or the UK.
4y ago
Delicious and with a great mission. What's not to love.
4y ago
I tried their dark milk chocolate variety. You do get that bitterness of dark chocolate & creamy taste of milk chocolate. But it's just as sweet as a milk chocolate.
Feedback
I wish it was less sweet.
LOVED the Christmas peppermint flavour....so so good! Wish they would make it a permanent addition!
Feedback
The bar is super thick which is great, but the different size and shape pieces make it quite hard to break apart.
4y ago
delicious taste, fun packaging and worthy donations. all in all it's good fun.
Feedback
the shape of the chocolate bar itself is a bit irritating to break up into eatable chunks or to bite down on. it's also expensive but if people are being fairly compensated then that's not annoying!
I had the dark chocolate bar, and that alone was tasty enough that anyone I came in contact with that day got a piece. The ethical making of the chocolate makes it even better.
Feedback
Make it easier to share! My friends and I like getting the larger bars and splitting, though it's not as easy to break apart as we would like.
Delicious and good for the planet and people!!
Feedback
Nothing, they’ve got a great selection - maybe do more dark chocolate varieties
I’m obsessed, what a fun experience to eat this! The bars are of a generous size and the pieces can be broken off into really fun shapes. The branding is also super fun (you also have the option to design your own wrapping) and I love their mission and ethics. Would definitely recommend purchasing!
Feedback
I'd love if there were more flavors!
4y ago
I am not a big chocolate fan but Tonys is a gamechanger. I originally discovered this after seeing one of my friends share the chocolate bar on her Instagram story and I was initially intrigued by the packaging and then after tasting it, I was converted! My favourite flavour is salted caramel. But I have also tried the wafer flavour (also fab). This product also made for a great little stocking filler at Christmas. If you haven't tried this chocolate bar, you are missing out!
Feedback
Tony's marketing features a story about paying their working fairly which was also a real driver in purchasing as these bars are not cheap!
4y ago
So delicious AND ethical. I’m obsessed with Tony’s.
Obsessed with this chocolate. Delicious. Tons of flavors and a great business model.
4y ago
Delicious. Love that they're chunky sized and now available in a lot of different outlets.
Feedback
More dark chocolate options please!
Truly the best tasting chocolate across the board. Normally I’m not a milk chocolate fan but they have turned me into a believer- especially the caramel cookie.
Delicious!!
Really testy, especially for chocolate fans ;)
huge bars and tasty!!