Rothy's reviews and discussion

Rothy’s definitely feel like an elevated everyday shoe. They have some weight to them and the fabric is a really nice, sturdy almost knit fabric. They run true to size, they are really comfortable. I do think socks are essential because the fabric on top isn’t soft, it’s a more hard knit and I bet that would rub really uncomfortably on the top of the foot and toes after a bit. I wouldn’t wear them to stomp around a city but would wear them to the airport and out on errands. I do think they look like an elevated shoe but also a slipper at the same time which throws me off sometimes. I don’t know if it’s because I got just black and a color or pattern would have been better but because of that I don’t reach for them as often even my Ugg tasmans but that’s also probably just a personal problem!

I actually have several pair of Rothy's, however, my favorite design are the ballet flats. I have the ballet flats in both black and navy. I love these shoes and have had them for years. They look like brand new! They really are worth the money and have held up under many different weather conditions in Pittsburgh, PA. They are great for us therapists who like to have an extra pair of flats in the office just in case out feet need a rest from any uncomfortable shoes we might have tried to wear - my Rothy’s are always near-by!

I really like my clogs! They’re the perfect shoe for wearing around the house. I’ve had them for a couple years, and they’ve held up well. They’re very comfortable, and I appreciate that they’re machine washable. I live in the south, and they are a bit warm for the summer but perfect for the colder months!

I have the brown square mary jane flats. seriously so comfortable. i always get compliments on them. i've worn them working on my feet all day as well as out and about traveling in a new city. they're also very easy to take care of and clean as well.

I have owned three pairs of Rothy's shoes the slip on sneakers, lace up and the ballet flats. I purchased them all at different times around 2023-2025. Since I work in health care I wanted some comfortable shoes that I could wear in clinic and also machine wash. My favorite shoes of the three that I own are the slip ons because they are more versatile and even comfier with insoles. I was not a huge fan of the flats, I didn't feel like they were very flattering on my feet and lacked support. I purchased the pointed ballet flats and had to return those twice because the sizing was off and unflattering silhouette. However, my sisters bought their own pairs of rounded ballet flats after I purchased mine and ended up loving them and wore them just about every day. I ended up giving my ballet flats to my sister because I was not wearing them.

I can't say enough about these clogs! They are my number 1 go to whether it is to wear on the way to work, to a soccer game, grocery shopping or out with friends. The inside is so soft and is great with or without socks. A truly must have!

I absolutely love Rothys! By far some of the most comfy shoes i have ever owned! I just got the super cute new mary janes but i also own a pair of the sneakers. I used to avoid ballet flats because i hate wearing invisible socks but also no one wants smelly shoes and feet! Being able to throw these into the washing machine is a game changer. Sizing can vary between styles sometimes. They are a bit pricey but so worth it!

Super comfy and I love that they're washable! They lose one star for feeling a bit flimsy and lacking any sort of arch support, but they've become one of my go-tos for a stylish, easy-to-wear loafer. Lots of their styles are office-appropriate too, which is great. Would definitely recommend them. Slightly overpriced.

Long time fan! This brand has continued to evolve in all the right directions. I love that the shoes can be dressed up and down, machine washed and are as comfortable as they claim to be. I’m a customer forever.

So comfy right out of the box and surprisingly supportive for how lightweight they are. Easy to clean and hold up well over time. I wear them constantly, especially when I’m on my feet all day and I always get compliments on them.

These were actually a recommended to me, and boy did they deliver! I am in my 40’s and cannot wear “cute” shoes anymore. These are comfy and cute! The cushioning is amazing! So comfortable for all day.

Neutral, unobtrusive shoes that hit the mark for a business casual workplace. I had purchased two pairs of the point-toe flats previously. Just added the driver mocs and the clogs. I think they are overpriced for the quality - it’s great that they are washable, but the material wears out so quickly, it’s not like the washability extends their usable life.

Over the years I’ve had so many different Rothy’s, from pointy toe to ballet flat to loafer and slippers. They were my go-to office shoe. Love the mission of the company, the replaceable inserts, the flexibility for ease of travel packing, and the variety in style. However, after having children, like many women my feet got wider and with age needing more support in my shoes, I find Rothy’s no longer give me the support I need. I still wear the slippers, but due to the flexible top material my foot will often slip off the side edge of the slipper which is risky for ankles and stability. I’ve kept a few pairs as backups just in case I need a fun business casual shoe, but for the most part I’ve given them away to friends. I just wish they had more support.

I have purchased Rothy’s before but the clogs were new to me. Since I have never owned clogs there was a short period of adjustment but so far I am loving them and the fact that you can wash them makes them functional as well as stylish.

I’ve had my Rothy’s for well over 5 years now and I still get compliments on them. Love that they use recycled plastic and can be tossed in the washing machine. Great for travel as they’re flexible and lightweight. I might go up in size next time as the point kind of squishes my toes. The front of the sole was coming off a little bit, but shoe glue fixed it!

From my wife: I’ve been a fan of Rothy’s since the company first opened. My favorite part about the shoes (aside from being very cute) are that they are washable (and still look good after being washed!), made from recycled bottles, and overall, pretty comfortable. I have relatively low tolerance for uncomfortable shoes, and while I can wear many of these flats for hours, it would be hard for me to walk 20k steps without being a bit uncomfortable in these flats by the end of the day. Though I wouldn’t say that any have suffered heavy abuse, all of my pairs of Rothy’s still look good, even after 5+ years. The comfort of the shoes really varies depending on the pair (the Clogs feel like house slippers, I wouldn’t recommend wearing the slip on sneakers without socks, and the flats are more comfy than most). Overall, I am a fan, but I try to buy them when there is some type of sale available, as they’re relatively pricey.

The best thing about Rothy's is that every shoe I've purchased from them is comfy right out of the box. You never have to break them in. I've ordered two flats and one clog and I constantly finding myself grabbing them because they're so comfy. I tried the Birkenstock clog and Rothy's clog and I'll never go back — Rothy's is hands-down wayyy more comfortable. Plus, they're super flexible and easy to pack. Absolutely worth the higher price tag.

I’m so glad I discovered Rothy’s. I only wish I had purchased more initially. I was hesitant because I wondered if the material would hold up well - and it totally does. I’m a lifelong Birkenstock wearer, so this was a leap for me. So glad I tried them. They’re super comfy, go with everything, and I even love the little blue signature stripe in the back. Going to get more for sure.

I like these but I think they are overpriced. I purchased a pair of the point flats. The fabric material of the shoe hugs your feet and they hold on well. I particularly like them for travel and work conferences as they’re stretchy. Just wish they had better arch support. As an overall, they come in fun colors and prints so there’s likely something for everyone!

I got my first pair of Rothy’s (the casual clog) about a week ago and love them. I wanted a house shoe with plenty of support, and these fit the bill. They’re similar to the Birkenstock Boston, but much more comfortable - the Birkenstock sole gives me blisters if I don’t wear socks, and it has a weird ledge at the toe that also gives me blisters, which Rothy’s doesn’t have! I love the look and feel of the merino wool. Plus, they’re washable, so if I were to wear them out (I probably will, I love the look!) I can just throw them in the washing machine and they’re good to wear around my apartment again.