Thingtesting Logo

Rothy's

4.1 • 112 Reviews

Rothy's uses recycled plastic to create unique and affordable shoes.

rothys.comArrow up right
Shop
Reward
10% reward
Rothy's Reviews

4.1

Rothy’s earns largely positive reviews for comfort straight out of the box, washable knit uppers, and versatile styles like The Point, loafers, sneakers, and clogs, but opinions split on fit and long‑term comfort. Reviewers praise durability for years of wear and easy cleaning, yet cite narrow toe boxes, inconsistent sizing, thin soles with minimal arch support, odor retention, and occasional wear issues as drawbacks.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Rewards
Shop
Review
Reward
10% reward

Join to earn a 10% reward

Join Thingtesting to earn a cash-based commission when you shop and review Rothy's using our link.

By continuing, you agree to Thingtesting’s Terms of Service, Community Guidelines, and the use of data in the Privacy Policy

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 113

  • 6h ago

    I’ve been wanting to try a pair of Rothy’s for quite awhile. I don’t really like Birkenstocks that much so I’m glad Rothy’s makes a clog but better. I first purchased a pair in Butternut- I love all the colors but I wanted something neutral to wear with everything. They are so comfortable and cute. I’ve walked a mile in these clogs and my feet don’t hurt at all. I like that you can wash them- I haven’t tried it yet but I like the option. I have scuffed the front but the mark came out with a damp cloth. I’ve had these clogs for a year and they still look brand new. I just recently bought a second pair (in Toffee- Raffia knit) ! I highly recommend if you want a clog that’s comfortable like a Birkenstock but also feels like a slipper

  • 1y ago

    Over the years I’ve had so many different Rothy’s, from pointy toe to ballet flat to loafer and slippers. They were my go-to office shoe. Love the mission of the company, the replaceable inserts, the flexibility for ease of travel packing, and the variety in style. However, after having children, like many women my feet got wider and with age needing more support in my shoes, I find Rothy’s no longer give me the support I need. I still wear the slippers, but due to the flexible top material my foot will often slip off the side edge of the slipper which is risky for ankles and stability. I’ve kept a few pairs as backups just in case I need a fun business casual shoe, but for the most part I’ve given them away to friends. I just wish they had more support.

  • 1y ago

    I’m so glad I discovered Rothy’s. I only wish I had purchased more initially. I was hesitant because I wondered if the material would hold up well - and it totally does. I’m a lifelong Birkenstock wearer, so this was a leap for me. So glad I tried them. They’re super comfy, go with everything, and I even love the little blue signature stripe in the back. Going to get more for sure.

    Verified purchase

  • 9mo ago

    Rothy’s definitely feel like an elevated everyday shoe. They have some weight to them and the fabric is a really nice, sturdy almost knit fabric. They run true to size, they are really comfortable. I do think socks are essential because the fabric on top isn’t soft, it’s a more hard knit and I bet that would rub really uncomfortably on the top of the foot and toes after a bit. I wouldn’t wear them to stomp around a city but would wear them to the airport and out on errands. I do think they look like an elevated shoe but also a slipper at the same time which throws me off sometimes. I don’t know if it’s because I got just black and a color or pattern would have been better but because of that I don’t reach for them as often even my Ugg tasmans but that’s also probably just a personal problem!

    Verified purchase

View all 113 reviews

Alternatives

What is Rothy's?

Rothy's uses recycled plastic to create unique and affordable shoes.

In their own words

Rothy's is a sustainable fashion brand that makes stylish and comfortable shoes and bags from recycled materials, including marine-bound ocean plastic. We're committed to reducing our environmental impact and practicing both sustainable and ethical manufacturing practices every step of the way. Our shoes and bags are made from materials that have been diverted from landfills and oceans, and we use a near zero-waste manufacturing process in our wholly-owned factory. Our shoes and bags are machine-washable and made to last, so you can feel good about looking and feeling your best while also helping the planet. Plus, we offer a wide variety of styles to choose from, so you can find the perfect pair for any occasion.