Start a review
Milk Bar
3.67 • 214 Reviews
Milk Bar makes one-of-a-kind-treats and baked goods delivered fresh anywhere in the USA.
What is Thingtesting?
Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.
3.7
Average rating from 214 users
68%
Recommend to a friend
Milk Bar Reviews
2 days ago
Experience
The birthday cake was wayyyy too sweet for my personal taste. However the brand is excellent when it comes to marketing and aesthetics and making drool worthy, I need this now, posts on social media.
Useful review?
2 days ago
Experience
The taste was ok, however it tasted a little too processed for my liking.
Useful review?
2 days ago
Experience
Not for me. I think the marketing hype is better than the product. It’s not bad but for the price you can probably get better at a local bakery.
Useful review?
13 days ago
Experience
I personally love the cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookies but they were out of stock at my bodega so I got these candy cane cornflake chocolate chip cookies instead as a gift for my mom. At $5.99 its not a terrible price point. But I'm wondering if they're any good? Seems like a good batch to give out for the holidays. My mother seemed pretty happy with them.
Good for gifts 🎁Fun unboxing 📦Tasty 😋
Useful review?
7 days ago
👀No discount
Experience
my favorite ice cream ever. run don't walk.The cornflake is my end all be all favorite flavor.
Useful review?
22 days ago
Experience
I received the Milk Bar Cookie Sampler as a gift and it was fantastic! The cookies were very unique and delicious. I enjoyed the different flavor combos. The best was the cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow, the different textures made it mind-blowing though a tad too sweet.
Feedback
Later down the line I found Milk Bar cookies at the grocery store. There is a big difference in quality between the cookies that were bought directly off the website to the grocery store Milk Bar brand. The grocery store cookies were just okay, the texture also was quite off when compared to the delivered ones.
Fun unboxing 📦Tasty 😋
Useful review?
25 days ago
Experience
I bought their cookie when I was in the Momofuko restaurant in Toronto, back int he days. The same year they did this TV show on Netflix. It was nice, trendy, but nothing more than that! I remember it was quite a splurge for a cookie haha But I took one as a gift for my boyfriend and he was happy of the small gesture!
Good for gifts 🎁Cool look & feelTasty 😋Luxury
Useful review?
7 days ago
Experience
I love Milk Bar! I've been impressed with their ability to maintain the quality of their products as they've expanded significantly. My favorites? The cereal milk ice cream (with corn flakes, of course), the cake truffles (both flavors), and compost cookie. My love for Milk Bar aligns with my other snack loves -- Betty Crocker boxed cakes, v sweet candy, and cookie dough. If you don't like those things then Milk Bar might not be right for you. One final word of caution -- don't eat too much in one sitting. You WILL get a belly ache.
Tasty 😋
Useful review?
8 days ago
Experience
I don't get the hype. The products are cute but the taste just average. Too expensive for what it is; have had both fresh in store in NYC and mass produced packaged.
Useful review?
13 days ago
Experience
Packaging is nice but not worth the money.
Fun unboxing 📦
Useful review?