Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

Birthday Cake Pint is a guilty pleasure but I love it! High quality, variety and unique flavor. Tastes super fresh!

Obsessed with Jeni’s, so many unique flavors and such great quality plus always love some gluten free dairy free options!

This company has so many fun flavors, it was hard to choose which one to try because they all sounded so good. I ended up getting the Boston Cream Pie flavor and basically ate half the pint when I got home. It was so good! There was chocolate syrup swirled throughout and the base cream flavor was addicting. My favorite part was how there were tiny cake pieces evenly in the ice cream so I always had a good amount each bite. Definitely want to try more flavors!

YUM! Always dynamic in flavor profile and a go-to all summer long and frankly winter too! Can't go wrong and if you are torn the team at any Jeni's shop is more than patient to help with the taste testing process.

My favorite widely distributed ice ream. Quality mix-ins and intensely creamy flavors.

Jeni's Ice cream lives up to the hype! I tried the Gooey Cake Batter flavor, and wow. I was impressed! I've always loved cake batter ice cream and this took it too a whole new level. High quality ice cream, great flavors, great ingredients.

Ordered some as a gift. The website was easy to use and there were so many choices. I liked that you could order for something to arrive ASAP, or for a specific date in the future. It made giving the ice cream as a gift much easier. The flavors were unusual and interesting. Some were really great and some were just okay, but they were all more exciting than what I could find in a local store.

Unique flavors and a fun treat

I really wish these weren't so expensive. The ice cream is definitely delicious, but there are equally delicious ice creams out there that cost a fraction of what Jeni's cost. I also do not live close to a Jeni's location, and many times when I've seen the pints for sale at the local grocery story they are covered in that frost bite that lets you know it's been in that freezer for ages. Given the cost, I wouldn't buy those packages because I would hate for the product to be bad and be out that money.

Jeni’s ice cream is amazing. The bramble berry crumble is my favorite!

So tasty, so creative! There hasn't been a flavor I haven't been pleasantly surprised by

I am lactose intolerant and will often reach for Jeni's (w/ Lactaid, duh.) It is so creamy and rich across almost all flavors, but anything they have with brown sugar is so good, hard to tell that it is "mass produced"

Obsessed. Every flavor is better than the last! My family has their little bowls of brambleberry crisp almost every single night. They ship super super well, and their sets of 6 pints are our go to gifts.

I first went to their shop in Atlanta and it was some of the best ice cream I've ever had! Glad it's widely distributed now.

Yes expensive. But does it spark joy? Also yes. The flavors are so spot-on. It’s a luxurious bite, but

I've only tried one flavor, but I found both the taste and texture to be fantastic. I also really appreciate that they don't use unnecessary ingredients or stabilizers. It is a little bit expensive, but that's to be expected.

Very good ice cream and very interesting flavors

Heck yeah, give me more fun flavors to pick out and choose from at the grocery store. This ice cream is truly so delicious and packs so much flavor into each pint. It is a little more costly, but completely worth it!

Jeni’s ice cream is wonderful! They’ve got some funky flavors that have a great taste & are a great late night snack. The BROWN BUTTER ALMOND BRITTLE & CHOCOLATE are my absolute favorite. Affordable pricing.

I enjoy the bold flavors and smooth texture of this ice cream. The wide variety of very creative flavor options allows something for everyone. I also appreciate that the underlying ice cream recipe was crafted by a James Beard award-winning chef.