4.7
95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Jeni's Ice Creams
4.7 • 1,848 Reviews
•

4.7
95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Jeni’s Ice Creams delivers intensely creamy, high‑quality pints with inventive, true‑to‑label flavors—reviews repeatedly praise standouts like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, and Darkest Chocolate—so yes, the brand works and is good. Reviews also flag drawbacks: pints are very expensive, flavor “hits” can vary, some find certain flavors too sweet or icy, and grocery pints can suffer freezer burn or shelf‑life issues; nonetheless, the rich texture, unique combinations, and strong dairy‑free/gluten‑free options make it a compelling splurge.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
20d ago
Jeni’s Basque Cheesecake with Brambleberry Jam Ice Cream is such a unique and delicious flavor! The creamy, tangy cheesecake taste pairs perfectly with the sweet, fruity brambleberry jam. I love the balance of rich and tart flavors that makes it feel like enjoying a slice of cheesecake in ice cream form. A perfect treat for anyone who loves fruity desserts!

20d ago
Jeni’s Brown Butter Almond Brittle Ice Cream is rich, creamy, and full of delicious nutty flavor! I love the toasted brown butter notes paired with crunchy almond brittle for the perfect balance of sweet and salty. The combination of smooth ice cream and satisfying crunch makes every bite feel indulgent. A must-try for anyone who loves caramelized, nutty desserts!

20d ago
Jeni’s High Five Candy Bar Ice Cream is the ultimate treat for anyone who loves a candy bar-inspired dessert! I love the rich, creamy texture and the delicious combination of sweet, chocolatey flavors with satisfying candy bar elements. It feels indulgent and fun, making it perfect for when I’m craving something extra decadent straight from the freezer!

20d ago
Jeni’s Buttercream Birthday Cake Ice Cream tastes like a birthday celebration in every bite! It has a sweet, creamy cake batter flavor with rich buttercream notes that make it feel extra indulgent. I love the nostalgic birthday cake taste and smooth texture. Perfect for satisfying a sweet tooth or celebrating a special occasion any day of the year!

20d ago
Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate Ice Cream is a dream for chocolate lovers! It has a rich, intense chocolate flavor with a smooth, creamy texture that feels incredibly indulgent. I love that it delivers a deep cocoa taste without being overly sweet. Perfect for satisfying a serious chocolate craving or pairing with cookies for an extra decadent dessert!

20d ago
Jeni’s Strawberry Buttermilk Ice Cream is the perfect balance of sweet, fruity strawberries and tangy buttermilk! I love how creamy and refreshing it tastes, with a bright strawberry flavor that feels a little more elevated than traditional strawberry ice cream. It’s delicious on its own and makes the perfect treat whenever I’m craving something sweet and refreshing!

20d ago
Jeni’s Holiday Ice Cream Collection is such a fun way to enjoy seasonal flavors! I love the variety and festive feel, making it perfect for trying something new during the holidays. The ice cream is rich and creamy, with unique flavor combinations that feel extra special. A great treat for cozy nights in or sharing with friends and family!

20d ago
Jeni’s Cookies in Cream ice cream is rich, creamy, and packed with delicious cookie pieces in every bite! I love the classic combination of smooth vanilla ice cream and chocolatey cookies for the perfect balance of flavors and textures. It feels indulgent and satisfying, making it a great treat whenever I’m craving a classic cookies and cream dessert!

This is my first time trying Jenni’s ice cream. I usually don’t buy pints at the grocery store but it was on sale and I had a craving. I bought the Green Mint Chip. I am a big fan of mint in general. It’s my go-to flavor for really any ice cream. This ice cream has a rich, mint aroma. The perfect amount of chocolate chips. A couple spoonfuls can fill a void but definitely tempting to finish a pint. I’ll try other flavors in the future. The price was usually what held me back.

Jenis ice cream make some really nice (and interesting flavours). I am not loyal to any one brand of ice cream but sometimes i will pick up a tub at wholefoods. Not the cheapest option but certainly creamy!

Have you had the peppermint ice cream! It is amazing! Love the taste and flavor and the peppermint is just right and it is naturally dyed. Only draw back is the chunks are a little to hard on the teeth and big. But other than that it’s awesome!

1y ago
Her shipment arrived melted second shipment was shipped out on a Thursday night for today Air UPS does not deliver on Saturday and Sunday therefore second shipment arrived Monday soup again. Very difficult to get in touch with the human. Everything is through email and they keep you on hold and say that no agent is available.

I've tried two flavors of the dairy-free options from this brand. I wasn't huge on the Texas Sheet Cake because I'm not too huge on chocolate in general. It tasted way too much like coconut for me to enjoy it. My partner loved it, so I let him have it. The lemon bar flavor was the one I liked more. It had quite a zingy lemon taste to it, but it was still good. I love that these don't have anything artificial in them.

Innovative flavours, delicious waffle cone. I picked up an ice cream in store. It was a great experience.
Feedback
I enjoyed my ice cream, but it wasn’t cheap and I’d still rather go for an authentic Italian gelato 🇮🇹

3y ago
This brand has really good vegan ice cream flavors. While I have not personally tried their dairy offerings, all of my friends and family absolutely adore "Gooey Butter Cake" and "Darkest Chocolate". As for me, I am a huge fan of the "Banana Pudding", which is surprising as it is something I do not normally eat. Before even trying any of them, your eyes will be delighted by the packaging for their pint. It is incredibly stylish and fun to look at for both adults and children alike. Biting into their ice cream is always satisfying even if you just pulled it out the freezer or if you left it to thaw for a bit. Regardless, this is a high-quality and unique ice cream brand.

After a long day of walking the big city, I craved something luxurious, and wow, was this just perfection! Delicious 😋 Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams makes artisan ice cream from high-quality ingredients, and you taste that in each and every bite!

2y ago
I love ice cream. Having worked at Baskin Robbins for 5 years during high school and college, I never tired of the stuff! Always looking for a new frozen delight taste treat, I recently tried Jenni's Splendid Ice Creams - what a perfect name - they were both spendid and delicious. The Brambleberry Crisp and the Peanut Butter/Jelly flavor were unlike flavors I'd had before. The brambleberry was so delicious I ate the entire container in a realtively short amount of time. The only reason it's not 5 stars is the cost. It was $9.99 at my local market. A special treat.

I had the brambleberry crisp at their shop in Austin 3 months ago, and I still think about it often. It’s amazing. However, $12 dollars a pint is kinda crazy! I see in it grocery stores here in nyc, but I just can’t get myself to spend double digits on a pint. Had to take off a point for the price, but otherwise delish.

quality ice cream!! my favorite has to be lemon bar, tangy yet sweet and burst of flavors. I love getting Jeni’s ice cream pints for friend gatherings.

Jeni's Ice Cream offers a truly exceptional experience. The flavors are rich and creative with unique combinations that excite the palate. Every scoop is creamy and smooth with a perfect balance of sweetness. The quality of the ingredients is obvious from the very first bite. Whether you choose a classic like salted caramel or something more adventurous, each taste is memorable. The atmosphere of the shops feels warm and inviting, making it a great place to enjoy a treat with friends or family. Overall, Jeni's Ice Cream is a must-try for anyone who loves artisan ice cream crafted with care and passion.
