Ithaca Hummus reviews and discussion

4.5

91% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vibrant, zesty flavor profiles
  • Creamy, thick hummus texture
  • Clean, preservative‑free ingredients
  • Inventive, collaborative flavor lineup
  • Occasionally overpowering lemon tang
  • Inconsistent, sometimes grainy texture
  • Small, modest container size
  • Seasoning intensity varies widely

Ithaca Hummus earns enthusiastic reviews for vibrant, fresh flavors and a smooth, thick texture that elevates staples like Lemon Dill, Lemon Garlic, Everything Bagel, French Onion, and Black Bean, signaling the brand is very good. Reviewers praise the clean, preservative‑free ingredients and creative collaborations, but note drawbacks including a higher price, occasional overly lemony or strong seasoning, inconsistent texture (too thick, grainy, or thin for some), and small container sizes.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

96 reviews and posts

  • Tasty, high quality hummus that tastes like it was made recently. The lemon garlic is a great flavor combination. It's a small amount of hummus for the cost, which is the only downside. The texture and taste are great.

  • Absolutely delicious. I love this hummus and always have a few flavors in my fridge. I’ve tried the lemon dill, jalapeño lime, classic, beet, and red bell pepper varieties, and every single one is fantastic. The flavors are bold and vibrant, and the consistency is perfect: smooth, not thick or pasty. I’ve seen some reviews saying the flavors are too strong, but to me, that’s what makes them so good. They taste incredibly fresh, and the jalapeño lime in particular is next-level - it has a bright, zesty kick that’s super satisfying. It’s not too spicy, just a really well-balanced heat that adds a ton of flavor. Highly recommend!

  • The French onion hummus just might be the best store-bought hummus that I've ever had. Perfectly creamy, thick but not too thick, great onion flavor that's not overpowering.

  • The lemon dill hummus is such a unique and delicious flavor that it serves as an indulgence worth the money, despite the small package size. It's just that good.

    Received a free product from Ithaca Hummus
  • This is my favorite store bought hummus. It’s smooth, rich, and every flavor I’ve tried has been incredible. I just wish I could get bigger containers!

  • I've always liked hummus, but would never have gone out of my way to purchase it. These are simply AMAZING and are a constant staple in my fridge now. So many good flavor options too!

  • This is the only pre-packaged hummus brand I will eat anymore. It's so fresh, so delicious.

  • Coming from my hometown this has been around for sometime in our area. Its so interesting seeing it expand as a brand. The hummus is good but can get pricey at some retailers.

  • I'm a hummus snob, but I really like Ithaca's flavors, especially the Lemon Dill. It's on the thicker side, which isn't my preference, but it's still very high quality and worth the purchase.

  • I love hummus and usually stick to more traditional offerings but when I saw beet hummus I had to try it. Well, I wasn’t disappointed- so good! Refreshing and so tasty. All of the flavors are just delicious.

    Feedback

    They can be a little pricey but so worth it. The flavors are really good and there is a nice variety.

  • Love the flavors and the overall texture of the product.

    Feedback

    Maybe some cool collabs-- if you can do it-- or large format sizes.

  • DELICIOUS!!! I am already a hummus lover but this one is so good. It’s a tad thicker than the normal store brands but in a good way. The taste is delicious - I will definitely be repurchasing.

    Feedback

    Nothing!

  • I like this hummus, it is one of the more quality ones you can buy at the grocery store and their flavors are delivious.

    Feedback

    I wish the texture was a bit more fluffy and light.

  • some of the best hummus i've had! a bit pricy but tried it when it was on sale at my local grocery store & am now convinced it's worth the splurge! lemon garlic knocked my socks clean off so delicious!!