One Trick Pony

519 Reviews

One Trick Pony sells a range of natural peanut butter made from one ingredient.


Average rating from 19 users


Recommend to a friend

One Trick Pony Reviews

Start a review

5 months ago

YUM. I didn't realize what I was missing out on before trying Argentinian PB. Super flavorful and a clean label - just peanuts and salt. My favorite is the kinda crunchy.

6 months ago

Friends with One Trick Pony

WOW! This is truly the best peanut butter I've ever had. I find myself wanting to put it in just about everything! Smooth with just the right amount of sweetness, the consistency is perfect and I feel good knowing it's made with all-natural ingredients and no BS.

9 months ago

Received my peanut butter within a couple of days of putting in my order. The branding is great, price is competitive with other premium brands of peanut butter. The smooth PB is on the runny side, that is not a bad thing; it's perfect for mixing into yogurt or smoothies. The taste is great, sweet at the front and it gets nuttier on the finish. I will buy this product again.

What is Thingtesting?

Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.

7 months ago

SO GOOD!! I thought peanut butter was the universal standard taste until trying this peanut butter. It honestly tasted 10x better than regular-store peanut butter. Also- love that its so clean just 2 ingredients! The crunchy one is amazing, and I will be buying this regularly. I also love the packaging, marketing, and the story behind the founders is super cute! Love that they are Argentinian peanuts + salt! It came super fast, the website was so cute and easy to order from, and the glass jars are great to reuse after!

9 months ago

I really liked this product. I have it to my daughter at 10 months old.


Love that it doesn’t have a bunch of additives. Personally love on toast

8 months ago

Friends with One Trick Pony

Amazing peanut butter brand with greaty, high-quality taste sans the messy oil separation and preservatives that exist in other brands. Love the founders, stories, and branding!

10 months ago

Simply THE BEST peanut butter. I tested all 3 varieties and all three are fantastic. Every other brand of natural peanut butter separates in the jar - not One Trick Pony! My personal favorite is the Kinda Crunchy (so many delicious little crunchies!), but you can’t go wrong. They also have great merch! I picked up a hat and a sweatshirt.

10 months ago

I love this peanut butter. I don't know why the Argentinean peanuts and Patagonian Sea salt make such a big difference, but they do. The product is so tasty and rich without any added oils or sugars. The on-line orders arrive in fun purple and pink boxes. I have ordered many two-packs and three-packs to use as hostess and neighbor gifts over the holidays.


I see the no-salt is only in smooth right now. I would love to have a no-salt crunchy option.

10 months ago

As someone who eats one jar of peanut butter a night with her fingers, I have a lot of experience with this topic. You’d be surprised how much a difference one single ingredient makes. What’s most surprising is even with just these two ingredients, it has all the flavor of other brands packed with preservations or artificial sweeteners. The size of the crunchy peanuts is extremely cool and is sure to meet the demands of even crunchy naysayers - adds the perfect crunch without being too offensive. Lastly , eating the entire jar did not wreak havoc on my digestive system as expected with other brands. Even the puppy one is dank , especially if you want to pour it directly down your throat or drink it with a straw. I personally love to dip dates in the crunchy one for the perfect 3 am snack. And I also love to go on dates where all we do is dip things in peanut butter if you know what I mean


If you’re considering the brand I don’t see why you wouldn’t just go for it. It’s healthy and has a cute container you can use as a vase after. Not to mention the founder is cute

10 months ago

One Trick Pony is delicious! I love both the smooth and crunchy kinds and my dog loves the low salt version! It's the best!