One Trick Pony reviews and discussion

Well I heard about palm oil and how its actually not good for you which made me sad and angry because I had finally found a peanut butter that satisfied the tastebuds.....or so I thought...... So then my mom told me about one trick pony, and let me tell you, the blessing that was bestowed upon me the second that decadent slither of silky deliciousness touched my tastebuds, I knew i was done for. So savory, yet with the perfect touch of sweet, I was going to branch out and try a store bought palm oil free brand but um.......I won't now. I can't. What could possibly be better than this?? Pretty blown away and now im addicted. So, yeah, that happened. Mind blown.

I do love the peanut butter, the branding, the story, etc, but I don’t know if I will purchase again. The marketing states that they import peanuts from Argentina, and that these peanuts make sweeter peanut butter. That’s what excited me enough to buy almost $50 of peanut butter while I was doomscrolling social media. But when I taste this side by side with Kirkland Peanut Butter, I honestly can’t taste the difference. Love the idea, but it was lost on me.

Been a fan since I found One Trick Pony online when they first started. I'm on autoship and can't say how much I love this peanut butter. It's sooo good. Super creamy and delicious. Recently, I tried the Maple Crunch and I'm completely obsessed. It's got white chocolate chips inside, is sweet but not too sweet, and makes my oatmeal taste MUCH better. Trying to add that to my autoship (it's SOLD OUT). SO GOOD. Also, customer service is exceptional.

This is the best peanut butter I've ever had. I'm a nutritionist and I have very high standards for what I consume!! I recommend this brand to all of my clients. I love supporting a small family-run business as well!! Truly amazing, I love to keep the crunchy in the fridge, it's such a treat!!!

I can't stand the natural peanut butter that separates in the jar and most of the time the Skippy type is too sweet. RXBAR discontinued their Nut Butter Honey Cinnamon Peanut Butter and I've been looking for a replacement that comes in individual packets to take on the go. This peanut butter is perfect - not too dry, doesn't make your mouth feel sticky, and a rich peanut taste. I also tried their limited Maple Crunch version and that was such a decadent dessert it was hard not to eat the jar in one sitting.

I never liked store peanut butter, not the usual IffYstuff, not the “fresh grind”, not the organic, none of it. Just wasn’t my thing! One trick pony has converted me to a peanut butter lover. It is so tasty, smooth and just a delight to eat on simple toast, oatmeal, smoothie or just a spoonful. My 2 kiddos and dog absolutely love it. We never use to but any peanut butter, now I am subscriber. Love the quality, taste and transparency. We have baked almond flour, peanut butter and maple cookie and they are divine with One trick pony. You are missing out if you don’t try it, even if you don’t like peanut butter. We are a fan!

I love this peanut butter, especially the crunchy! Love putting it in my oatmeal, cold cereal, on rice cakes and is delicious on a PBJ! Taste is so good! Will continue to order!

This really is the best peanut butter out there. I’ve tried A LOT of peanut butters, I mean A LOT. One Trick Pony is now my only go to. It’s clean, tastes great, and spreads easily. There’s minimal separation so requires little mixing. Their customer service is excellent. Love this stuff.

Creamy, delicious, flavorful, natural, amazing.

WOW! This is truly the best peanut butter I've ever had. I find myself wanting to put it in just about everything! Smooth with just the right amount of sweetness, the consistency is perfect and I feel good knowing it's made with all-natural ingredients and no BS.

Beautiful packaging and delicious peanut butter. I'm a one trick pony ride or die now.

I have tried nearly every single all natural (and palm oil free) peanut butter on the market and I can truthfully say this is the best I’ve ever had. I’m not sure if it’s the Argentian peanuts, but the taste is naturally sweet enough, without being overbearing. I really love that there’s not a big oil to butter ratio, so it’s easy to eat without making a huge mess. I love supporting developing brands and would definitely recommend OTP peanut butter. #teamcrunchy

I was immediately impressed with how smooth and easy it was to stir this peanut butter. There is a perfect blend of slightly sweet peanuts with just the right amount of salt. It went perfectly with apple slices as well as toast. I am hooked and will definitely be signing up for a subscription!

Some of the best peanut butter I’ve ever tried!! Was so impressed with the consistency and lack of separation natural peanut butters so often have. I tried all three types. They were all amazing and would serve different purposes well but overall I loved the creamy one best. My dog loved the one trick puppy :)

This is the BEST peanut butter I have EVER had - no stirring, perfect flavor, and no random ingredients. Just Argentinian peanuts and sea salt!!! 10/10 recommend to anyone, PB-lovers or not. Order this now (get the trio, you're gonna wanna taste each type)!!

One Trick Pony is delicious! I love both the smooth and crunchy kinds and my dog loves the low salt version! It's the best!

I would recommend One Trick Pony to anyone with taste buds! This is the most delicious PB on the market, comprised of just ONE ingredient. In a world where there are far too many additives that I can't even pronounce, I warmly welcome One Trick Pony as a new pantry shelf staple. I am partial towards crunchy, but those inclined towards smooth PB will be equally delighted with this product. This PB is truly EVERYTHING - no other tricks up their sleeve needed. Run don't walk to this tantalizing, nutty goodness!

Literally, the best tasting peanut butter I’ve ever had. The Argentinian peanuts give it an amazing texture and unique sweetness. And, nothing but peanuts and salt - much healthier than the other stuff!

Big fan of the crunchy, one of the only natural butters that doesn’t separate, very clutch