Thingtesting Logo

One Trick Pony

4.9 • 40 Reviews

One Trick Pony sells a range of natural peanut butter made from one ingredient.

onetrickponynuts.comArrow up right
Shop
Reward
20% reward
One Trick Pony Reviews

Best of Thingtesting4.9

One Trick Pony earns enthusiastic reviews and consistently delivers rich, naturally sweet peanut butter that spreads smoothly and largely resists messy separation, though the smooth can run thin and it underperforms for baking. Reviews praise the clean, two-ingredient formulas, standout Kinda Crunchy and Maple Crunch variants, and elegant reusable glass jars, while noting desires for a no-salt crunchy option and occasional flavor indistinguishability versus generic PB.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Rewards
Shop
Review
Reward
20% reward

Join to earn a 20% reward

Join Thingtesting to earn a cash-based commission when you shop and review One Trick Pony using our link.

By continuing, you agree to Thingtesting’s Terms of Service, Community Guidelines, and the use of data in the Privacy Policy

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 40

  • 20d ago

    I ordered this for the first time after seeing ads for a while and I'm so glad I did! The limited maple flavor is so delicious and the ingredients are so minimal. The jar itself is a great design and the peanut butter is such high quality. I will definitely order again.

    Verified purchase

  • 3mo ago

    I am a big fan of One Trick Pony. The taste is delicious (how can it not be when it's basically just ground peanuts) and the new jar design makes it so I can get out every last spoonful of peanut butter (yay, no waste!). We go through jars of pb pretty fast in our house, so we've opted to keep the jars in the pantry instead of the fridge. If you go the fridge route it makes it really hard to scoop and spread. I just purchased the individual packets to keep on hand at work.

    Verified purchase

  • 4mo ago

    Just bought this at Target since I needed a crunchy healthy peanut butter and the reviews were good. Well, it lived up to and exceeded them! Only 2 ingredients, peanuts and salt, organic and non-gmo and tastes delicious! The bonus is no refrigeration needed so it's easy to spread on bread (no more cold and stiff/separated peanut butter!). Extra bonus is the clever (and simple) container which you store with the lid down- helps keep the natural oil from separating. When you flip it over to use, just remember to give it a quick perk so the butter in the lid goes into the cup before you open it. Love the crunch and the peanut punch this has! Went out and bought 2 more the next day.

  • 5mo ago

    Really amazing peanut butter - great on toast, in yogurt bowls, etc.

View all 40 reviews

Alternatives

What is One Trick Pony?

One Trick Pony sells a range of natural peanut butter made from one ingredient.

In their own words

One Trick Pony peanut butter is made of the world’s best Argentinian peanuts and Patagonian sea salt. That's it. No additives, no oils, no sugars, no other shenanigans. Really, really good peanut butter. That's the trick!