Thingtesting Logo

One Trick Pony

4.9 • 37 Reviews

One Trick Pony sells a range of natural peanut butter made from one ingredient.

onetrickponynuts.comArrow up right
Shop
Reward
20% reward
One Trick Pony Reviews

Best of Thingtesting4.9

One Trick Pony earns standout reviews and proves itself a genuinely good peanut butter brand, praised for clean two-ingredient formulas, rich natural sweetness from Argentinian peanuts, and a smooth, no-separation texture. Reviews also flag trade-offs: smooth can run thin, the product isn’t ideal for baking, and flavor differences versus standard peanut butter aren’t universally perceptible, while limited flavor variants (like no-salt crunchy) are missing.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Rewards
Shop
Review
Reward
20% reward

Join to earn a 20% reward

Join Thingtesting to earn a cash-based commission when you shop and review One Trick Pony using our link.

By continuing, you agree to Thingtesting’s Terms of Service, Community Guidelines, and the use of data in the Privacy Policy

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 37

  • 22d ago

    Really amazing peanut butter - great on toast, in yogurt bowls, etc.

  • 7mo ago

    I just got the maple crunch peanut butter from one trick pony, and it is delicious!! It's definitely on the sweeter side, but the crunchy pieces in it make it a fabulous sweet treat. its great as part of a PB&J!

  • 3y ago

    SO GOOD!! I thought peanut butter was the universal standard taste until trying this peanut butter. It honestly tasted 10x better than regular-store peanut butter. Also- love that its so clean just 2 ingredients! The crunchy one is amazing, and I will be buying this regularly. I also love the packaging, marketing, and the story behind the founders is super cute! Love that they are Argentinian peanuts + salt! It came super fast, the website was so cute and easy to order from, and the glass jars are great to reuse after!

  • 1y ago

    I first experienced OTPs amazing peanut butter on a trip to Washington D.C. (snuck a couple of jars back home in my case) in April and fell in love with it. Very high quality, fabulous taste and no nasty stuff. Then I found myself at a loss when it was running out and whilst OTP don't traditionally ship to me (I'm in Edinburgh, Scotland), OTP (Lucy, you're awesome) provided the best customer experience ever and my 3 new jars arrived yesterday. I love this PB and I love OTP ethos and customer service even more (well almost as I just love their PB). I was so pleased, here is one jar on my walk to work this morning with Edinburgh castle in the background Thanks OTP for making the simple things in life awesome Scott

View all 37 reviews

Alternatives

What is One Trick Pony?

One Trick Pony sells a range of natural peanut butter made from one ingredient.

In their own words

One Trick Pony peanut butter is made of the world’s best Argentinian peanuts and Patagonian sea salt. That's it. No additives, no oils, no sugars, no other shenanigans. Really, really good peanut butter. That's the trick!