Milk Bar reviews and discussion

3.6

68% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Nostalgic, creative flavor profiles
  • Iconic cereal milk soft serve
  • Decadent cake truffles favorite
  • Attractive, giftable packaging
  • Overly sweet flavor profile
  • Inconsistent packaged product quality
  • Occasional dryness or oiliness
  • Frequent delivery reliability issues

Milk Bar polarizes: reviews praise the in-store classics like Cereal Milk soft serve, Milk Bar Pie, Birthday Cake, and cake truffles as nostalgic, inventive, and delicious, yet many find products overwhelmingly sweet and note uneven quality in packaged grocery items. Reviews also flag inconsistent freshness and multiple failed or late deliveries, while applauding playful branding and gift appeal, plus solid gluten-free options.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

371 reviews and posts

  • Milkbar cake pops and cakes are so sweet! A guilty pleasure sugar bomb that is too much for me to consume unless offered, and even then, very occasionally. The cookies are a bit less overwhelming, but still feel packed with too much sweet punch.

  • The best gluten free baked goods! Expensive but worth it for the splurge!

  • Milkbar is for if you are a Sweetteeth. Not singular tooth. Teeth. Milkbar is SWEET. I've had their crack pie and other various cookies. The flavours are creative and the textures are great. I feel like a fancy kid eating Milkbar. Their brand and flavours are playful and nostalgic. Their beautiful cakes are worth every penny.... if you like sweet. I had one for my birthday in uni and inhaled that cake. Years later when I got another cake... I felt like I was going to overdose on sugar.... Note- I tried a Milkbar cookie I purchased from a grocer the other week and the quality was not as good as buying directly from a Milkbar bakery. Stick to the bakeries if you can.

  • Super delicious cakes and ice cream. Very festive and dense.

    Feedback

    The cookies are not good! Always a bit dry.

  • I really like to buy this brand of put in birthday gifts for my friends. The packaging is too cute. I have had one by myself and I think it is pretty good. The price is also comparable to other candy bars near in the store.

  • Milk bar knows how to make great tasting cookies. I love their birthday cake flavor soft cookies and also their crunchy brown butter chocolate chip cookies. One bite, and I can’t stop eating them. They are amazing.

  • They make the best cookies. The best flavone is the brown butter crunchy cookies.

  • The cookies are very addicting. I am usually not a cookie person, but these cookies are very good.

  • Milk Bar has completely redefined dessert for me! Their cakes are a total indulgence, with unique flavors that are both nostalgic and innovative. The cake I tried was moist, flavorful, and packed with layers of creamy frosting that perfectly balanced the sweetness. The best part? They deliver fresh, straight to your door! Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just treating yourself, Milk Bar’s creations are a must-try for anyone who loves a fun twist on classic desserts. 🎂💖

  • Delicious sweet treats that are great for special occasions! I love their birthday cakes - add a special twist to any occasion!

  • Im not a huge sweets person but wow everything from here is amazing !! The cookies and the pie is seriously divine! Love love love this brand everyone should try something From here at least once!

  • Everything is super yummy from them, but just a little pricey (as someone who isn't the biggest fan of sweets/dessert).

  • Just delicious. As a former visitor to their stores,I was thrilled to receive the cookies on a flight. Ice creams also delicious and were available in our local grocery store.

  • So happy to see their products in grocery stores. Cookies and ice cream are very rich, so a little goes a long way. The ice cream is also a little on the salty side, so flavors more than others.

  • taste is amazing but a little too sweet for my asian taste buds sometimes. would there ever be a 'not too sweet' version :)