Start a review
Average rating from 29 users
35%Recommend to a friend
Catalina Crunch Reviews
I eat a LOT of catalina crunch, even though I don't think its delicious. It's the best keto cereal, comparatively, so far, but don't expect Cinnamon Toast Crunch levels of pleasure. The chocolate flavor is especially heinous.
You can really taste the sugar alcohols in this and I don't like the aftertaste at all...
I tried the chocolate version, and it was just so so sweet. I may just be sensitive to the sweetener in it because I know other people who love it!
What is Thingtesting?
Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.
I really wanted to like this because I love cereal but am always interested in healthier options, but I found the taste of this to be really off putting. I could not get past the fake sugar taste of the cereal and ended up throwing it out after just 2 times trying it. Would not repurchase.
I actually love their cinnamon toast cereal so much I end up finishing the bag in one sitting. I think a lot of people are put off by the fake sugar sweetness flavor you taste as you chew it and the accompanying aftertaste, but it's like so odd and bland in a way that I enjoy it so much. Thus, I would only recommend if you're into very particular tastes like that. The downside is that their smaller bags are too expensive, therefore only worth purchasing occasionally or looking for big bag from Costco. Also, although I believe it has good macros, I'm not really a fan of the ingredients compared to other cereal alternatives I've tried.
OK this might not be a popular opinion because I understand some people can taste the stevia aftertaste but I LOVE the cinnamon cereal because of its crunch. My husband and I go through a bag in a day when we have it. I like the high protein, high fiber and recognizable ingredients. Acknowledging the stevia taste but not a deal-breaker for me!
The blueberry is vile. It's so sweet and fake. Boy do i wish I didn't just throw out $50. Barf!
Its tolerable but... pretty tough chewing experience and it does have an aftertaste of stevia. I'd compare the taste to if you dehydrated a Muscle Milk protein shake (if you know this taste - you KNOW).
I absolutely LOVE the Cinnamon Toast cereal! I am gluten intolerant and try to avoid sugar. I eat a small bowl with oatmilk after dinner for dessert. If you expect it to taste like regular wheat and sugar cereal, you’ll probably be disappointed. If you CAN’T eat the other, you may love this as I do!
Tried the Catalina crunch Fruity mix Cereal, and I gave it two full spoonfuls, then poured the bowl down the garbage disposal. Horrible Taste, bad aftertaste. Taste nothing like Cereal at all, I'd rather eat grapenuts.