Thingtesting Logo

Beauty Pie

4.5 • 54 Reviews

Beauty Pie is a member's club that sells luxury makeup and skincare products.

beautypie.comArrow up right
Shop
Reward
30% reward
Beauty Pie Reviews

4.5

Beauty Pie earns largely positive reviews for effective, luxe-feeling formulas—standouts include Japanfusion Cleanser, Super Retinol, Über Youth Probiotic Serum Mist, Triple Hyaluronic Acid Eye Cream, candles, and fragrances—so yes, the brand works; however, reviews also flag inconsistencies and drawbacks like heavy fragrance, occasional misses (e.g., mascaras, some lipsticks), and confusing or restrictive membership mechanics. Reviewers praise the broad range and repeat-buys but note formula changes, stock unpredictability, and a desire for samples and more sustainable, refillable packaging.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Rewards
Shop
Review
Reward
30% reward

Join to earn a 30% reward

Join Thingtesting to earn a cash-based commission when you shop and review Beauty Pie using our link.

By continuing, you agree to Thingtesting’s Terms of Service, Community Guidelines, and the use of data in the Privacy Policy

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 54

  • 5mo ago

    I’d been a member of BeautyPie a few years ago, but had let my membership lapse. A family member had asked for the glycolic acid wipes again, so I rejoined. Aside from the subscription fee, the products are very good value. The wipes are as good as ever, and the body lotion seems to have improved. The glass jar makes it a gift worthy product, and the scent is nice. Worth the money for the quality. UPDATE: another purchase of equally excellent products. This time a body scrub intended as a gift, eye shadow, and a retinol hand cream.

    Verified purchase

  • 1mo ago

    The beads and exfoliating enzymes feel so nice. I use it as a mask when I feel me skin is clogged and needs a deep clean. Proud to say this one one of my beauty empties and I'll add this to my reorder list when I run out

  • 8mo ago

    This is one of my favorite sunscreens. Almost no white cast and it’s excellent under makeup. I use it virtually everyday. I love that it’s mineral based; no chemicals on my sensitive skin. Like most Beauty Pie items, it’s at a great price point if you are a member, like I am.

  • 5y ago

    I've been a Beauty Pie member since I discovered it on Thingtesting in 2018. I love this brand so much - it's where I truly get all of my skincare, makeup and personal care products (and sometimes even a candle here and there). I love the subscription because of the price and the convenience of getting everything from one place. Coming from someone who loves trying new products all the time, it's a huge statement to say I switched everything over to one brand! I also love that they're always coming out with new products so it feels like a new shopping experience everytime I go to the website to stock up every other month or so.

    Feedback

    Some of their products are hit or miss but I have found such holy grail products that I'm willing to experiment to find my favorites. They can be also kinda unpredictable with inventory too - they always seem to have products out of stock so sometimes its hard when I'm almost out of something I consider one of my essentials. I also wish they were doing more to have more sustainable packaging or refillable product systems given that they are already on a subscription business model.

View all 54 reviews

Alternatives

What is Beauty Pie?

Beauty Pie is a member's club that sells luxury makeup and skincare products.

In their own words

Beauty guru and serial entrepreneur, Marcia Kilgore, launched Beauty Pie in December 2016, challenging the old definition of ‘luxury’ and blowing the lid off the mainstream luxury beauty industry. The world’s first beauty membership, Beauty Pie is on a mission to give members insider access to shop for products direct, from the best suppliers in premium skincare, makeup, haircare, bodycare, candles, fragrance, accessories and nutritional supplements, without paying the crazy 10X typical industry markups. Members get a bigger piece of the Beauty Pie.