Barebells reviews and discussion

4.4

92% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Candy-bar-like texture and flavor
  • Consistently high protein macros
  • Smooth nougat center texture
  • Widely praised signature flavors
  • Occasionally artificial flavor notes
  • Overly sweet flavor profiles
  • Chewy, dense bar texture
  • Flavors taste overly similar

Barebells earns strong reviews for tasting like a candy bar while delivering around 20g of protein, with standout flavors like Cookies & Cream, Salty Peanut, Caramel Cashew, Chocolate Dough, and Creamy/Creamy Crisp. Reviews also flag drawbacks—some flavors taste artificial or overly sweet, textures can run chewy or dense (especially vegan options), flavor profiles often blur together, and occasional powdery notes or aftereffects from sweeteners appear.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

78 reviews and posts

  • This flavor is amazing! I have bought out all of the stock at Walmart and The Vitamin Shoppe. It’s so yummy and doesn’t make your stomach hurt. It’s enough for a meal replacement, which is great for travel or on the go.

  • I typically avoid protein bars but since trying to add more to my diet these have been my go to. I have yet to find a flavor I don’t like and they travel extremely well.

  • I’m new to protein bars and products in general, but Barebells is a very novice-friendly brand. Good flavors (for the most part) with my fave being Caramel Crunch. I am also a fan of their protein shakes, particularly, vanilla or chocolate (I’m basic like that), but the sugar amount in those where one point comes off in the raining (way too high for my liking).

  • Personally, my favorite protein bar! I find that they're not too sweet and are transparent about their ingredients. I love the chocolate crisp and cookie dough flavors. I feel like typical protein bars either taste like chalk or are overly sweet, no in between. I always grab these bars for breakfast because I know it will satisfy my sweet tooth without being too unhealthy!

  • I absolutely love them! From textures to flavors, they have to be my current favorite protein bar. I truly feel like I’m eating a candy bar and they don’t give me any funky protein after taste. The new marshmallow ones are the bomb!

  • My husband and I tried the Banana Caramel because it was suggested by the sales associate at GMC. She’s tried all of the protein bars and said it was her favorite. We liked that it had 16 grams of protein, just 200 calories and no sugar. It had a mild banana flavor and was similar in texture and density to a Charleston Chew from my childhood. We both said we would get this brand again, but will try a different flavor. The banana had a slightly artificial taste.

  • I liked this as an introduction to protein bars. The texture is definitely reminiscent of a candy bar. I have them as a morning snack if I've worked out that day. I've tried the creamy crisp and the marshmallow peanut road. The marshmallow did not really taste like marshmallow to me, so I will not repurchase it in the future.

  • When they’re good, they’re really good. And even when they’re bad, they’re still good for a protein bar. Every protein bar I have had tastes vile, but there are 3-4 flavors of bare bells I would happily eat even if their protein content was lower. Please make key lime pie a permanent flavor!

  • I bought the bars from Trader Joe's and tried carmel-cashew and chocolate dough. Chocolate dough had a really weird aftertaste for me and I couldn't get behind it. Carmel-cashew was pretty good. I really like the soft, nougaty center. Not sure if I'll buy them again though.

  • The best protein bar that I have ever had, by far! The texture is great and no sugar alcohol taste that a lot of similar protein bars have. Still love these years later, better than any other protein bar!

  • BEWARE OF THESE. Once you try them, you will never go back to a different protein bar ever again. I have no idea how they have so much protein because the cookies & cream flavor tastes just like a chocolate bar. I'm obsessed.

  • Barebells protein bars, discovered at Trader Joe's, have quickly become my go-to choice for a guilt-free and satisfying snack. With a delicious taste that hits the spot, these bars pack an impressive 20g of protein without any added sugar. It's a win-win, providing a convenient and enjoyable way to fuel up with a healthy dose of protein.

  • This has been one of my favorite protein bars that I've ever eaten. I bought a box the caramel cashew bars off of Amazon and have been blown away by the taste and texture. There's not that overly dry, protein taste you get with other bars - this feels and tastes more like candy than a meal replacement.

    Feedback

    If you can find single bars at grocery stores or gas stations, that's the best way to try new flavors. They do have a sampler pack but it was sold out when I went to buy. I bought through amazon but you can buy from the site. Hoping they add like a subscriber plan in the future.

  • I ordered one box +2 single bars, and when I got them, they were all melted! At first, I didn’t hear back from them after I sent them a picture of the melted bars, and then I asked if they would send me another box but not to send it the way they sent it and they told me that’s the only way they could send it so they don’t care if they get to your mountain or not but they charge you that extra money to send them with dry ice that was completely melted when I got them

  • I recently had the pleasure of trying the Barebells Cookies and Cream Protein Bar, and I must say it exceeded all my expectations. From its distinct flavor to its impressive macronutrient profile, this protein bar is a true gem that I highly recommend to anyone seeking a tasty and nutritious snack. Let's start with the flavor. The cookies and cream combination is simply delightful. With every bite, you're greeted by a rich and creamy taste that perfectly balances the sweetness of cookies with a subtle hint of vanilla. The texture is also spot on, providing a satisfying crunch that enhances the overall enjoyment of the bar. Whether you're a cookies and cream enthusiast or simply looking for a delicious protein-packed treat, this flavor will leave you craving more. In addition to its outstanding taste, the Barebells Cookies and Cream Protein Bar boasts an impressive macronutrient profile. Each bar contains a generous amount of protein, providing a substantial 20 grams per serving. This makes it an excellent choice for those who lead an active lifestyle or are looking to supplement their protein intake. What's more, the bar is relatively low in sugar compared to other options on the market, making it a healthier alternative without compromising on flavor. What sets Barebells apart is their commitment to quality ingredients. The Cookies and Cream Protein Bar is made with real cookie pieces, which adds an authentic touch to its flavor. Furthermore, it is gluten-free and suitable for vegetarians, catering to a wide range of dietary preferences and restrictions. One aspect that deserves special mention is the convenience of these protein bars. They come individually wrapped, making them easy to grab on the go or toss into your gym bag for a quick post-workout refuel. Whether you're at the office, hitting the gym, or exploring the great outdoors, this protein bar is a convenient snack option that won't let you down. In conclusion, the Barebells Cookies and Cream Protein Bar is a true standout in the world of protein bars. Its distinct and delicious flavor, coupled with its impressive macronutrient profile, make it an absolute winner. Whether you're seeking a post-workout snack, a guilt-free indulgence, or simply a tasty on-the-go treat, I highly recommend giving Barebells a try. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

    Consumer
  • Hands down the BEST protein bars on the market! I have (unfortunately) IBS, so I've tried quite a few different bars to figure out what works for me. These (any and all flavors) do not make my tummy have any issues. I never feel bloated either. They literally taste like a candy bar which helps satisfy my sweet tooth, along with helping hit my protein goals! I travel often for work and refuse to not have a few bars in my backpack at all time. The crispy and the cookie dough flavors are my favorite. I even toss them in the fridge sometimes like I would a candy bar. So, so good!

  • By far the best protein bars on the market, I've tried all the flavors aside from most of the vegan flavors except the hazelnut vegan one, the only flavor I'd suggest not trying is the confetti cake because the little nougat pieces in it were hard as a rock. Otherwise compared to others on the market barebells hit a home run.

  • They have a ton of protein, and so many innovative flavours. However I can't escape that they taste a little powdery and the chocolate feels a little off to me.

  • I love the caramel cashew! They are such a great option for protein with minimal sugar added! It is also a nice price point and are sold at Trader Joe’s.

  • Not for me! I don't understand the hype of these. They were not tasty at all and I expect better from a protein bar. Wouldn't recommend.