Rothy's reviews and discussion

Love the slip on sneakers the most but also have the point, the loafer, and the driving shoe. The only drawback is the cost.

Love the brand mission of recycled fibers. I have the flats from them and they are so comfortable and easy to throw in a bag for backup shoes. Since they are flats I still do get tired feet at the end of the day but that would be with any flat. I wish there was more arch support but idk how they would easily do that in such a lightweight shoe. I also wish these were cheaper, as I was able to use a healthcare discount on them

Absolutely love the pointed flat. I have 2 pairs. They have changed the fit a little to where they are bit more flexible so I like them even more.

Light weight, comfortable to wear, beautiful design, sustainable materials, easy to clean.

Love the concept, but the shoes have very narrow toe boxes to the point where it was causing me significant nail pain. This was both with the ballet flat and also the slip on loafer. I have normal width feet and haven’t had this issue with any other shoe brand.

I have had my ballet flat Rothy's for over 5 years. They never gave me blisters and needed no breaking in period. I have washed them multiple times a year and the shape and color are still great.

I got a pair of the lace up sneakers for a recent trip to New Zealand and Australia since they would be easy to pack and I needed a cute shoe for all the walking. I was surprised at how comfortable they were! If you’re going to be walking a lot, you definitely need to wear socks to avoid blisters.

I wanted to love these. Shoes made from recycled plastic? I bought the rounded toe and the point. The sides were great, never chaffing or rubbing. The part on the ankle was sturdy but soft, no blister. They really are machine washable and come out looking new. But, in the rounded and pointed toe - the right size (they run a tad small), there is zero give in the toe. I thought continued wear would stretch them a bit, but it never did. My toenails actually ached at the end of the day.

I love my Rothys! As a teacher who spends a ton of time outside on the playground, my shoes get stinky and dirty....fast.. Being able to throw these in the wash is a game changer! The only negative is the lack of arch support; my feet can ache if I'm wearing these standing for long periods of time. These aren't exactly hiking shoes! But I love my Rothys, and have recommended them to lots of friends!

I do like my Rothy's Mary Janes! I have them in red and they add a nice pop of color to every outfit. This is old news but my one issue with the brand is their sizing. Luckily there are physical locations that you can try things on at, but my experience was confusing. I've had employees suggest different sizes. One employee really tried to get me to purchase a size that was uncomfortable, just because it's what the brand overall recommends. While I like the style of shoe and the options, I still feel like they need to standardize the shoe sizing or how their size chart/employees do fittings.

I was first attracted to the brand because of it's mission to reduce or eliminate plastic from the ocean. I have wide feet so the points are not as comfortable as the Flats which are the rounded toe flats. My favorite are the Drivers which are stylish and go with practically anything you want to wear. They are always inventing new styles and I love the variety of colors. They tend to be on the pricey side but you can wait for sales or they have sales on the styles that they are trying to get rid of.

Great shoes. They really are washable and come out looking brand new every time! I find them TTS.

I tried both the sneakers and men's loafers. The loafers are fantastic. They are comfortable to wear to and from the office as well as all day. I have received a ton of compliments on them and have been able to wear them with different styles of outfits and in a number of settings. The best part is that they are machine washable. Will definitely be buying more in other colors. The sneakers have a narrow fit and weren't comfortable even while sitting down in them.

I've had my black pointed-toe ballet flats for over 4 years and they're still one of my favorite pairs of shoes for work. They're incredibly comfortable and look brand new as soon as I clean them in the washing machine. I've convinced so many of my friends to purchase a pair and am tempted to start a collection with all the color options they have. My feet tend to sweat in them more than other shoes, but it doesn't both me because I can clean them so easily.

Overall really love this brand, it's the first place I go when I look for dress shoes.

So overpriced, but I do love my sesame driving loafers. They are surprisingly comfy and I wear them often. I do worry about the durability of this loafer style given the thinness of the sole...but only time will tell. I also truly don't think they're worth the money -- that being said they can definitely become a wardrobe staple for those who aren't price sensitive. My Rothy's loafers are unique, stylish, versatile, and comfy!

I went to the Rothy's store because I've heard mixed reviews on sizing. I ended up with the Loafer style, the popular Point style felt like they were going to slip off. I'm very happy with my Loafers and wear them for everyday commuting.

Wasn’t too impressed with these for the price point. Support wasn’t what I was looking for — definitely a fun looking shoe but not one I kept because I couldn’t wear it for long periods of time.

I can't believe that I put off trying these for so long. I bought a pair of the round-toed flats (camel-colored) and I am so glad I did. They are stretchy and comfortable. The fabric is easy to clean and take along on any trip.

I bought these for my mom she hated them, said no support at all. So I took them and I’m not as old and I have to agree. They are comfortable but def not to be worn if walking any kind of distance at all. Car to desk where u sit all day. Around house as slippers. However if you need no support at all, then these are great. Extremely comfortable.