Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

This is a fairly unique item, just because of the flavors. They have some pretty interesting flavors to choose from, but they actually taste pretty decent. The ice cream itself is a little expensive for my taste, especially if you're just wanting ice cream. However, the different flavors and better ingredients make it worth trying at least once. I would buy this ice cream again, but not on a regular basis.

I love the vegan flavors, especially the Texas Sheet Cake!

I’ve loved every flavor I’ve tried, but the brown butter almond brittle and texas sheet cake are incredible. Could easily eat a whole pint!

Honestly, I think Jeni's Icecream is overhyped. I haven't been to an actual store, but have tried plenty of the flavors. There are definitely some interesting ones and I appreciate that. I find the texture actually a little icy though. It's not the smoothest ice cream, by far, and at that price point, I'm not really getting all the hype.

Truly some of the most delicious and innovative flavors I’ve see at the grocery store. The mix-ins that are supposed to be crunchy stay that way and the base is rich and flavorful.

This ice cream is awesome. Creamy and delicious and the flavors are really really good. Especially the Banana!!!

As a Columbus native, I’ve long been singing the praises of Jeni’s. Most flavors are familiar but with fun twists that kick things up a notch. Salty Caramel and Brambleberry Crisp are two year-round flavors that I recommend to anyone, but I also love seasonal flavors like Savannah Buttermint and Atlantic Beach Pie. Also! Their dairy free flavors are some of the best in terms of taste in texture that I’ve tried.

Yes yes Jeni's is the most delicious ice cream. Flavours so awesome that you wish you could invent them. This beautiful combination of flavours that are playful and exciting and made with high quality ingredients.

I love Jeni's ice creams. The flavors are so fun and use a lot of great mid-western ingredients like brambleberry. The packaging is simple and clean which is a plus for me as well.

I tried the Skillet Cinnamon Roll flavor and it was so delicious. It might have been one of the best ice creams I've ever tried! So creamy, so flavorful, so decadent.

Unique and tasty flavors, good labeling of gf/df

Jeni's is my absolute favorite ice cream. Their Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks is delightful, and it's the only peanut butter ice cream I've ever loved. I am such a fan of Jeni's creative flavors, and I've never been disappointed by their ice cream.

The ice cream is delicious with innovative flavors. I wouldn't re-purchase frequently because it is pretty pricey for ice cream

LOVE that Jeni's has some dairy free options!!!! So good

Obsessed with every flavor of Jeni’s I’ve tried, including everything bagel. I can’t wait to try more!

Jeni's took ice cream and made it an experience. They have some of the most interesting flavors and every single one of them is a hit. Even flavors like Everything Bagel are so delicious even if they're a little weird. Their stores are so cute and on-brand. Eating Jeni's feels special.

This ice cream is insane. It's so creamy and I love the innovative flavors. It's not cheap, but definitely worth it.

Might be partial to Jeni's just because we share the best name - minus the "i" and add a few more letters. But besides that, I truly rave about Jeni's at every chance I get. Their flavors? Innovative. Their stores? SO CUTE. The waffle crisps? The perfect amount of saltiness to sweet ratio. Major fan.

Jeni's ice cream is the best ice cream on the market, hands down. Don't @ me!!! The birthday cake ice cream is NEXT LEVEL. Love the story and the extreme attention to detail. Such unique flavors and creative combinations. I'm always excited to see what flavors she puts out.

Jeni's birthday cake ice cream is the best ice cream available in grocery stores. SO worth the price.