4
85% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
HighKey
4.0 • 52 Reviews
•
HighKey reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Addictive chocolate chip flavor
- Buttery mini cookie texture
- Keto‑friendly ingredient profile
- Portable grab‑and‑go convenience
- Grainy cookie mouthfeel
- Oily aftertaste presence
- Crumbly cookie texture
- Noticeable sweetener aftertaste
HighKey reviews show the brand works as a satisfying low‑carb cookie alternative: reviewers praise chocolate chip and mini cookies for their addictive, buttery crunch and keto‑friendly profile but repeatedly note off‑putting textures and sweetener aftertastes. Strengths include flavor variety and grab‑and‑go convenience; weaknesses center on grainy or oily mouthfeel, crumbly texture, and noticeable sweetener finish—helpful for buyers deciding between taste, texture, and dietary needs.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
52 reviews and posts
4y ago
I've only tried the Snickerdoodle mini cookies but holy cow... they're so good. The right amount of soft, and they basically melt in your mouth. Like the mission, like the simple branding. Big supporter!
These very really good and addictive. I like how crunchy they are. I want to try other flavors too!
Received a free product from HighKeyI am a HUGE HighKey fan. I grew up eating Nilla Wafers with my family as a treat, but now that I'm getting older, I try to avoid the high sugar/high carb stuff. HighKey makes the only poduct that even remotely compares to the old Nilla Wafers I loved as a kid! Highly recommend :)
These are not for me. The cookies have a oily mouth feel that is not appetizing
Better for you oreos
I love these cookies!
I love these cookies - they're a real clutch snack when I need something with protein but can't bother with cooking.
Feedback
It's a bit grainy in texture and I can't have too much of it in one go. I think for the price, there's not a lot in the package
Good a little crispy
1y ago
The chocolate chip ookies are yummy! Plus they are keto friendly!
2y ago
The cookies taste good but I found them weirdly addicting in a bad way
I could eat these all day. It might be one of those things you like or you don't, but I'm a huge fan of the texture and taste.
3y ago
Feedback
I heard raves about these cookies - people told me that they taste exactly like regular, non-healthy chocolate chip cookies. They were very wrong. If you haven’t had an actual cookie in awhile (or if you don’t notice/like Monk fruit extract) you might think these are okay, but I really didn’t like the taste. I always find things with monk fruit extract taste weirdly chemical-y, and these were no exception.
I would not have guessed these were supposed to be better for you based on how great they taste! I have tried several of the flavors and the chocolate chip is probably my favorite! I am excited to try some of the newer flavors as well.
Feedback
I am normally more of a fan of chewy cookies, but I was delighted with how satisfying these crunchy cookies were!
I got the mini cookies in my Misfits Market box and my boyfriend and I ate the entire bag in one sitting, they were so delicious.
Feedback
More in a bag, please.
The chocolate chip cookies are to die for! A little bit expensive but so worth it
Got the chocolate chip cookies -- the first couple taste okay but something about the aftertaste makes them not as good. There are so many players in this market now so I may try something else next.
Really enjoy these as a treat when I have sweet cravings. These make being a diabetic easier. That being said, you could easily finish this bag quickly and will still need self-control to not indulge. I would definitely buy these again to be the cheat dessert or snack instead of other sugar-filled brands.
Feedback
My only drawback is that there are a lot of artificial ingredients that may not sit well with some people in their gut.
Not bad for a healthier option!
Feedback
A little pricey
Sale or special offerFor a Keto cookie, I wasn't sure what to expect... but honestly HighKey is a great brand!! They taste great and have a large variety of other items that are just as good. You can't taste the missing extra sugar and carbs, which is great when I want to be healthy yet have a sweet treat!
2y ago
Tried the chocolate chip cookies and love them. Just expensive