HighKey reviews and discussion

4

85% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Addictive chocolate chip flavor
  • Buttery mini cookie texture
  • Keto‑friendly ingredient profile
  • Portable grab‑and‑go convenience
  • Grainy cookie mouthfeel
  • Oily aftertaste presence
  • Crumbly cookie texture
  • Noticeable sweetener aftertaste

HighKey reviews show the brand works as a satisfying low‑carb cookie alternative: reviewers praise chocolate chip and mini cookies for their addictive, buttery crunch and keto‑friendly profile but repeatedly note off‑putting textures and sweetener aftertastes. Strengths include flavor variety and grab‑and‑go convenience; weaknesses center on grainy or oily mouthfeel, crumbly texture, and noticeable sweetener finish—helpful for buyers deciding between taste, texture, and dietary needs.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

52 reviews and posts

  • If you are diabetic these snacks are portion controlled, they are small but delicious! I keep them on hand to grab one or two when I feel like having a snack without over eating!

  • The cookies are fun in the mini sizes and I like the different flavors, however the double chocolate is my personal favorite. Great topping for pudding or ice cream, though that might have undone the intention about it being a low sugar item...I prefer my cookies a little more chewy than the crispy texture of these, though that's personal- not a fault of the product.

  • The Chocolate chip and snickerdoodle are my top favorites and then the double chocolate after that. They are little mini cookies and I like that they are low carb and grab and go. A lot of low carb/Keto foods you have to take the time to make from scratch so when you can find a good quality item ready made it's nice. The pricing of course is a little high but you are paying for better ingredients and a smaller company vs the big guys that sell cheap and it's all junk.

  • These are expensive but a great option for those trying to lessen sugar intake, and avoid gluten. I wish they made them a little bigger in size and more flavors. Good product though! Kinda melt in your mouth like. Buttery

  • I ate keto for over a year to heal a brain injury. I still eat very clean…but it gets boring, and these are so perfect for a fun snack! They taste amazing and love the crunch 😊

  • The mini cookies (Specifically the chocolate chip) are bomb. So good. Brought as a snack once to a party and the bag was gone. Good even for a “keto” food. I’m not keto and I choose to eat these they’re that yummy

  • A great alternative to regular cookies. Not too sweet, although I wasn’t a fan of the texture. It crumbles easily and I would feel a film in my mouth after eating them.

  • Tasty little cookies that leave little fake-sugar taste. A bit too crumbly, and I would only buy these if they're on sale given that they're not that nutrient-dense.

  • As a sugar free snack, the cookies are just okay. You can definitely taste the artificial sugar, and it has a strange minty aftertaste that I didn’t like.

  • As far as gluten free snacks go, these weren’t bad! They were a bit dry, but I liked the flavor. I don’t think I went back to them but they’re good for beating a cookie craving while gluten free.

  • These snacks were just ok. The cookies had a very oily mouth feel that was off-putting and hard to ignore.

  • I really wanted to like these more, because the flavor is great and I love the extra protein, but the texture is just so hard to get past. Its super grainy and you can just taste that it's not a real cookie. Good if your Gluten Free!

  • The chocolate chips cookies are amazing ! They are really small like bit size. They are keto friendly and gluten free but honestly you wouldn’t noticed because they are just good. Very unique too

    Feedback

    Try these for sure if you have a sweet tooth and want a “healthier” option especially since they are small you can just a few if you want.

  • I’m don’t have any grain allergies but a few of my family members do so I buy these cookies. After tasting them, I buy these cookies for myself! I eat them with milk, I make crusts out of them, they are so good and good for you!

  • My kids love this! Just wasn't for me. If you like a crunchy cookie id recommend.

    Feedback

    Almost like a powder/crumby texture that I couldn’t get past. My kids like them though!

    Discount code
  • My mom introduced me to high key cookies and I’m so glad she did! They are absolutely delicious and I love knowing that they don’t have a lot of sugar. Chocolate chip is my favorite but snickerdoodle is a close second

  • Very popular cookies in my household! Tasty coffee companions without the carbs.

  • As someone who has been gluten free for many years now (due to autoimmune disease exacerbated by gluten), I find the chocolate chip flavor pretty enjoyable when I'm having a cookie craving. I like the small one bite size of the cookies. My significant other however doesn't enjoy them as much and he found the taste and texture lacking a bit (but let's be real, I caught him eating the rest of the bag anyway, so he couldn't have disliked them that much). I don't think these are really 1-1 comparable to regular cookies, but for me I thought the taste overall was pretty good, especially if you are making a real effort to eat keto or low carb, and I will likely purchase again.