Fishwife reviews and discussion

4.5

89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vibrant, giftable packaging design
  • Consistently flavorful, high-quality fish
  • Ethical, sustainability-forward sourcing
  • Versatile, recipe-friendly selections
  • Small portions per tin
  • Occasionally dry cod texture
  • Overly smoky flavor variants
  • Inconsistent flavor intensity

Fishwife earns strong reviews for genuinely tasty, high-quality tinned seafood—standouts include Smoked Rainbow Trout, Smoked Albacore Tuna, and Fly By Jing Smoked Salmon—paired with striking, giftable packaging and an ethics-forward sourcing ethos. Reviews also flag meaningful drawbacks: small portions, frequent dryness or intense smokiness in certain SKUs (notably Campfire Cod), inconsistent flavor intensity, and a price that many consider steep for everyday use.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

219 reviews and posts

  • The campfire cod has a pretty smoky flavor straight out of the tin. I made one of the pasta recipes from the website and it was delicious. Super cute packaging.

    Feedback

    Not sure it's really worth buying multiple times.

    Verified purchase

  • The campfire cod was too smoky for my taste, but my partner liked it.

    Verified purchase

  • I appreciate the packaging, it's really engaging and does a nice job of explaining the brand. The cod was good, nice big chunks and the serving size was appropriate. Definitely high quality product.

    Feedback

    The flavor profile of this particular product was not one of my favorites. Personal preference would be less smoke and pepper flavor but I think it would meet the expectations of those seeking this type of flavor profile. A bit overpowering by the end of the can.

    Verified purchase

  • Got a variety pack & ate them all in one week — love the recipe inspo on their site! Definitely go for the tahini trout salad sandwich.

    Feedback

    No comment! Excited to order more!

  • I think the best thing about this brand is the branding. 10/10. Love the packaging, the colors, the vibe. Canned food is tasty? Yes. But nothing out of this world tbh, and don't think the extra cost vs competitors makes much sense. I think I'd rather spend the money in a more traditional albacore tuna from Spain when it comes to taste itself.

  • I want to love the product, and it's certainly good, but it's definitely overpriced and hit or miss account the flavors.

  • I got their variety pack when they first came out to gift to my boyfriend for his birthday. He loved it and he’s a tin fish connoisseur (according to him). I tried the spicy tuna the other day and it was so good. I put it on a pita cracker with a bit of cottage cheese and unlocked my new favorite snack

  • Convenient for lunch, but I wish the cans were larger for the cost. I especially like the collab with Fly by Jing.

  • I really like flavors of Fishwife I tried - Smoked Salmon with Fly by Jing Sichuan Chili Crisp and Smoked Rainbow Trout. I don't think they're necessarily worth the money, though, and I'm not sure how I would incorporate them into a larger meal

    Received a free product from Fishwife
  • Great product, great branding, great mission. Excited to see this brand get wider distribution!

  • High quality canned fish. Love the Fly by Jing collab smoked salmon.

  • Delicious! I was hesitant to hop on the tinned fish trend, but these were a great first step. Not too "fishy" and I didn't have to worry about accidentally leaking oil everywhere. I'd definitely buy again.

  • Fishwife is so so tasty, and has such a cute vibe. My personal favs are the rainbow trout jerky gems and their collar with fly by Jing. They're so good right out of the tin with some bread. I love bringing these to friends houses with a nice charcuterie board!

  • I love these tins. I had this company at Salty Girl in LA and was surprised at the elevated quality

  • Obsessed! I first learned about this from Kiernan Shipka's can't live without article and she obviously has good taste so, I had to look into it for myself. I bought a shipment with a couple of different ones and love how easy this is to pair for a quick meal or a snack.

    Feedback

    It has great packaging and so fun to eat. I would love to be able to get it locally so, excited for when it finally launches in Whole Foods.

  • Tinned fish! The packaging is what sells this. All of the fish inside is actually good too... but once you open the cardboard it isn't very unique. Does taste good though! And some fun collabs with other brands.

  • Whenever I see this brand in stores and on social media, I get a jolt of excitement. The branding is absolutely stunning. This makes for a great gift.

  • Super cute packaging and marketing. The taste of the cod was not my favorite—it had almost a jerky kind of flavor. Interesting concept, but it’s just not for me.

    Feedback

    Not sure. I’d need to try some more of their flavors.

  • SO yummy! I tried the campfire cod collab with Graza and it was super tasty and well seasoned. Brought it to the beach for a picnic with crackers, pickles and cheese .... *chef's kiss*

    Feedback

    I wish it was a liiiiiittle more affordable. Super pricey for a small amount of fish, but I understand fish is $$$.