Everlane reviews and discussion

4.1

84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Durable denim construction
  • Soft, luxurious cashmere
  • Minimalist, timeless aesthetics
  • Comfortable everyday pants
  • Inconsistent sizing accuracy
  • Boxy, unflattering silhouettes
  • Thin, shrink‑prone cotton tees
  • Narrow, blister‑prone footwear

Everlane proves a reliable source for well-made basics, according to reviews of Everlane, with standouts like Way‑High Jeans, Classic/Cheeky denim, cashmere, alpaca sweaters, and utility/barrel pants that hold up and anchor capsule wardrobes. Reviews also fault inconsistent sizing and boxy, unflattering cuts, variable fabric quality (thin tees, shrinking/pilling), and a drift from earlier simplicity—plus ethics concerns (union-busting) and limited size inclusivity—making the brand hit-or-miss depending on the piece.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

752 reviews and posts

  • I want to like Everlane more than I do. I keep trying, but it feels like quality has slipped over time, and I'm often somewhat disappointed. Over the years, I've gotten: - Two backpacks, both of which I adore! So that's a high note - Two pairs of shoes. One I love and wear frequently. The other pair seemed to be almost a full size too small? - A shirt jacket, weirdly shaped but salvageable as a layer (good, since it was final sale!) - A few shirts, none of which I kept - And a few other accessories that I largely liked So hit or miss, and heading more toward misses lately.

  • Sizing can be all over the place but overall I've felt my everlane pieces are high quality and hold up. Great for a core capsule wardrobe, although some of their rotating trendier pieces have an odd fit.

  • I looove my pair of pants that I bought from there (Utility Barrel) that I wear it like every week. I even bought 2 more colors of it. However, I'm so sad that I have only had it for like 3 months and the knees are starting to show wear and discoloration. Also, the sizing isn't that consistent for me.

  • High quality for price point - love the price transparency and commitment to basic designs that fit well

    Feedback

    Have heard that the internal culture at the company is at odds with the image projected outside the company; hope that leadership is taking this seriously and making changes

  • What can I say about Everlane!? I really do love this brand. Firstly, I’ve been using everlane backpacks for the past 10 years now, and I’ve only recently had to buy a second one. I also have a pair of pants from this brand that are so comfy and flattering. I find things to be priced well in relation to the quality as well.

    Feedback

    No improvements!

  • Hit or miss. Some of their products are my favorite pieces in my wardrobe (alpaca sweaters, easy pants), while others were COMPLETE failures and I had to donate/resell/return.

    Feedback

    Consistent pant sizing and more transparent measurements. A 4 in some pants is totally different in others. They don't provide the rise, so the easy pant (11" rise) fits totally differently than the easy shorts (8 or 9" rise).

  • I really want to like them, but I'm just not sure. They claim to be transparent but are they really? There has been a lot in question. The products are decent quality but you do pay for it. The shoes I like because they run narrow and I have a narrow foot so it's hard to shop. Overall I might purchase them on sale but would never pay full price.

    Feedback

    Increase your transparency.

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE their Track hoodies. Super comfy and high quality.

    Feedback

    For their shirts, the collar becomes really loose to easily.

  • Have trouble finding flattering items from Everlane and materials don't always feel high-quality.

  • Here is the thing. When you buy luxury items you can feel the difference in quality. Like how it is stitched or the materials used. Like I could go to Walmart and get leather flats for work. Or I could buy Everlane's leather womens loafers, which are so fancy I will keep them for years. I even bought 2 colors. Its a subtle but noticeable difference to an outfit that just elevates it. I really love their products for business casual or if you want understated elegance. Or if you want to impress your mother in law for Christmas, their Cashmere sweaters! Their items are a bit too pricey for my budget for every day wear or weekend casual. But I treasure the items I buy from them.

    Feedback

    Nothing! Thank you for making approachable, affordable luxury.

  • The Everlane products I’ve purchased over time are high quality, but not quite as classic as their brand tries to communicate. Many of their style simply fade with the trend, betraying their eco friendly message.

    Feedback

    MAKE BIGGER SIZES. This is one brand that could really take off if it were more size inclusive. Some of the designs feel a bit boring and almost remind me of The Gap. They do best when they truly embrace natural fabrics and designs that highlight all bodies.

  • Have been a big fan of the brand since it was launched! With my fair share of different pieces from Everlane, safe to say the quality matches its prices. My jeans are probably my favorite purchase amongst them all, and would recommend the brand predominantly for pants.

    Feedback

    I do wish the product line was a little more extensive.

  • I love so many of Everlane's pieces, but I get more and more frustrated with their sizing. I will check their sizing chart against my measurements, order the size it says to order, and still will get a pants size that 1 or 2 sizes too small. It makes you think they don't really have any interest in having sizing for women above a size 8 or 10.

    Feedback

    They *need* to 1) have more inclusive sizing and 2) have a more accurate size chart so we actually know what to order. Everlane, I want to give you my money but you make it so difficult sometimes!

  • Love Everlane, own multiple pieces from shoes to pants, bags, and tops. The feel of the products are high quality and the content of the clothing are typically 100% cotton or silk or other natural fibers.

    Feedback

    Sizing could be more consistent. I’m a size 00 for the pants but then a 2 for some dresses. It makes for some hassle involving returns.

  • Good quality clothes, especially for the basics. Love seeing all the markup related information and how they are saving us money.

    Feedback

    Keep the basics high quality, and in stock always :)

  • Love the clothes and the mission! They have a physical store in Seattle and I really enjoy the experience.

    Feedback

    Some of the sizing in inconsistent especially with the woman's sizing.

  • I have bought all my winter coats from everlane and I love them. They are good products and have kept me warm in cold winters. They are also beautiful and good quality.

    Feedback

    More sizing options.

  • Love the wardrobe staples for a capsule wardrobe. Materials are nice, but require extra maintenance.

    Feedback

    Pricing is a little high, especially when One Quince and Italic exist. Don't like the excessive logos.

  • Overall, great basics at a reasonable price. Some of their pants don't fit me that well, but what can you do. Everything I've gotten from them has been a good value.