I was kinda in between a 4 and 5 on this. I've always been interested in this brand but super skeptical of hte 4 in 1 pen. They were having a sale recently so i finally bought a bunch of stuff to try.
I was actually really pleasantly surprised by it. The 11th hour eyeshadow is shockingly good, it stays put without any real effort (I'm not good at makeup, I need easy products like this). I've tried a bunch of other eyeshadows like this in the past and found they don't last that long (I mean no eye shadow really does I think?) and this one stuck with me through a work day, through me layering a glittery product on top for a concert, jumping around at a concert and sweating like crazy, and then doing a quick wash of my face before bed. I mean there wasn't a lot left at that point but it wasn't 100% gone when i woke up.
also the tinted sunscreen (relatively new product) is my other clear winner here. I find myself reaching for it pretty often, its the best of this type of product i've tried for this kind of hybrid product. Nothing is as good as a bunch of separate products but sometimes you aren't in the mood for that. The tint coverage is actually a little higher than a lot of 'light' coverage foundations on the market right now, so its exactly what I always wanted those products to be and never quite got out of them. The downside is I feel like it also kind of highlights any skin texture (not pores but just the little bits of roughness. this is probably a YMMV issue but its not bad enough to bother me compared to the level of convenience.
The 4 in 1 pen is better product quality than I expected, and I think it'll go in my bag for travel, but I don't really care to use it over other products like that. However this + the tinted sunblock are going to be great travel companions. Fast and easy first thing in the morning, 2 products to pack instead of 5.
The concealer I used once and liked but don't have enough data to provide info on.
Oh also overall the packaging quality feels kinda cheap...but I also feel like its a plus for travel and for carrying in a bag for quick touchups. A lot of stuff is now coming in heavy glass packaging which looks and feels nice but weighs a ton. This stuff is super duper lightweight.