Magic Spoon reviews and discussion

The flavors are ok.. It’s very expensive and doesn’t have the best flavor. I would rather buy catalina crunch because it has a lot better flavor and texture.

Love this stuff

Love the idea of this brand, but I have to agree with others about the aftertaste. I've tried two flavors and while they resemble our childhood cereal, the aftertaste was weird and off-putting. It doesn't help that the bag is small and it's pricey.

Favorite cereal brand!! The s'mores flavor is so tasty. Amazing ingredients, low calorie, zero sugar, and high protein! 10/10

Interesting product. I like the Blueberry and Fruity. Wasn't really a fan of Cinnamon Roll. I hadn't had cereal in years and this has brought me back to having it occasionally. Worth a try!

Love the principle of higher quality cereal but there is still a lot of sugar.

Some flavors I've had from this brand are amazing and taste just like the originals (the fruit loops and peanut butter) but others have fallen extremely flat (even somewhat icky) in the flavor section. And for $10 a box it's not enough for a cereal to be packed with protein. I actually want it to taste good and relatively normal otherwise I'll just make a protein shake instead. Brand is hit or miss for me.

I was shocked at how much I enjoyed this cereal. The ingredients give it this amazing crunch and ability to not get soggy in milk that traditional cereals do not have. Minus one star for the price - it’s $10 for a box with almost half the amount of cereal as a traditional box. I’ve bought it twice and both times have only been because it was on clearance.

Must try!

Tasty cereal. Not crispy enough but once with milk taste amazing. I love them paired with some fruit and yoghurt. They add a little crunch which every yoghurt bowl needs.

Tried the fruit loop dupe flavor - tastes fine but definitely not the same as regular fruit loop cereal. It's less crunch and leaves a the milk a bit viscous.

Frosty and peanut butter are my favorite. Repeat purchase x 2.

This tastes pretty good, but the price tag is nothing short of shocking. For a very small amount the price is 8-10 dollars. I just can't justify the price going forward. I also really dislike the packaging.

Wanted to love Magic Spoon, but I thought it was just ok. With a picky eater, I often struggle to ensure they are getting enough protein in their diet, so I thought this would be a massive win for breakfast. But, my kids only semi-liked it; in fact they only ate half the box then wouldn't eat it again.

Didn’t think I’d like these but they grew on me a lot, and as someone who’s gluten free would definitely love this on occasion.

I think that teh brand is really good. But it can be better. I like that it is high protein and low protein, but is will like it to have a different flavor since it is not nice and feels weird in mouth.

OBSESSED! Cereal, to me, has always been more of a treat than a breakfast staple. I’m also highly averse to the taste of fake sugars. But THIS! We bought a multipack to try a few different flavors, and I can confidently say that we are big Magic Spoon fans! The flavors are great, I feel full after eating a bowl or two, and it feels like a real treat!

Cereal for adults! TBH nothing tastes great if it's sugar free (not a fan of artificial sugar-flavour) but this is bearable. I've had both their b-day cake cereal and their cereal treats. They're both a bit sweet but good if you want cereal and also want to get your protein in!

I usually do eat breakfast or when I do it’s usually hard boiled eggs. I usually don’t like my cereal in milk because it gets soggy. Tried this and yes it gets soggy like the rest. I eat them dry like Cheerios as a snack. They do satisfy my sweet tooth as a snack but the price is just too high for me. Taste is okay though. Maybe if you ate cereal all the time it would be good but I don’t and for the price would stick to my egg.

Unfortunately these were not for me. I am definitely a cereal snob and very brand particular, so I didnt try these with high hopes. They flavors don't taste like what they are marketed as and they also gave me heartburn.