Thingtesting Logo

Cometeer Coffee

4.3 • 121 Reviews

Cometeer Coffee makes incredibly delicious coffee that gets sent straight to your freezer door in a tiny little recyclable capsule.

cometeer.comArrow up right
Shop
Reward
15% reward
Cometeer Coffee Reviews

Best of Thingtesting4.3

Cometeer Coffee earns strong reviews for delivering cafe-level flavor and exceptional convenience—flash‑frozen capsules dissolve into smooth, fresh‑tasting coffee that shines for iced lattes and quick hot cups—yet the brand draws criticism for excessive packaging, freezer-space demands, and subscription frustrations. Reviews also note inconsistent customization of roasters/flavors, occasional damaged or melted pods, and a few complaints of bitter taste or very high caffeine, making it outstanding for speed and variety but imperfect for sustainability purists or those wary of subscriptions.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Rewards
Shop
Review
Reward
15% reward

Join to earn a 15% reward

Join Thingtesting to earn a cash-based commission when you shop and review Cometeer Coffee using our link.

By continuing, you agree to Thingtesting’s Terms of Service, Community Guidelines, and the use of data in the Privacy Policy

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 121

  • 10mo ago

    My trusty Nespresso died and I’ve been trying to find a way around a new one for the time being. I am thrilled with the variety, taste, and convenience of Cometeer! They don’t take up much space in my freezer either, which I appreciate. I put the capsules in recycling after use and appreciate the aluminum construction.

    Verified purchase

  • 4y ago

    THIS IS A MUST TEST. Cometeer is simply genius. Cold-brewed coffee loses half the flavor as hot brewed, and these puppies have all the bold flavor of a true cup of coffee in the most convenient way possible. These are nitro frozen and don't touch oxygen until opened... pour in a cup with ice and milk or whatever you want and BOOM -- Coffee shop equivalent coffee. About 150mg of caffeine and it gets you GOING! They even partner with your favorite local coffee shops... it's seriously the easiest and best tasting thing out there... Skips the whole Keuric process of water & heating and is so simple.

  • 5y ago

    I started ordering Cometeer to try it out and I have kept reordering! The coffee is high quality and I like that it comes from brands I know. The packaging is sleek and the pods are recyclable. It's really been the easiest way to quickly make coffee before a meeting. It's also just cool.

    Feedback

    I wish there as better communication around reordering. I would love texts vs. emails because if a box is coming and I'm not around it's not ideal since the product is frozen.

  • 4y ago

    They have some great coffees and some icky ones... I guess coffee is so based on personal flavor preference. I think the packaging and the use is amazing... but I had a really hard tome stopping my subscription, which I didnt even realize I signed up for, so that caught me by surprise. Still trying to get through all the coffee I ordered... personally prefer my Nespresso still but I think those who like cold brews will love these different coffee. I will way I LOVEEE the half calf options! Making a half calf iced coffee is like the greatest thing in the world. Also, I brought a few packages with me for a weekend away with friends and people LOVED trying out all the NYC coffees and making them... fun crowd pleaser!

View all 121 reviews

Alternatives

What is Cometeer Coffee?

Cometeer Coffee makes incredibly delicious coffee that gets sent straight to your freezer door in a tiny little recyclable capsule.

In their own words

Create massive positive change in the coffee-verse. From farm to roaster to consumer. More fair, more delicious, more sustainable, more future-forward.