Charlotte Tilbury

Charlotte Tilbury

Charlotte Tilbury reviews and discussion

4.2

80% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Luxe, glamorous packaging aesthetics
  • Blendable, silky complexion formulas
  • Long-wearing, effective setting spray
  • Universally flattering nude lip options
  • Inconsistent, underwhelming mascara performance
  • Divisive pillow talk shade match
  • Chunky wooden lip liner packaging
  • Leaky sponge-tip wand applicators

Charlotte Tilbury earns largely positive reviews for delivering a polished, glowy finish—especially via Pillow Talk lip products, Magic Cream, setting spray, and Hollywood Flawless Filter—yet the brand draws criticism for inconsistent hits (mascara, some eyeshadows), divisive Pillow Talk shades, and packaging quirks. Reviews also flag issues with scent, sticky or heavy textures on some skincare, shade range gaps, leaky wands, and a powder with poor blurring and an off-putting smell, making the brand compelling for glow-forward looks but not universally flawless.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

49 reviews and posts

  • The eye shadown palette is perfect. The eyeshadow colors were easy to place on my eyelids The colors are not heavy. These shades work for both my every day eye for the office and more dramatic but sophisticated looks.

  • I received this sample of Charlotte Tilbury Magic Cream when I really needed some magic to happen. I was getting dry patches, possibly due to mild eczema or possibly due to other products drying me out. I did see instant success and felt more moisturized quickly too. I used it underneath my makeup and felt that it protected me throughout the day. I’ve used it several times but would love to try it more. I have other similar products, one that’s more moisturizing but has a lighter barrier, and one that’s a touch heavier. I’d still like to try the cream when I’m not in as bad of shape and see how it works then, but based on my experience, I’m overall happy with it!

  • The packaging of the product is a mess for the amount that you are paying but it is worth it when you consider the formulation of the product and how flawless it looks. PSA it enhances closed comedones and texture.

  • love this highlighter and blush duo - beautiful colors and blending. the sponge tip applicator is lovely to use, but sometimes too much comes out and the packaging becomes a little leaky. lasts a long time.

  • Truly one of the best foundations I’ve ever used. It gives such a flawless finish while still feeling super lightweight on the skin. It blends beautifully, looks natural, and makes my skin look so smooth and healthy without feeling heavy or cakey. I always feel so much more confident when I wear it because it just makes my skin look and feel amazing.

  • I tried their Pillow Talk lipstick and I was not impressed. It looked chalky on my lips and was not flattering on my naturally light pink lips. Also, it is not very flattering for fair to light skin tones (makes me look dead).

    Received a free product from Charlotte Tilbury
  • I bought lip cheat for my wedding make up and it lasts all night. It’s super easy to use and the color is so cute (supersize me). I would recommend this product and look forward to trying additional colors.

  • I love this contour wand and I love the color and the way the product comes out onto the blender. The only downside of these wands is that bacteria grows and collects on them and in the long run I don’t think these types of products are good for my skin.

  • Amazing highlighter been using it daily for over a year. Gives just enough highlight without being overbearing. Will be keeping this in my routine for years to come. Perfect addition to your makeup bag.

  • I love the Pillow Talk blush because it works well on my tan skin. I first tried my friend's blush when I forgot my makeup bag. The next time I visited Sephora, I bought my own despite the price. I felt like it was well worth the price and quickly became my go-to blush for work. It's glittery without being overwhelming. I purchased the flawless setting spray after I finished my MAC fix+ setting spray. I read reviews that it was long-lasting and prevented makeup transfer on face masks. I do like the setting spray, but I would disagree that it does not stop my makeup from transferring to my facemask (which I wear at work every day); however it's still better than MAC setting spray in this regard.

  • Charlotte Tilbury is such great quality! I wore almost exclusively charlotte tilbury for my makeup on my wedding day and I still use many of the products. The Hollywood Flawless filter is a gamechanger for someone who doesn't need much coverage.

  • I love Charlotte Tilbury products in general. They’re really high quality and leave your skin looking amazing. They last all day and their skin care is amazing. I’m currently using one of their foundations that’s made with daikon radish to leave your skin looking amazing even after you take it off. My only issue is I can’t find a lot of their foundations in my shade.

  • I own a bunch of Charlotte Tilbury products and have always thought they were excellent purchases. Their make up is super high quality and always gets the job done. My only complaint is that the things I want are often sold out when I go to Ulta. Also their setting spray is the best I've ever tried, no exaggeration.

  • These are great products for professional working 20 and 30 something and above. I would recommend for those reasons because of the universal shades offered. Traditional colours. As s redhead, I recommend.

  • I have and like the pillow talk lip set. I recently tried the mascara and it was a miss for me. The brand overall is great and innovative. I’m not a huge makeup girlie but I do think I would repurchase the lippie

  • Not a huge fan of the texture. It’s milky and a bit sticky, and it kind of just sits on top of your skin. It also has kind of an odd scent. It’s not overwhelming and not overly bothersome, but I would prefer not to smell it as it sits on my face. I do like that it contains vit C and niacinamide, but the texture is too heavy for acne prone skin. It caused a major breakout for me

  • Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk products truly live up to the hype. The shades are universally flattering and give that soft, effortless “your lips but better” look. I’ve used the lipstick, lip liner, and blush, and they all work beautifully together for a polished, natural glow. The formulas are smooth, blendable, and feel luxe without being over-the-top. It’s one of the few beauty lines where I’ve repurchased multiple times—Pillow Talk has definitely earned a permanent spot in my makeup routine.

  • I've tried lipsticks and eye shadows by Charlotte Tilbury and none of them really speak to me. I was gifted them by a family member and they're in the bottom of my makeup bin. I just don't reach for them vs other brands. I want to love Charlotte Tilbury, but I haven't found the product for me yet!

  • The Airbrush Brightening Flawless Finish powder is a bit steep on the cost but for setting your eye makeup, it's the best one I've tried yet. Comes in a compact which is travel friendly too! The powder itself looks white but goes on sheer and leaves a subtle matte finish. Only gripe is the cost.

  • I have only tried a few products from Charlotte Tilbury but have loved them all and will continue to try more. I used to have an eyeshadow palette that went on so easily and blended amazingly well. It was a neutral, four color palette that I used up. I have also loved the matte lipstick and the collection of lip liners. They go on so easily and the color options are perfect for every option, and last all day.