Benefit reviews and discussion

4.3

94% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • High-performing brow gel
  • Precise eyebrow pencil definition
  • Lengthening, volumizing mascaras
  • Smooth, blendable hoola bronzer
  • Juvenile-looking product packaging
  • Drying lip and cheek tints
  • Clumpy or flaking mascaras
  • Primer pilling, acne irritation

Benefit earns strong reviews for high-performing brow products and mascaras that deliver visible volume, length, and hold, while bronzers, lip/cheek tints, and the POREfessional line smooth and set makeup effectively. Reviews also flag drawbacks: non–cruelty-free status, occasionally juvenile packaging, drying or hard-to-remove formulas (tints, some mascaras), potential clumping/flaking, and primer that can worsen acne or pill on drier skin—making the brand effective but not universally suitable.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

36 reviews and posts

  • Benefit has been a favorite of mine for a while. I love their eyebrow products the best. I do feel like some of the packaging is a bit juvenile though & probably would buy more if they looked more mature.

  • This brand isn’t cruelty free so I won’t buy from them. Many of their products don’t interest me anyway. The prices are good though

  • Benetint b y Benefit has been one of my makeup that doesn't look like makeup favorites for a long time. The brow gel is top notch too.

  • Decent brand .. I like to get my eyebrows done at ulta and they have good eyebrow pencils

  • The brow gel is one of the few that I like. It works well. It is quite hard to fix after it has dried and don't like that it sometimes clumps, but if you do it properly, looks amazing.

  • I really liked the Bang mascara. My eyelashes aren't very long, but this mascara would make them pop. The formula is a really rich black that’s quite noticeable and the bristles of the brush really grip my lashes to separate and emphasize them. It was so weird to use this and actually see my lashes lol

  • I LOVE LOVE LOVEEEE their products. Their brow gel is part of my (almost) daily routine - it's so good and convenient to transport. I always keep it with me in the bag in case my brows need some work. Their mascara is also super good - it leaves my lashes looking good without being too overpowering.

  • Not all products are great. But their mascaras and brow products are my absolute favorites that I continue to repurchase and recommend constantly. I particularly love the brow glue over any others on the market and is definitely worth the price (I have tried Glossier, Anastasia, Nyx, and elf ones). It is not crusty and stays completely invisible throughout the day while keeping your eyebrows in place

  • I’ve tested a lot of products of this brand : the hoola powder, the cakeless concealer, the brow gel, the highlighter pencil, and the brow pencil… In the fact there’s brand is super cool the products are super. It’s worth of money. But the composition is always super for the pencil for example… I would love to test the benetint and the cookie highlighter !! bit expensive, but it’s okay because the products are really effective!

  • Benefit brow products have been a game changer for me. As a blonde girly, i have nearly clear eyebrows. the benefit products are easy to use and have people asking me if I got my brows microbladed. My favorite product is the brow wax

  • I have used mostly the volumizing eyebrow gel for years and absolutely love it! Great product. I do recommend it! It makes my brows look fuller and natural. The brush is very well designed. The instructions in the box are also super helpful.

  • I have used mostly the eye makeup. The mascara Ave eyebrow gel! Great products. I do recommend their mascara!

  • Great! I love this brand. It’s affordable, durable and it’s easy to get your hands on. I am so excited to purchase from this brand again!

  • This brand has been a favorite of mine for a long while. Amazing quality. Amazing products. Best brow pencil and gel i've ever had. No other product does it like the benefit brow pencil and gel.

  • Benefits Bad Gal Bang Mascara is one of the best mascaras I've ever used! The formula combined with the applicator wand is almost magic!

  • Influencer for Benefit