Vagabond reviews and discussion

I have been repurchasing the Vagabond Judy as my elevated work sneaker for a few years, I am on my 3rd pair. I really love the look of these, and am really happy with the quality. The only issue that I have ever had has been the back heels wearing out a little quick, but I do find this happens to a lot of my shoes (so maybe it's just me). Either way, I really love this pair and will continue to repurchase as I think they are a nice elevated sneaker, perfect for work or non-work. Also, super comfortable and easy to keep clean.

I love this brand! Just about every year I buy a new pair of booties from them – I live in NYC and walk a lot. Although, they are very durable and really don't need to be replaced that frequently. I have gotten a few pairs resoled and they feel like new shoes! Given how much I'm out walking, they are extremely comfortable and their designs are always timeless, yet very chic and stylish. I've tried both their more square shaped and pointed toes and both are equally as comfortable. My go-to brand for sure! I would however recommend buying from alternate sites or stores than their website as they do not offer free returns/exchanges. Over the years I have found them to be true to size and very consistent no matter the style.

I have the vegan loafers and I love them! I put in different insoles (the standard insoles were pretty flimsy) and they are very comfortable now!

I have to say, most of my shoes are from Vagabond. They're quick with the trends, but also produce styles that can be worn for years on end (I have a couple of pairs like that). Deducting a point as their quality and sizing is not always the best, not to mention some political issues in the past.

If you are in NYC, there are so many places to get Vagabond shoes from! My favorite is ShoeMarket in Brooklyn. Vagabond is a super reliable brand for leather shoes with great quality control! However, they still do need care just like any other leather shoe. If you are new to leather shoes, please be sure to look into proper care of them, because they do not last like sneakers. The sizing is quite consistent and the shoes are comfortable once broken in. They have something for everybody, and very likely, more than one thing for everybody!

I recently purchased COSMO boots and they were the comfiest boots I've ever owned. However, after 3 months, the seams on them got loose and very quickly got ripped in those areas so I had to, unfortunately, return them.

NOT WORTH THE PRICE! I just received my Vagabond Norah two days ago and on my first day wearing it I received winter sale email. Now the shoe is 80 dollars cheaper and they don’t have price match policy. So don’t buy until it’s on sale! They still have all the sizes, definitely wait!