Tate’s Bake Shop

Tate’s Bake Shop

Tate’s Bake Shop reviews and discussion

4.5

87% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Buttery flavor profile
  • Crispy, addictive texture
  • High-quality chocolate chips
  • Excellent gluten-free execution
  • Overly crunchy texture
  • Occasionally too sweet
  • Crumbly, breakage-prone cookies
  • Stales quickly after opening

Tate’s Bake Shop earns glowing reviews for thin, crisp, buttery cookies—especially the classic and gluten-free chocolate chip—which many call the best store-bought option, close to homemade. Reviews also flag clear drawbacks: the cookies are very crunchy (divisive for chewy-cookie fans), sometimes too sweet or oily, crumbly, go stale quickly in the bag, and feel sparse per package.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

126 reviews and posts

  • My FAVORITE cookies! I love the variety of flavors. The crunch that these have are perfect & definitely a favorite in my household. I wish the price was a little lower, but the quality is much better than other options.

  • I am a cookie snob and if it doesn’t have a good texture or a good taste then I won’t eat it! These cookies have the perfect crunch, the perfect amount of chocolate, and there are so many flavors to choose from!

  • Love these cookies! While I am not gluten free or vegan, I have several friends or family who are and these cookies are a great option to have for those who avoid dairy or gluten. The texture is my favorite part, very crunchy without being too hard.

  • These cookies are quite crunchy and create a lot of crumbs - I wish they were a bit softer and chewier. As expected, they are very sweet with a lot of sugar. However, the taste is good overall.

  • Maybe this one’s for the crispy burnt cookie lovers out there but as a soft chewy cookie aficionado, this one was just not for me.

  • Appreciate the gluten free cookies! I have celiac and am able to enjoy the gf Tate’s options. They are so tasty and have a texture similar to the original Tate’s cookies

  • Best store bought cookie experience ever! They are so packed with flavor and give the best texture in a cookie! Definitely a high quality treat 🥰

  • The thing I like most about this brand is it's consistency. I have friends who are gluten intolerant, which can make shopping for snacks a hassle. However, these cookies are great in that they not only are safe for my friends to eat, but they're so tasty. Normally I like them a little thicker, but the balance of cookie to chocolate chip is just right.

  • The lemon cookies are sooooo good. I’ve actually seen some of the flavors at Aldi!! Worth the price as a yummy splurge.

  • These cookies are consistently delicious. I’ve never had a bad cookie from Tate’s. I love their classic chocolate chip as well as their seasonal offerings! They’re good if you like a good snap with your cookie. They definitely have crunch to them.

  • I’ve tried most of their flavors and for a packaged crispy cookie it’s definitely a winner. If your like me though and like a crispy outside but moist chewy inside this might not be the cookie brand for you!

  • Absolutely love these cookies! So tasty, but you have to love a crunchy cookie - my favorite is the classic chocolate chip.

  • These are addictively good. Love the thinness of the cookie which makes it taste more homemade to me. I got my mom hooked on them too.

    Friends with Tate’s Bake Shop
  • Tate’s for prez! Just so good. I’ve loved them for such a long time. Their double chocolate cookie is absolute perfection. Best part is that now that I can’t have gluten, they have a gluten free version! Fan for life.

  • Not worth the hype - IMO you can get cheaper cookies that taste better. Other people love them but they're not worth it for me.

  • chocolate chip cookie are ridiculously good, and vegan so tell all your non vegans friends they are here to stay.

  • Hands down amazing. I can’t keep them in our house for more than a few minutes with my husband and kids. They are crispy and so delicious.

  • Outside of homemade, these are best store bought cookies I have ever tasted.