Tate’s Bake Shop

Tate’s Bake Shop

Tate’s Bake Shop reviews and discussion

4.5

87% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Buttery flavor profile
  • Crispy, addictive texture
  • High-quality chocolate chips
  • Excellent gluten-free execution
  • Overly crunchy texture
  • Occasionally too sweet
  • Crumbly, breakage-prone cookies
  • Stales quickly after opening

Tate’s Bake Shop earns glowing reviews for thin, crisp, buttery cookies—especially the classic and gluten-free chocolate chip—which many call the best store-bought option, close to homemade. Reviews also flag clear drawbacks: the cookies are very crunchy (divisive for chewy-cookie fans), sometimes too sweet or oily, crumbly, go stale quickly in the bag, and feel sparse per package.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

126 reviews and posts

  • My FAVORITE cookies! I love the variety of flavors. The crunch that these have are perfect & definitely a favorite in my household. I wish the price was a little lower, but the quality is much better than other options.

  • I am a cookie snob and if it doesn’t have a good texture or a good taste then I won’t eat it! These cookies have the perfect crunch, the perfect amount of chocolate, and there are so many flavors to choose from!

  • Love these cookies! While I am not gluten free or vegan, I have several friends or family who are and these cookies are a great option to have for those who avoid dairy or gluten. The texture is my favorite part, very crunchy without being too hard.

  • These cookies are quite crunchy and create a lot of crumbs - I wish they were a bit softer and chewier. As expected, they are very sweet with a lot of sugar. However, the taste is good overall.

  • Maybe this one’s for the crispy burnt cookie lovers out there but as a soft chewy cookie aficionado, this one was just not for me.

  • Appreciate the gluten free cookies! I have celiac and am able to enjoy the gf Tate’s options. They are so tasty and have a texture similar to the original Tate’s cookies

  • The thing I like most about this brand is it's consistency. I have friends who are gluten intolerant, which can make shopping for snacks a hassle. However, these cookies are great in that they not only are safe for my friends to eat, but they're so tasty. Normally I like them a little thicker, but the balance of cookie to chocolate chip is just right.

  • The lemon cookies are sooooo good. I’ve actually seen some of the flavors at Aldi!! Worth the price as a yummy splurge.

  • These cookies are consistently delicious. I’ve never had a bad cookie from Tate’s. I love their classic chocolate chip as well as their seasonal offerings! They’re good if you like a good snap with your cookie. They definitely have crunch to them.

  • I’ve tried most of their flavors and for a packaged crispy cookie it’s definitely a winner. If your like me though and like a crispy outside but moist chewy inside this might not be the cookie brand for you!

  • Absolutely love these cookies! So tasty, but you have to love a crunchy cookie - my favorite is the classic chocolate chip.

  • These are addictively good. Love the thinness of the cookie which makes it taste more homemade to me. I got my mom hooked on them too.

    Friends with Tate’s Bake Shop
  • Tate’s for prez! Just so good. I’ve loved them for such a long time. Their double chocolate cookie is absolute perfection. Best part is that now that I can’t have gluten, they have a gluten free version! Fan for life.

  • Not worth the hype - IMO you can get cheaper cookies that taste better. Other people love them but they're not worth it for me.

  • chocolate chip cookie are ridiculously good, and vegan so tell all your non vegans friends they are here to stay.

  • Hands down amazing. I can’t keep them in our house for more than a few minutes with my husband and kids. They are crispy and so delicious.

  • Outside of homemade, these are best store bought cookies I have ever tasted.

  • Ok, so I'm a huge cookie fan and my mom tops me in this respect. For a while, she kept these hidden because she didn't want me anywhere near them. She was right to do so, these are the bomb.com. Like they are perfectly crisp to the crunch but not burnt and have such a solid flavor. I would definitely recommend buying them on sale since they are a bit on the expensive side. But they're also available at Costco in bigger packs (yet still wrapped in groups of 5 cookies) so they stay fresh.