Thingtesting Logo

Smallhold

4.7 • 49 Reviews

Smallhold sells organic, freshly harvested speciality mushrooms.

smallhold.comArrow up right
Shop Arrow up right
Smallhold Reviews

4.7

Smallhold reviews assert the brand works: customers repeatedly call the mushrooms fresh, meaty, and delicious but note high price and inconsistent pack sizes. Reviewers praise unique, clean varieties, eco cardboard packaging, and reliable flavor and texture; common drawbacks are short shelf life, occasional mold/bruising, and small/uneven portions that make cooking awkward.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 49

  • 1y ago

    When I can’t make it to my local greenmarket, I always reach for Smallhold mushrooms at Whole Foods. They’ve become a staple — consistently high quality, organic, and available in a great range of varieties that go beyond the basics. A+ packaging, and the 'shrooms have always been fresh, flavorful, and beautifully grown. I really appreciate being able to count on mushrooms this good even when I’m shopping at a grocery store. Great people, great products!

  • 2y ago

    Awesome mushrooms! I got the BOGO Free offer with try new things and was so excited for the assortment. I bought trumpet mushrooms and made the Serious Eats trumpet mushroom “B”LT and then used the assorted for a wild mushroom risotto. Love the assortment, love the packaging. All around great experience.

    Verified purchase

  • 2y ago

    Loved these mushrooms! Had a BOGO coupon, so ended up purchasing one pack of blue oyster mushrooms plus a second package with a mix of blue and yellow oyster mushrooms (I would have tried more diverse types, but at the two stores that had them near me these were the only varieties available). They were easy to prepare (stovetop stir-fried with olive oil, kale, and a bit of ginger) and really meaty. The only drawback, and why I am not giving them 5 stars, is the cost. At $9.50/package, I can't imagine I would buy them regularly, esp. knowing I can find oyster mushrooms at local Asian markets for much less. Still, they were and are super tasty!

    Verified purchase

  • 3y ago

    Got a blue oyster grow kit for my father for Christmas, and grew a large clump of great blue oysters! Couldn't get it to produce a second batch though, despite following instructions from the website.

View all 49 reviews

Alternatives

What is Smallhold?

Smallhold sells organic, freshly harvested speciality mushrooms.

In their own words

Smallhold, a Certified B Corporation, is a growing network of organic mushroom farms with operations in Brooklyn, Austin, Los Angeles, and beyond. Named one of Fast Company’s 2023 Most Innovative Companies, Smallhold is upending the traditional model for mushroom cultivation and distribution. By operating urban farms in strategic regions, growing mushrooms on byproducts from other industries, and using compostable cardboard packaging, Smallhold improves product quality and extends shelf life, all while reducing overall footprint, food waste, and plastic usage.