Muddy Bites reviews and discussion

4.4

90% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Nostalgic concept, clever execution
  • Crisp cone, satisfying crunch
  • Rich, flavorful chocolate filling
  • Fun flavors, seasonal variety
  • Occasional stale, cardboard cone
  • Chocolate bloom, unappealing appearance
  • Chocolate texture overly hard
  • Dry bite without ice cream

Muddy Bites earns enthusiastic reviews for delivering the nostalgic “best bite” of an ice cream cone with crisp mini cones and satisfying chocolate cores, proving the brand is a good—and often addictive—treat. Reviews also flag weaknesses: some batches taste bland or cardboard-like, chocolate can bloom or feel too hard/sweet, and without cold ice cream the experience can feel dry or less magical.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

150 reviews and posts

  • Innovative product

    Feedback

    Loved the concept but the end of the cone isn’t as good without a hint of ice cream seeping in.

  • What a fun snack! Love the flavors, branding, and concept. Delicious treat.

    Feedback

    A little expensive for small-ish bags

  • The snacks were good, but hard to find, and very expensive for how much came in the bag. Tasty but overall not worth it.

    Feedback

    Price

  • Insanely tasty and at a reasonable price in my opinion, especially if you purchase the variety pack on their website. I expected to like the milk chocolate the least because most milk chocolate flavors are just too sweet, but it was actually very pleasant and paired so nicely with the waffle cone. So, so addicting.

    Feedback

    All 4 bags of dark chocolate were bloomed. Not very pleasant to look at, and very crumbly. Not to mention that the dark chocolate just wasn't very good quality. Very one note/flat flavor with an acidic profile.

  • These are GREAT and so fun to eat. Truly the best part of eating an ice cream cone, plus you can bring them with you any wear. Wish they came in larger bags!

  • Great at curbing sweet cravings. These are very crunchy- which isn't a bad thing, but I feel like that doesn't match that "bottom of the cone" experience you may be looking for.

  • Delicious! I do love that little bit of chocolate at the bottom of an ice cream cone, so I knew I’d be a fan. Super smart to make that into a snack.

    Feedback

    Definitely more flavors.

  • Super cute and tasty! I highly recommend! My favorite thing about waffle cone ice cream is the waffle cone,so this was a huge win for me in snacks.

  • I can't stop eating these (dark chocolate) - and was so pleasantly surprised when I realized the serving size is SEVEN and not something minuscule like 4. Perfect (extreme) crunch, great chocolate quality, perfect amount of chocolate fill.

    Feedback

    n/a!

  • I LOVED these and found them to be a fun and addictive snack. However, as others have mentioned, the servings are so small for what you pay for. At Target they're $4 a bag and it has maybe 15ish pieces which is pretty much enough for 1. Worth a try though! I put mine in the fridge and it made it even better + more authentic to the traditional experience :)

  • I tried a bag of white chocolate: the waffle cone smelled and tasted like cardboard, as another reviewer noted. I'm assuming it was an off-batch since it was inedible and I had another flavor where the cone tasted fine. I understand small brands would have QC issues early on as they figure out production. Tried a bag of milk chocolate which was much better and not "off". That being said, the cone part tastes more like a bland wafer than a waffle cone. Chocolate had great consistency and flavor though.

  • These were delicious and so hard to put down.

  • I love the concept!! Dark chocolate flavor was the only option which is not my favorite, I’d be very excited to try other ones.

  • I actually really enjoyed these. It’s a small treat so you don’t over eat and gives you the sweet crunchy taste you need. Will purchase again!

  • Bought these on a whim for a camping trip and they were the perfect crunchy-creamy sweet treat!

  • I was so excited when I saw these at the store, I of course had to buy all 3 bags that they had in stock! This is my favorite part of the cone! It tastes just like the last bite of your ice cream cone!