3.7
68% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Good American
3.7 • 26 Reviews
•

3.7
68% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Good American earns largely positive reviews for durable, flattering denim that holds shape through years of wear, though sizing inconsistency and occasional quality issues temper the praise. Reviews cite inclusive sizing, comfortable stretch, and confidence-boosting fits as strengths, while complaints include wildly variable sizes, loose or high waists, buttons or seams failing, and mixed results beyond denim.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
5mo ago
I have many, many pair of Good American jeans and a few jackets and tops. I am pleased with the quality of the material, the fit, the way the material holds-up to washing and the compliments I get when wearing their brand! I always suggest this brand to others when they are looking for a clothing line to try!

10mo ago
I wanted to hate this brand (sorry, just not usually a Kardashian fan), but damn, they really are now my go-to jeans. They hold up well, reform to your body if it gains or loses a few lbs, and are FREAKING FLATTERING.

1y ago
I’ve had a couple Good American jeans and I was not impressed with the quality. The buttons like to fall off. I don’t think any of the jeans I’ve had were very flattering on me. I like some of their newer styles of jeans , but I can’t justify the price knowing the quality is not there.

4y ago
I recently got a pair of Good American jeans and Good American leggings. The leggings don't feel true to size. I got a small which is supposed to be a 2/4 and it felt like a medium. The jeans aren't exactly true to size either, unless I lost weight. I am a 26 in the waist and I ended up needing to size down to a 25 for a proper fit.
Feedback
Leggings could be more true to size. Jeans fit great but could be a little more true to size

9mo ago
I really like the fit of most of these products. And I think it’s cool. They’re very size inclusive. It’s also pretty easy to find good American at Nordstrom, and Nordstrom rack, the good American store or online. The only thing is I do feel like their past products were higher quality than the current products now. They also had a really good activewear line going for a while and now I only see denim.
I was able to work with a digital stylist because it became too frustrating to find a pair of petite jeans and she pulled some from Good American. I purchased a straight-leg pair in a medium wash and rise and I was surprised with the quality and fit. The stretch and elastane have helped keep the shape through many washes and while I haven't purchased from the brand again, I do peek at the site and get their promo emails. The range of styles and sizes is more than most brands, but for petite styles, it's still lacking. a decent assortment.
2y ago
The jeans were good quality but the reason I ranked them lower because they were insanely high wasted. Plus, the jeans looked so insanely different on me than on the model and we didn’t have that crazy of a different body type - it almost seemed like they were completely different pants.
I got two of their pieces for a collaboration and I loved the quality. I never thought to try Good American, but wow! It was definitely worth it! The jeans fit like a glove and the bodysuit was so flattering on. I highly recommend trying them and splurging on some quality pieces.
4y ago
I have had a few pairs of jeans from them and loved the way they feel! This was definitely the first brand of its kind to be all-inclusive and really was reachable by everybody. I really like supporting a company with that mission. With countless styles, it's impossible not to be able to find something that I don't like.
Feedback
The price is a little steep. Not always in stores so you do have to purchase online sometimes.
I wasn’t impressed with the fit. The waist was still too loose and the pants ride down while wearing, which is so annoying.
I have a pair of Good American jeans I bought from Nordstrom a few years ago. They are so comfortable for denim, flattering and hug in all of the right places, and have held up really well. I would definitely consider buying another pair of Good American jeans in the future.
I bought the jeans I got from them with a discount code, and I'm pretty happy. I got exactly what I wanted and while they are not 100% denim, I believe they will hold up very well. They fit good and I think I look good in them.
Feedback
The website is pretty annoying, and they email spam. I also think the size chart can be unreliable. I had to make an exchange.
the jeans are so hit or miss with me. the sizes, although inclusive, seem to be all over the place - even when referencing the size guide and comments. i am consistently the same size in most brands and with good american i am anywhere between a 2 and an 8. i wouldn’t mind buying a few sizes at a time to find one that fits, but with their frequent sales, returning isn’t always an option. i will say when i do get lucky with sizing, the jeans are great quality and have great durability. i’m still wearing a pair i got 4 years ago and the quality is still great. i will say though that i’ve never had luck with the shoes and refuse to buy them now after being stuck with so many pairs.
Love!! However, I'm really glad theyre starting to be in more physical stores/building their own brick and mortars. It's hard to tell how the pants will fit/look on you when ordering online. My biggest issue with them is that I get texts/emails from them every single day and have diligently tried to unsubscribe. Regardless, great denim!
I have some pairs from here I absolutely love and other pairs that I could do without. The sizing is absolutely wild because some pairs I'm a 6 and others I'm a 10. They are a good quality and look great on, but not exactly worth the cost. Maybe if they were more around the $80 price point regularly, instead of only when on sale would they be more worth it.
4y ago
Nothing but good things to say about Good American. I own their shorts, crop denim, white denim, black denim, and 90s denim.
Feedback
The waist bands could have a bit more sinch to them. Since many women wearing them are curvier or have large quads like me, I would appreciate the stretch in the quads but a slightly snugger waste band on some.
Good American impresses with its inclusive sizing and body-positive ethos. The denim and fashion offerings cater to a wide range of body types, promoting confidence and style for all. While the prices can be higher, the quality and fit justify the investment. Elevate your wardrobe with pieces that celebrate diversity and fashion-forward thinking. Definitely the most comfortable jeans I have tried!!
3y ago
Love Good American!! I'm not kidding - I have a few pairs of jeans by them that are still in great shape after 7 years. SEVEN. YEARS. They are so amazing and definitely worth the price point!! Perfect denim to invest in that will LAST!
2y ago
I have two of the Fit for Success jumpsuits and they are my current favorite things to wear. super comfy and flattering, and the denim is very high quality. I get non-stop compliments every time I wear them out in the world.
3y ago
Wanted to Love and give a 5 star because I love the way they fit so much! But both pair I purchased split apart between the back pockets. I got refunded for 1 pair only. Because this happened , I won’t be buying any more. Which makes me really sad. They need to do better with the product!