Good American reviews and discussion

3.7

68% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Durable denim construction longevity
  • Flattering, body-contouring fit
  • Comfortable stretch fabric
  • Inclusive, extensive size range
  • Inconsistent sizing variability
  • Occasional seam or button failures
  • Waist fit overly high or loose
  • Swim and footwear underperform

Good American earns largely positive reviews for durable, flattering denim that holds shape through years of wear, though sizing inconsistency and occasional quality issues temper the praise. Reviews cite inclusive sizing, comfortable stretch, and confidence-boosting fits as strengths, while complaints include wildly variable sizes, loose or high waists, buttons or seams failing, and mixed results beyond denim.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

26 reviews and posts

  • Don’t waste your money. Hand washed the cutout underwire swimsuit prior to wearing and the casing covering the underwire pilled and frayed.

  • Was not impressed. The waist was too loose and the pants ride down while wearing.

  • i bought the satin one shoulder bikini top in bubble pink, and i’m so disappointed. the material is so soft and nice, but once you get it wet it basically shows EVERY DETAIL of your nipples. it just has a metal hook in the back, and since the material is satin and slippery it just pops right off the hook with not effort at all. my boobs have popped out 10 times and i’ve only wore it twice. then the ruched part in the front is not sewn, so the shoulder strap moves all over the place. i also bought the matching bottoms, which sag in the butt when they get wet.

  • The jeans fit pretty good! Better than most that I have purchased. I had an assumption that it would make my butt and legs look next level... which it didn't but it still fit nicer than most jeans!

    Feedback

    The price is steep but you get a quality pair of jeans that should last. They don't stretch out easily.

  • While they are my absolute go-to for jeans. I’m not sure why the mess around with so much other stuff. Their jeans are comfortable, stretchy, look great, come in tons of styles, etc…. But the other stuff is usually a miss.

    Feedback

    If they stuck stricktly to denim, their site would be MUCH cleaner and their quality would be much higher in my opinion.